A comparison of performance on the Towers of London and Hanoi in young children

Rebecca Bull, K. A. Espy, T. E. Senn

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

91 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Background: The Towers of London (TOL) and Hanoi (TOH) have been viewed as equivalent measures of planning and/or problem solving, although recent evidence in adults suggests that the underlying measurement characteristics of these two tasks may differ. As tower tasks are one of the few instruments that can be used to assess executive functioning in young children, the cognitive demands for both tasks merit further examination. Methods: The relation among tower tasks and those of shortterm memory, inhibition, and shifting ability were examined in a sample of 118 typically developing young children (M age - 4 years, 9 months, SD = 6 months). Half the children completed TOL and half completed TOH, with groups matched with respect to age, sex, and child vocabulary. Results: Whilst performance on a shifting task uniquely predicted TOH performance, none of the executive function measures were related to TOL performance after statistically controlling for the influence of baseline naming speed. For both tower tasks, performance on a shifting task contributed more strongly on complex trials that required more moves in the counter-intuitive direction relative to the end-state goal, whereas inhibition task performance only predicted performance on complex TOL trials. Conclusions: Successful tower task performance may be determined, at least at higher levels of complexity, by mental flexibility in this age range. However, overall the findings suggest that TOL and TOH are not interchangeable tasks even in young children, and more generally, raise methodological issues regarding the complex nature of executive function tasks.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)743-754
Number of pages11
JournalJournal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry
Volume45
Issue number4
Early online date30 Mar 2004
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - May 2004

Keywords

  • executive functions
  • inhibition
  • shifting
  • short-term memory
  • tower tasks
  • children
  • learning-disabled readers
  • executive function tasks
  • traumatic brain-injury
  • working-memory
  • frontal-lobe
  • preschool-children
  • individual-differences
  • porteus maze
  • system
  • intelligence

Cite this

A comparison of performance on the Towers of London and Hanoi in young children. / Bull, Rebecca; Espy, K. A.; Senn, T. E.

In: Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, Vol. 45, No. 4, 05.2004, p. 743-754.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Bull, Rebecca ; Espy, K. A. ; Senn, T. E. / A comparison of performance on the Towers of London and Hanoi in young children. In: Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry. 2004 ; Vol. 45, No. 4. pp. 743-754.
@article{78d41c06be2742dfa22c44f6d10cce40,
title = "A comparison of performance on the Towers of London and Hanoi in young children",
abstract = "Background: The Towers of London (TOL) and Hanoi (TOH) have been viewed as equivalent measures of planning and/or problem solving, although recent evidence in adults suggests that the underlying measurement characteristics of these two tasks may differ. As tower tasks are one of the few instruments that can be used to assess executive functioning in young children, the cognitive demands for both tasks merit further examination. Methods: The relation among tower tasks and those of shortterm memory, inhibition, and shifting ability were examined in a sample of 118 typically developing young children (M age - 4 years, 9 months, SD = 6 months). Half the children completed TOL and half completed TOH, with groups matched with respect to age, sex, and child vocabulary. Results: Whilst performance on a shifting task uniquely predicted TOH performance, none of the executive function measures were related to TOL performance after statistically controlling for the influence of baseline naming speed. For both tower tasks, performance on a shifting task contributed more strongly on complex trials that required more moves in the counter-intuitive direction relative to the end-state goal, whereas inhibition task performance only predicted performance on complex TOL trials. Conclusions: Successful tower task performance may be determined, at least at higher levels of complexity, by mental flexibility in this age range. However, overall the findings suggest that TOL and TOH are not interchangeable tasks even in young children, and more generally, raise methodological issues regarding the complex nature of executive function tasks.",
keywords = "executive functions, inhibition, shifting, short-term memory, tower tasks, children, learning-disabled readers, executive function tasks, traumatic brain-injury, working-memory, frontal-lobe, preschool-children, individual-differences, porteus maze, system, intelligence",
author = "Rebecca Bull and Espy, {K. A.} and Senn, {T. E.}",
year = "2004",
month = "5",
doi = "10.1111/j.1469-7610.2004.00268.x",
language = "English",
volume = "45",
pages = "743--754",
journal = "Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry",
issn = "0021-9630",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",
number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - A comparison of performance on the Towers of London and Hanoi in young children

AU - Bull, Rebecca

AU - Espy, K. A.

AU - Senn, T. E.

PY - 2004/5

Y1 - 2004/5

N2 - Background: The Towers of London (TOL) and Hanoi (TOH) have been viewed as equivalent measures of planning and/or problem solving, although recent evidence in adults suggests that the underlying measurement characteristics of these two tasks may differ. As tower tasks are one of the few instruments that can be used to assess executive functioning in young children, the cognitive demands for both tasks merit further examination. Methods: The relation among tower tasks and those of shortterm memory, inhibition, and shifting ability were examined in a sample of 118 typically developing young children (M age - 4 years, 9 months, SD = 6 months). Half the children completed TOL and half completed TOH, with groups matched with respect to age, sex, and child vocabulary. Results: Whilst performance on a shifting task uniquely predicted TOH performance, none of the executive function measures were related to TOL performance after statistically controlling for the influence of baseline naming speed. For both tower tasks, performance on a shifting task contributed more strongly on complex trials that required more moves in the counter-intuitive direction relative to the end-state goal, whereas inhibition task performance only predicted performance on complex TOL trials. Conclusions: Successful tower task performance may be determined, at least at higher levels of complexity, by mental flexibility in this age range. However, overall the findings suggest that TOL and TOH are not interchangeable tasks even in young children, and more generally, raise methodological issues regarding the complex nature of executive function tasks.

AB - Background: The Towers of London (TOL) and Hanoi (TOH) have been viewed as equivalent measures of planning and/or problem solving, although recent evidence in adults suggests that the underlying measurement characteristics of these two tasks may differ. As tower tasks are one of the few instruments that can be used to assess executive functioning in young children, the cognitive demands for both tasks merit further examination. Methods: The relation among tower tasks and those of shortterm memory, inhibition, and shifting ability were examined in a sample of 118 typically developing young children (M age - 4 years, 9 months, SD = 6 months). Half the children completed TOL and half completed TOH, with groups matched with respect to age, sex, and child vocabulary. Results: Whilst performance on a shifting task uniquely predicted TOH performance, none of the executive function measures were related to TOL performance after statistically controlling for the influence of baseline naming speed. For both tower tasks, performance on a shifting task contributed more strongly on complex trials that required more moves in the counter-intuitive direction relative to the end-state goal, whereas inhibition task performance only predicted performance on complex TOL trials. Conclusions: Successful tower task performance may be determined, at least at higher levels of complexity, by mental flexibility in this age range. However, overall the findings suggest that TOL and TOH are not interchangeable tasks even in young children, and more generally, raise methodological issues regarding the complex nature of executive function tasks.

KW - executive functions

KW - inhibition

KW - shifting

KW - short-term memory

KW - tower tasks

KW - children

KW - learning-disabled readers

KW - executive function tasks

KW - traumatic brain-injury

KW - working-memory

KW - frontal-lobe

KW - preschool-children

KW - individual-differences

KW - porteus maze

KW - system

KW - intelligence

U2 - 10.1111/j.1469-7610.2004.00268.x

DO - 10.1111/j.1469-7610.2004.00268.x

M3 - Article

VL - 45

SP - 743

EP - 754

JO - Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry

JF - Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry

SN - 0021-9630

IS - 4

ER -