A pilot randomised controlled trial of brief versus twice weekly versus standard supervised consumption in patients on opiate maintenance treatment

Richard Holland, Catriona Isobel Matheson, Geraldine B. Anthony, Kennedy Roberts, Saket Priyardarshi, Ann MacRae, Eddie Whitelaw, Sivaram Appavoo, Christine Margaret Bond

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

7 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Introduction and Aims.Methadone maintenance remains the mainstay of treatment for opiate dependence in Scotland. Guidelines recommend supervised self-administration for at least 3 months, yet this is often interpreted as long-term supervision. However, there is no evidence base for deciding the optimal period of supervision. We tested the feasibility of conducting a randomised controlled trial (RCT) of different supervision models.

Design and Methods.Three armed pilot RCT, set in three Scottish treatment areas, recruited opiate-dependent patients who had received methadone treatment for 3 months. Participants were randomised to: (i) no supervision; (ii) twice weekly supervision; or (iii) daily supervision for further 3 months. As a pilot, key process measures were: recruitment rates, follow-up rates and treatment fidelity. We also wanted to estimate effect sizes of two co-primary outcomes for a full RCT: treatment retention and illicit heroin use. The recruitment target was 60 participants.

Results.One hundred and two eligible patients were identified, 60 (59%) participated, and 46 followed up (77%). Study fidelity was good with two participants moving group. Those randomised to no supervision were significantly happier with their group allocation. No significant differences were found in primary outcomes, although retention decreased with increased supervision, while illicit heroin use was least in those most supervised.

Discussion and Conclusions.It is possible to recruit and randomise participants to an RCT comparing different forms of supervised consumption. Pilot data suggest increased supervision may reduce illicit heroin use, but may decrease retention. This should now be tested in a large-scale multicentre RCT.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)483-491
Number of pages9
JournalDrug and Alcohol Review
Volume31
Issue number4
Early online date12 Dec 2011
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jun 2012

Fingerprint

Opiate Alkaloids
supervision
Randomized Controlled Trials
Heroin
Therapeutics
Methadone
Opioid-Related Disorders
self-administration
Process Assessment (Health Care)
Self Administration
Scotland

Keywords

  • adherence
  • opiate maintenance treatment
  • RCT
  • supervised consumption

Cite this

A pilot randomised controlled trial of brief versus twice weekly versus standard supervised consumption in patients on opiate maintenance treatment. / Holland, Richard; Matheson, Catriona Isobel; Anthony, Geraldine B.; Roberts, Kennedy; Priyardarshi, Saket; MacRae, Ann; Whitelaw, Eddie; Appavoo, Sivaram; Bond, Christine Margaret.

In: Drug and Alcohol Review, Vol. 31, No. 4, 06.2012, p. 483-491.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Holland, Richard ; Matheson, Catriona Isobel ; Anthony, Geraldine B. ; Roberts, Kennedy ; Priyardarshi, Saket ; MacRae, Ann ; Whitelaw, Eddie ; Appavoo, Sivaram ; Bond, Christine Margaret. / A pilot randomised controlled trial of brief versus twice weekly versus standard supervised consumption in patients on opiate maintenance treatment. In: Drug and Alcohol Review. 2012 ; Vol. 31, No. 4. pp. 483-491.
@article{89346109f55b44f1a9bea6ead327d7e5,
title = "A pilot randomised controlled trial of brief versus twice weekly versus standard supervised consumption in patients on opiate maintenance treatment",
abstract = "Introduction and Aims.Methadone maintenance remains the mainstay of treatment for opiate dependence in Scotland. Guidelines recommend supervised self-administration for at least 3 months, yet this is often interpreted as long-term supervision. However, there is no evidence base for deciding the optimal period of supervision. We tested the feasibility of conducting a randomised controlled trial (RCT) of different supervision models. Design and Methods.Three armed pilot RCT, set in three Scottish treatment areas, recruited opiate-dependent patients who had received methadone treatment for 3 months. Participants were randomised to: (i) no supervision; (ii) twice weekly supervision; or (iii) daily supervision for further 3 months. As a pilot, key process measures were: recruitment rates, follow-up rates and treatment fidelity. We also wanted to estimate effect sizes of two co-primary outcomes for a full RCT: treatment retention and illicit heroin use. The recruitment target was 60 participants. Results.One hundred and two eligible patients were identified, 60 (59{\%}) participated, and 46 followed up (77{\%}). Study fidelity was good with two participants moving group. Those randomised to no supervision were significantly happier with their group allocation. No significant differences were found in primary outcomes, although retention decreased with increased supervision, while illicit heroin use was least in those most supervised. Discussion and Conclusions.It is possible to recruit and randomise participants to an RCT comparing different forms of supervised consumption. Pilot data suggest increased supervision may reduce illicit heroin use, but may decrease retention. This should now be tested in a large-scale multicentre RCT.",
keywords = "adherence, opiate maintenance treatment, RCT, supervised consumption",
author = "Richard Holland and Matheson, {Catriona Isobel} and Anthony, {Geraldine B.} and Kennedy Roberts and Saket Priyardarshi and Ann MacRae and Eddie Whitelaw and Sivaram Appavoo and Bond, {Christine Margaret}",
year = "2012",
month = "6",
doi = "10.1111/j.1465-3362.2011.00394.x",
language = "English",
volume = "31",
pages = "483--491",
journal = "Drug and Alcohol Review",
issn = "0959-5236",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",
number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - A pilot randomised controlled trial of brief versus twice weekly versus standard supervised consumption in patients on opiate maintenance treatment

