Limited subject choice is bad news for history teaching

  • Neil McLennan

Press/Media: Teaching

Description

In 2012 I first raised issues of the poor coverage of Scottish history. For a start, the first chronological qualification course option starts in 1286. There is a real danger that pupils will believe Scottish history began with Alexander III’s death in a riding accident and the subsequent conflict with southern neighbours. Pupils must be exposed to Scottish history long before 1286. Where can students learn that Scotland originally was a nation of many different peoples?

What follows in history qualifications is a “tartan shortbread tin” whirlwind tour though Scottish history (including Robert the Bruce), just missing Brigadoon along the way.

Period14 May 2019 → 16 May 2019

Media coverage

3

Media coverage

  • TitleHistory didn't start in 1286
    Media name/outletPress and Journal
    Country/TerritoryUnited Kingdom
    Date16/05/19
    PersonsNeil McLennan
  • TitleLimited subject choice is bad news for the teaching of history
    Media name/outletThe National
    Country/TerritoryUnited Kingdom
    Date15/05/19
    PersonsNeil McLennan
  • TitleRobert the Who? Young Scots' history holes
    Media name/outletThe Times
    Country/TerritoryUnited Kingdom
    Date14/05/19
    DescriptionHalf of young Scots do not know that William Wallace and Robert the Bruce defeated the English during the wars of independence, a survey suggests.

    One in six people aged 16-24 said that they had not learnt any Scottish history at school. About 60 per cent said that they learnt about Scottish history from television.
    URLhttps://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/robert-the-who-young-scots-history-holes-bdz0tcxdm
    PersonsNeil McLennan

Media contributions

1

Media contributions

  • TitleLimited subject choice is bad news for history teaching
    Media name/outletThe National
    Country/TerritoryUnited Kingdom
    Date15/05/19
    DescriptionTHE headline showing issues with Scottish history learning highlights some old and new issues (This is why half of young Scots don’t know about Scottish history, thenational.scot, May 13). Whilst the survey scope is shallow, it is also revealing.
    URLhttps://www.thenational.scot/news/17639663.limited-subject-choice-bad-news-history-teaching/
    PersonsNeil McLennan