A systematic review of electronic multi-compartment medication devices with reminder systems for improving adherence to self-administered medications

Mary Paterson, Moira Kinnear, Christine Bond, Brian McKinstry

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

18 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

BACKGROUND: Many patients experience difficulties adhering to medication regimes. For people who forget or get confused about medication, there are products to help them such as multi-compartment medication devices (MMDs). Some of these, known as electronic MMDs (eMMDs), use audible and/or visual signals to prompt the patient when to take medication, dispense medications, give instructions to the patient, and contact a caregiver (mobile Internet or text to a carer) as needed.

AIM: To systematically review the literature on the use of eMMDs, to determine what evidence for their effectiveness is available.

METHODS: A comprehensive literature search of 10 databases, plus an Internet search and hand searching was conducted, using the MeSH terms reminder systems/patient compliance/medication adherence. There were no date restrictions. Inclusion criteria were patients in any community setting, in any country and with no restrictions of age, gender, ethnicity or medical condition, using an eMMD. Peer-reviewed quantitative or qualitative studies of any design were included.

RESULTS: Of 805 abstracts identified and 99 full text papers retrieved, six met the inclusion criteria. Five of the studies reported adherence to medication regimes; one reported design factors to improve adherence. Adherence varied by the context of the reminders, the target group and usability of the devices. The studies were small scale and only one was a well conducted randomised controlled trial.

CONCLUSION: Overall methodological quality of the studies was poor. Although positive effects on adherence were reported further, rigorously conducted, studies are needed to inform the use of eMMDs.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)185-194
Number of pages10
JournalInternational Journal of Pharmacy Practice
Volume25
Issue number3
Early online date1 Feb 2016
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jun 2017

Fingerprint

Reminder Systems
Internet
Equipment and Supplies
Medication Adherence
Caregivers
Patient Compliance
Randomized Controlled Trials
Databases

Keywords

  • medication device
  • patient adherence
  • reminder systems

Cite this

A systematic review of electronic multi-compartment medication devices with reminder systems for improving adherence to self-administered medications. / Paterson, Mary; Kinnear, Moira; Bond, Christine; McKinstry, Brian.

In: International Journal of Pharmacy Practice, Vol. 25, No. 3, 06.2017, p. 185-194.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{b3c66e21df7845a4bcc83feda656a1bc,
title = "A systematic review of electronic multi-compartment medication devices with reminder systems for improving adherence to self-administered medications",
abstract = "BACKGROUND: Many patients experience difficulties adhering to medication regimes. For people who forget or get confused about medication, there are products to help them such as multi-compartment medication devices (MMDs). Some of these, known as electronic MMDs (eMMDs), use audible and/or visual signals to prompt the patient when to take medication, dispense medications, give instructions to the patient, and contact a caregiver (mobile Internet or text to a carer) as needed.AIM: To systematically review the literature on the use of eMMDs, to determine what evidence for their effectiveness is available.METHODS: A comprehensive literature search of 10 databases, plus an Internet search and hand searching was conducted, using the MeSH terms reminder systems/patient compliance/medication adherence. There were no date restrictions. Inclusion criteria were patients in any community setting, in any country and with no restrictions of age, gender, ethnicity or medical condition, using an eMMD. Peer-reviewed quantitative or qualitative studies of any design were included.RESULTS: Of 805 abstracts identified and 99 full text papers retrieved, six met the inclusion criteria. Five of the studies reported adherence to medication regimes; one reported design factors to improve adherence. Adherence varied by the context of the reminders, the target group and usability of the devices. The studies were small scale and only one was a well conducted randomised controlled trial.CONCLUSION: Overall methodological quality of the studies was poor. Although positive effects on adherence were reported further, rigorously conducted, studies are needed to inform the use of eMMDs.",
keywords = "medication device, patient adherence, reminder systems",
author = "Mary Paterson and Moira Kinnear and Christine Bond and Brian McKinstry",
note = "Funding The study was supported by the Chief Scientist Office [grant number CZH/4/968]. Acknowledgements We are grateful for the support of Lucy McCloughan as programme manager for eHealth research.",
year = "2017",
month = "6",
doi = "10.1111/ijpp.12242",
language = "English",
volume = "25",
pages = "185--194",
journal = "International Journal of Pharmacy Practice",
issn = "0961-7671",
publisher = "John Wiley & Sons, Ltd (10.1111)",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - A systematic review of electronic multi-compartment medication devices with reminder systems for improving adherence to self-administered medications

