After the rainbow nation: Jacob Zuma, charismatic leadership and national identities in Post-Polokwane South Africa

Natascha Mueller-Hirth

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

Abstract

This paper argues that Jacob Zuma’s rise to power marks the mobilisation of a new discourse of nationalism in Post-Apartheid South Africa, after what appears to be the ultimately failed project of the rainbow nation. This is performed in juxtaposition to Zuma’s predecessor Thabo Mbeki who was frequently cast as a distant, elitist and technocratic leader. It is argued that binary oppositions such as populist/ elitist or military/ diplomat enabled a powerful message of change to be produced, for instance with regards to the supposed shit to the left in the Government’s economic policy framework. Subsequently, the paper draws out the connections between the ‘Zumafication’ of left politics in South Africa – a populist rhetoric with little commitment to a substantial pro-poor policy – and the understandings of national identity and nationalism it mobilises. For instance, the portrayal as ‘man of the struggle’ exemplified by Zuma’s famous trademark song ‘Bring me my machine gun’, evokes the liberation struggle as an important narrative in Post-Apartheid nation-building, in part responding to a sense of betrayal felt by the majority population. But Zuma’s displays of a militant, masculinist nationalism arguably also produce versions of national identity that are deeply gendered, and in their insistence on ‘100 percent Zulu’ identity potentially divisive.
Original languageEnglish
Publication statusPublished - 2010
Event20th Annual ASEN Conference - Nation and Charisma - London, United Kingdom
Duration: 13 Apr 201015 Apr 2010

Conference

Conference20th Annual ASEN Conference - Nation and Charisma
CountryUnited Kingdom
CityLondon
Period13/04/1015/04/10

Fingerprint

national identity
nationalism
leadership
apartheid
trademark
diplomat
state formation
liberation
Economic Policy
song
mobilization
rhetoric
opposition
Military
commitment
leader
narrative
politics
discourse

Cite this

Mueller-Hirth, N. (2010). After the rainbow nation: Jacob Zuma, charismatic leadership and national identities in Post-Polokwane South Africa. Paper presented at 20th Annual ASEN Conference - Nation and Charisma , London, United Kingdom.

After the rainbow nation : Jacob Zuma, charismatic leadership and national identities in Post-Polokwane South Africa. / Mueller-Hirth, Natascha.

2010. Paper presented at 20th Annual ASEN Conference - Nation and Charisma , London, United Kingdom.

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

Mueller-Hirth, N 2010, 'After the rainbow nation: Jacob Zuma, charismatic leadership and national identities in Post-Polokwane South Africa' Paper presented at 20th Annual ASEN Conference - Nation and Charisma , London, United Kingdom, 13/04/10 - 15/04/10, .
Mueller-Hirth N. After the rainbow nation: Jacob Zuma, charismatic leadership and national identities in Post-Polokwane South Africa. 2010. Paper presented at 20th Annual ASEN Conference - Nation and Charisma , London, United Kingdom.
Mueller-Hirth, Natascha. / After the rainbow nation : Jacob Zuma, charismatic leadership and national identities in Post-Polokwane South Africa. Paper presented at 20th Annual ASEN Conference - Nation and Charisma , London, United Kingdom.
@conference{7ccbbe79b34949518a24149573e73e48,
title = "After the rainbow nation: Jacob Zuma, charismatic leadership and national identities in Post-Polokwane South Africa",
abstract = "This paper argues that Jacob Zuma’s rise to power marks the mobilisation of a new discourse of nationalism in Post-Apartheid South Africa, after what appears to be the ultimately failed project of the rainbow nation. This is performed in juxtaposition to Zuma’s predecessor Thabo Mbeki who was frequently cast as a distant, elitist and technocratic leader. It is argued that binary oppositions such as populist/ elitist or military/ diplomat enabled a powerful message of change to be produced, for instance with regards to the supposed shit to the left in the Government’s economic policy framework. Subsequently, the paper draws out the connections between the ‘Zumafication’ of left politics in South Africa – a populist rhetoric with little commitment to a substantial pro-poor policy – and the understandings of national identity and nationalism it mobilises. For instance, the portrayal as ‘man of the struggle’ exemplified by Zuma’s famous trademark song ‘Bring me my machine gun’, evokes the liberation struggle as an important narrative in Post-Apartheid nation-building, in part responding to a sense of betrayal felt by the majority population. But Zuma’s displays of a militant, masculinist nationalism arguably also produce versions of national identity that are deeply gendered, and in their insistence on ‘100 percent Zulu’ identity potentially divisive.",
author = "Natascha Mueller-Hirth",
note = "Paper presented at 20th Annual ASEN Conference: Nation and Charisma, London, United Kingdom, April 2010; 20th Annual ASEN Conference - Nation and Charisma ; Conference date: 13-04-2010 Through 15-04-2010",
year = "2010",
language = "English",

}

TY - CONF

T1 - After the rainbow nation

T2 - Jacob Zuma, charismatic leadership and national identities in Post-Polokwane South Africa

AU - Mueller-Hirth, Natascha

N1 - Paper presented at 20th Annual ASEN Conference: Nation and Charisma, London, United Kingdom, April 2010

PY - 2010

Y1 - 2010

N2 - This paper argues that Jacob Zuma’s rise to power marks the mobilisation of a new discourse of nationalism in Post-Apartheid South Africa, after what appears to be the ultimately failed project of the rainbow nation. This is performed in juxtaposition to Zuma’s predecessor Thabo Mbeki who was frequently cast as a distant, elitist and technocratic leader. It is argued that binary oppositions such as populist/ elitist or military/ diplomat enabled a powerful message of change to be produced, for instance with regards to the supposed shit to the left in the Government’s economic policy framework. Subsequently, the paper draws out the connections between the ‘Zumafication’ of left politics in South Africa – a populist rhetoric with little commitment to a substantial pro-poor policy – and the understandings of national identity and nationalism it mobilises. For instance, the portrayal as ‘man of the struggle’ exemplified by Zuma’s famous trademark song ‘Bring me my machine gun’, evokes the liberation struggle as an important narrative in Post-Apartheid nation-building, in part responding to a sense of betrayal felt by the majority population. But Zuma’s displays of a militant, masculinist nationalism arguably also produce versions of national identity that are deeply gendered, and in their insistence on ‘100 percent Zulu’ identity potentially divisive.

AB - This paper argues that Jacob Zuma’s rise to power marks the mobilisation of a new discourse of nationalism in Post-Apartheid South Africa, after what appears to be the ultimately failed project of the rainbow nation. This is performed in juxtaposition to Zuma’s predecessor Thabo Mbeki who was frequently cast as a distant, elitist and technocratic leader. It is argued that binary oppositions such as populist/ elitist or military/ diplomat enabled a powerful message of change to be produced, for instance with regards to the supposed shit to the left in the Government’s economic policy framework. Subsequently, the paper draws out the connections between the ‘Zumafication’ of left politics in South Africa – a populist rhetoric with little commitment to a substantial pro-poor policy – and the understandings of national identity and nationalism it mobilises. For instance, the portrayal as ‘man of the struggle’ exemplified by Zuma’s famous trademark song ‘Bring me my machine gun’, evokes the liberation struggle as an important narrative in Post-Apartheid nation-building, in part responding to a sense of betrayal felt by the majority population. But Zuma’s displays of a militant, masculinist nationalism arguably also produce versions of national identity that are deeply gendered, and in their insistence on ‘100 percent Zulu’ identity potentially divisive.

M3 - Paper

ER -