A sketch is not enough: Dynamic external support increases creative insight on a guided synthesis task

David G. Pearson (Corresponding Author), Robert H. Logie

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

6 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Although external representations, such as sketches, are regarded as facilitating insight during creative synthesis and design tasks, previous empirical studies have provided conflicting evidence in support of this role. Here, we argue sketches are static representations that fail to fully externalise mental imagery processes involved during creative synthesis tasks. An experiment is reported in which participants manipulate simple alpha-numeric and geometric shapes into patterns depicting familiar objects or symbols. Trials were performed using either mental imagery alone, drawing manipulations in the air with a finger, sketching manipulations on a piece of paper, or dynamically performing the manipulations on-screen using a graphics package. Results show the number of patterns correctly interpreted as recognisable objects was significantly higher in the dynamic support condition in comparison to all other conditions. Based on this finding, we argue that static forms of external support may be less effective in supporting creative problem-solving than previously believed.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)97-112
Number of pages16
JournalThinking & Reasoning
Volume21
Issue number1
Early online date1 Apr 2014
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2015

Fingerprint

Imagery (Psychotherapy)
Mental Processes
Fingers
Air
Manipulation
Mental Imagery

Keywords

  • creativity
  • insight
  • external support
  • mental imagery
  • mental synthesis

Cite this

A sketch is not enough : Dynamic external support increases creative insight on a guided synthesis task. / Pearson, David G. (Corresponding Author); Logie, Robert H.

In: Thinking & Reasoning, Vol. 21, No. 1, 2015, p. 97-112.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{4e63da4ee6a146e996b82e67bda1445e,
title = "A sketch is not enough: Dynamic external support increases creative insight on a guided synthesis task",
abstract = "Although external representations, such as sketches, are regarded as facilitating insight during creative synthesis and design tasks, previous empirical studies have provided conflicting evidence in support of this role. Here, we argue sketches are static representations that fail to fully externalise mental imagery processes involved during creative synthesis tasks. An experiment is reported in which participants manipulate simple alpha-numeric and geometric shapes into patterns depicting familiar objects or symbols. Trials were performed using either mental imagery alone, drawing manipulations in the air with a finger, sketching manipulations on a piece of paper, or dynamically performing the manipulations on-screen using a graphics package. Results show the number of patterns correctly interpreted as recognisable objects was significantly higher in the dynamic support condition in comparison to all other conditions. Based on this finding, we argue that static forms of external support may be less effective in supporting creative problem-solving than previously believed.",
keywords = "creativity , insight, external support, mental imagery, mental synthesis",
author = "Pearson, {David G.} and Logie, {Robert H.}",
year = "2015",
doi = "10.1080/13546783.2014.897255",
language = "English",
volume = "21",
pages = "97--112",
journal = "Thinking & Reasoning",
issn = "1354-6783",
publisher = "Psychology Press Ltd",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - A sketch is not enough

T2 - Dynamic external support increases creative insight on a guided synthesis task

AU - Pearson, David G.

AU - Logie, Robert H.

PY - 2015

Y1 - 2015

N2 - Although external representations, such as sketches, are regarded as facilitating insight during creative synthesis and design tasks, previous empirical studies have provided conflicting evidence in support of this role. Here, we argue sketches are static representations that fail to fully externalise mental imagery processes involved during creative synthesis tasks. An experiment is reported in which participants manipulate simple alpha-numeric and geometric shapes into patterns depicting familiar objects or symbols. Trials were performed using either mental imagery alone, drawing manipulations in the air with a finger, sketching manipulations on a piece of paper, or dynamically performing the manipulations on-screen using a graphics package. Results show the number of patterns correctly interpreted as recognisable objects was significantly higher in the dynamic support condition in comparison to all other conditions. Based on this finding, we argue that static forms of external support may be less effective in supporting creative problem-solving than previously believed.

AB - Although external representations, such as sketches, are regarded as facilitating insight during creative synthesis and design tasks, previous empirical studies have provided conflicting evidence in support of this role. Here, we argue sketches are static representations that fail to fully externalise mental imagery processes involved during creative synthesis tasks. An experiment is reported in which participants manipulate simple alpha-numeric and geometric shapes into patterns depicting familiar objects or symbols. Trials were performed using either mental imagery alone, drawing manipulations in the air with a finger, sketching manipulations on a piece of paper, or dynamically performing the manipulations on-screen using a graphics package. Results show the number of patterns correctly interpreted as recognisable objects was significantly higher in the dynamic support condition in comparison to all other conditions. Based on this finding, we argue that static forms of external support may be less effective in supporting creative problem-solving than previously believed.

KW - creativity

KW - insight

KW - external support

KW - mental imagery

KW - mental synthesis

U2 - 10.1080/13546783.2014.897255

DO - 10.1080/13546783.2014.897255

M3 - Article

VL - 21

SP - 97

EP - 112

JO - Thinking & Reasoning

JF - Thinking & Reasoning

SN - 1354-6783

IS - 1

ER -