A qualitative assessment of students' experiences of studying music: a Spanish perspective on the European credit transfer system (ECTS)

José María Esteve Faubel, Miguel Ángel Molina Valero, Jonathan Stephens

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

2 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The purpose of this investigation is to evaluate whether or not the allocation of time proposed in the Music Study Guide, adapted from the Espacio Europeo de Educacion Superior (European Higher Education Area) guidelines, is consistent and adequate for students with a minimal musical knowledge.

The data for this study arise from a self-administered questionnaire completed during the academic year 2005-2006 by first, second and third-year students of the primary education with music specialism degree at Alicante University. Third-year students studying for the equivalent degree at the Autonomous University of Madrid acted as a control group. The report acknowledges variables related to the students' previous knowledge and considers the relationship of these variables to the time and effort required by students to complete their musical studies.

Qualitative methodology has been employed in considering the data as a means of providing in-depth analysis of the student experience. The study of students' stories and experiences provides an opportunity to understand their own perspectives, strengths and weaknesses. The questions were categorised by the researchers and subsequently assigned codes for analysis. The results show that: students' previous academic knowledge influences their quantification of time and effort and determines their overall performance; the teaching guide is coherent with the demands of university studies and the labour market; and difficulties in the acquisition of certain competences are evident only in those students who come to university without any musical experience.

This last point underlines the need to provide curricular reinforcement or 'level zero' courses to support students in their musical studies.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)241-265
Number of pages25
JournalMusic Education Research
Volume11
Issue number2
Early online date26 May 2009
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jun 2009

Keywords

  • music teacher training
  • generalist/specialist music teacher training
  • ECTS

Cite this

A qualitative assessment of students' experiences of studying music : a Spanish perspective on the European credit transfer system (ECTS). / Faubel, José María Esteve; Valero, Miguel Ángel Molina; Stephens, Jonathan.

In: Music Education Research, Vol. 11, No. 2, 06.2009, p. 241-265.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Faubel, José María Esteve ; Valero, Miguel Ángel Molina ; Stephens, Jonathan. / A qualitative assessment of students' experiences of studying music : a Spanish perspective on the European credit transfer system (ECTS). In: Music Education Research. 2009 ; Vol. 11, No. 2. pp. 241-265.
@article{1f735b639ae447aa82ebd478a3a11dff,
title = "A qualitative assessment of students' experiences of studying music: a Spanish perspective on the European credit transfer system (ECTS)",
abstract = "The purpose of this investigation is to evaluate whether or not the allocation of time proposed in the Music Study Guide, adapted from the Espacio Europeo de Educacion Superior (European Higher Education Area) guidelines, is consistent and adequate for students with a minimal musical knowledge. The data for this study arise from a self-administered questionnaire completed during the academic year 2005-2006 by first, second and third-year students of the primary education with music specialism degree at Alicante University. Third-year students studying for the equivalent degree at the Autonomous University of Madrid acted as a control group. The report acknowledges variables related to the students' previous knowledge and considers the relationship of these variables to the time and effort required by students to complete their musical studies. Qualitative methodology has been employed in considering the data as a means of providing in-depth analysis of the student experience. The study of students' stories and experiences provides an opportunity to understand their own perspectives, strengths and weaknesses. The questions were categorised by the researchers and subsequently assigned codes for analysis. The results show that: students' previous academic knowledge influences their quantification of time and effort and determines their overall performance; the teaching guide is coherent with the demands of university studies and the labour market; and difficulties in the acquisition of certain competences are evident only in those students who come to university without any musical experience. This last point underlines the need to provide curricular reinforcement or 'level zero' courses to support students in their musical studies.",
keywords = "music teacher training, generalist/specialist music teacher training, ECTS",
author = "Faubel, {Jos{\'e} Mar{\'i}a Esteve} and Valero, {Miguel {\'A}ngel Molina} and Jonathan Stephens",
year = "2009",
month = "6",
doi = "10.1080/14613800902924516",
language = "English",
volume = "11",
pages = "241--265",
journal = "Music Education Research",
issn = "1461-3808",
publisher = "Routledge",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - A qualitative assessment of students' experiences of studying music

T2 - a Spanish perspective on the European credit transfer system (ECTS)

AU - Faubel, José María Esteve

AU - Valero, Miguel Ángel Molina

AU - Stephens, Jonathan

PY - 2009/6

Y1 - 2009/6

N2 - The purpose of this investigation is to evaluate whether or not the allocation of time proposed in the Music Study Guide, adapted from the Espacio Europeo de Educacion Superior (European Higher Education Area) guidelines, is consistent and adequate for students with a minimal musical knowledge. The data for this study arise from a self-administered questionnaire completed during the academic year 2005-2006 by first, second and third-year students of the primary education with music specialism degree at Alicante University. Third-year students studying for the equivalent degree at the Autonomous University of Madrid acted as a control group. The report acknowledges variables related to the students' previous knowledge and considers the relationship of these variables to the time and effort required by students to complete their musical studies. Qualitative methodology has been employed in considering the data as a means of providing in-depth analysis of the student experience. The study of students' stories and experiences provides an opportunity to understand their own perspectives, strengths and weaknesses. The questions were categorised by the researchers and subsequently assigned codes for analysis. The results show that: students' previous academic knowledge influences their quantification of time and effort and determines their overall performance; the teaching guide is coherent with the demands of university studies and the labour market; and difficulties in the acquisition of certain competences are evident only in those students who come to university without any musical experience. This last point underlines the need to provide curricular reinforcement or 'level zero' courses to support students in their musical studies.

AB - The purpose of this investigation is to evaluate whether or not the allocation of time proposed in the Music Study Guide, adapted from the Espacio Europeo de Educacion Superior (European Higher Education Area) guidelines, is consistent and adequate for students with a minimal musical knowledge. The data for this study arise from a self-administered questionnaire completed during the academic year 2005-2006 by first, second and third-year students of the primary education with music specialism degree at Alicante University. Third-year students studying for the equivalent degree at the Autonomous University of Madrid acted as a control group. The report acknowledges variables related to the students' previous knowledge and considers the relationship of these variables to the time and effort required by students to complete their musical studies. Qualitative methodology has been employed in considering the data as a means of providing in-depth analysis of the student experience. The study of students' stories and experiences provides an opportunity to understand their own perspectives, strengths and weaknesses. The questions were categorised by the researchers and subsequently assigned codes for analysis. The results show that: students' previous academic knowledge influences their quantification of time and effort and determines their overall performance; the teaching guide is coherent with the demands of university studies and the labour market; and difficulties in the acquisition of certain competences are evident only in those students who come to university without any musical experience. This last point underlines the need to provide curricular reinforcement or 'level zero' courses to support students in their musical studies.

KW - music teacher training

KW - generalist/specialist music teacher training

KW - ECTS

U2 - 10.1080/14613800902924516

DO - 10.1080/14613800902924516

M3 - Article

VL - 11

SP - 241

EP - 265

JO - Music Education Research

JF - Music Education Research

SN - 1461-3808

IS - 2

ER -