AU - Paterson, Mary

AU - Kinnear, Moira

AU - Bond, Christine

AU - McKinstry, Brian

N1 - Funding The study was supported by the Chief Scientist Office [grant number CZH/4/968]. Acknowledgements We are grateful for the support of Lucy McCloughan as programme manager for eHealth research.

PY - 2017/6

Y1 - 2017/6

N2 - BACKGROUND: Many patients experience difficulties adhering to medication regimes. For people who forget or get confused about medication, there are products to help them such as multi-compartment medication devices (MMDs). Some of these, known as electronic MMDs (eMMDs), use audible and/or visual signals to prompt the patient when to take medication, dispense medications, give instructions to the patient, and contact a caregiver (mobile Internet or text to a carer) as needed.AIM: To systematically review the literature on the use of eMMDs, to determine what evidence for their effectiveness is available.METHODS: A comprehensive literature search of 10 databases, plus an Internet search and hand searching was conducted, using the MeSH terms reminder systems/patient compliance/medication adherence. There were no date restrictions. Inclusion criteria were patients in any community setting, in any country and with no restrictions of age, gender, ethnicity or medical condition, using an eMMD. Peer-reviewed quantitative or qualitative studies of any design were included.RESULTS: Of 805 abstracts identified and 99 full text papers retrieved, six met the inclusion criteria. Five of the studies reported adherence to medication regimes; one reported design factors to improve adherence. Adherence varied by the context of the reminders, the target group and usability of the devices. The studies were small scale and only one was a well conducted randomised controlled trial.CONCLUSION: Overall methodological quality of the studies was poor. Although positive effects on adherence were reported further, rigorously conducted, studies are needed to inform the use of eMMDs.

AB - BACKGROUND: Many patients experience difficulties adhering to medication regimes. For people who forget or get confused about medication, there are products to help them such as multi-compartment medication devices (MMDs). Some of these, known as electronic MMDs (eMMDs), use audible and/or visual signals to prompt the patient when to take medication, dispense medications, give instructions to the patient, and contact a caregiver (mobile Internet or text to a carer) as needed.AIM: To systematically review the literature on the use of eMMDs, to determine what evidence for their effectiveness is available.METHODS: A comprehensive literature search of 10 databases, plus an Internet search and hand searching was conducted, using the MeSH terms reminder systems/patient compliance/medication adherence. There were no date restrictions. Inclusion criteria were patients in any community setting, in any country and with no restrictions of age, gender, ethnicity or medical condition, using an eMMD. Peer-reviewed quantitative or qualitative studies of any design were included.RESULTS: Of 805 abstracts identified and 99 full text papers retrieved, six met the inclusion criteria. Five of the studies reported adherence to medication regimes; one reported design factors to improve adherence. Adherence varied by the context of the reminders, the target group and usability of the devices. The studies were small scale and only one was a well conducted randomised controlled trial.CONCLUSION: Overall methodological quality of the studies was poor. Although positive effects on adherence were reported further, rigorously conducted, studies are needed to inform the use of eMMDs.

KW - medication device

KW - patient adherence

KW - reminder systems

U2 - 10.1111/ijpp.12242

DO - 10.1111/ijpp.12242

M3 - Article

C2 - 26833669

VL - 25

SP - 185

EP - 194

JO - International Journal of Pharmacy Practice

JF - International Journal of Pharmacy Practice

SN - 0961-7671

IS - 3

ER -