AU - Holland, Richard

AU - Matheson, Catriona Isobel

AU - Anthony, Geraldine B.

AU - Roberts, Kennedy

AU - Priyardarshi, Saket

AU - MacRae, Ann

AU - Whitelaw, Eddie

AU - Appavoo, Sivaram

AU - Bond, Christine Margaret

PY - 2012/6

Y1 - 2012/6

N2 - Introduction and Aims.Methadone maintenance remains the mainstay of treatment for opiate dependence in Scotland. Guidelines recommend supervised self-administration for at least 3 months, yet this is often interpreted as long-term supervision. However, there is no evidence base for deciding the optimal period of supervision. We tested the feasibility of conducting a randomised controlled trial (RCT) of different supervision models. Design and Methods.Three armed pilot RCT, set in three Scottish treatment areas, recruited opiate-dependent patients who had received methadone treatment for 3 months. Participants were randomised to: (i) no supervision; (ii) twice weekly supervision; or (iii) daily supervision for further 3 months. As a pilot, key process measures were: recruitment rates, follow-up rates and treatment fidelity. We also wanted to estimate effect sizes of two co-primary outcomes for a full RCT: treatment retention and illicit heroin use. The recruitment target was 60 participants. Results.One hundred and two eligible patients were identified, 60 (59%) participated, and 46 followed up (77%). Study fidelity was good with two participants moving group. Those randomised to no supervision were significantly happier with their group allocation. No significant differences were found in primary outcomes, although retention decreased with increased supervision, while illicit heroin use was least in those most supervised. Discussion and Conclusions.It is possible to recruit and randomise participants to an RCT comparing different forms of supervised consumption. Pilot data suggest increased supervision may reduce illicit heroin use, but may decrease retention. This should now be tested in a large-scale multicentre RCT.

AB - Introduction and Aims.Methadone maintenance remains the mainstay of treatment for opiate dependence in Scotland. Guidelines recommend supervised self-administration for at least 3 months, yet this is often interpreted as long-term supervision. However, there is no evidence base for deciding the optimal period of supervision. We tested the feasibility of conducting a randomised controlled trial (RCT) of different supervision models. Design and Methods.Three armed pilot RCT, set in three Scottish treatment areas, recruited opiate-dependent patients who had received methadone treatment for 3 months. Participants were randomised to: (i) no supervision; (ii) twice weekly supervision; or (iii) daily supervision for further 3 months. As a pilot, key process measures were: recruitment rates, follow-up rates and treatment fidelity. We also wanted to estimate effect sizes of two co-primary outcomes for a full RCT: treatment retention and illicit heroin use. The recruitment target was 60 participants. Results.One hundred and two eligible patients were identified, 60 (59%) participated, and 46 followed up (77%). Study fidelity was good with two participants moving group. Those randomised to no supervision were significantly happier with their group allocation. No significant differences were found in primary outcomes, although retention decreased with increased supervision, while illicit heroin use was least in those most supervised. Discussion and Conclusions.It is possible to recruit and randomise participants to an RCT comparing different forms of supervised consumption. Pilot data suggest increased supervision may reduce illicit heroin use, but may decrease retention. This should now be tested in a large-scale multicentre RCT.

KW - adherence

KW - opiate maintenance treatment

KW - RCT

KW - supervised consumption

U2 - 10.1111/j.1465-3362.2011.00394.x

DO - 10.1111/j.1465-3362.2011.00394.x

M3 - Article

VL - 31

SP - 483

EP - 491

JO - Drug and Alcohol Review

JF - Drug and Alcohol Review

SN - 0959-5236

IS - 4

ER -