Allometric relationships between seed mass and seedling characteristics reveal trade-offs for neotropical gap-dependent species

Matthew I. Daws, Christopher Ballard, Christopher E. Mullins, Nancy C. Garwood, Brian Murray, Timothy R. H. Pearson, David F. R. P. Burslem

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

28 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

A seed size-seed number trade-off exists because smaller seeds are produced in greater number but have a lower probability of establishment. This reduced establishment success of smaller-seeded species may be determined by biophysical constraints imposed by scaling rules. Root and shoot diameter, root growth extension rate (R-GER) and shoot length at death for dark-grown seedlings are predicted to scale with the cube root of seed embryo and endosperm mass (m). We confirmed this expectation for ten neotropical gap-dependent tree species with an embryo and endosperm dry mass >1 mg. However, for nine smaller seeded species (m < 1 mg) with photoblastic germination, root and shoot diameters were larger than expected, and consequently, R-GER was slower than expected. The maximum shoot thrust of seedlings from seeds with masses >= 1 mg was comparable to the estimated force required to displace overlying litter, supporting the hypothesis that photoblastic behaviour only occurs in seeds with insufficient shoot thrust to displace overlying leaves. Using the model soil water, energy and transpiration to predict soil drying in small and large gaps, we showed that: (1) gaps that receive a significant amount of direct sunlight will dry more quickly than small gaps that do not, (2) compared to the wet-season, soil that is already dry at depth (i.e. the dry-season) will dry faster after rainfall (this drying would most likely kill seedlings from small seeds) and (3) even during the wet-season, dry periods of a few days in large gaps can kill shallow-rooted seedlings. We conclude that the smaller the seed, the more vulnerable its seedling would be to both covering by litter and soil drying because it can only emerge from shallow depths and has a slow R-GER. Consequently, we suggest that these allometrically related factors contribute to the reduced establishment success of smaller-seeded species that underpins the seed size-seed number trade-off.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)445-454
Number of pages10
JournalOecologia
Volume154
Issue number3
Early online date11 Sep 2007
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Dec 2007

Keywords

  • allometric relationships
  • Barro Colorado Island
  • soil water availability
  • sweat
  • tropical forest
  • topographic position
  • soil-water
  • size
  • growth
  • establishment
  • germination
  • herbivory
  • Panama
  • model

Cite this

Allometric relationships between seed mass and seedling characteristics reveal trade-offs for neotropical gap-dependent species. / Daws, Matthew I.; Ballard, Christopher; Mullins, Christopher E.; Garwood, Nancy C.; Murray, Brian; Pearson, Timothy R. H.; Burslem, David F. R. P.

In: Oecologia, Vol. 154, No. 3, 12.2007, p. 445-454.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Daws, Matthew I. ; Ballard, Christopher ; Mullins, Christopher E. ; Garwood, Nancy C. ; Murray, Brian ; Pearson, Timothy R. H. ; Burslem, David F. R. P. / Allometric relationships between seed mass and seedling characteristics reveal trade-offs for neotropical gap-dependent species. In: Oecologia. 2007 ; Vol. 154, No. 3. pp. 445-454.
@article{29e7354482e840b4b7e776ac4ef3dd7b,
title = "Allometric relationships between seed mass and seedling characteristics reveal trade-offs for neotropical gap-dependent species",
abstract = "A seed size-seed number trade-off exists because smaller seeds are produced in greater number but have a lower probability of establishment. This reduced establishment success of smaller-seeded species may be determined by biophysical constraints imposed by scaling rules. Root and shoot diameter, root growth extension rate (R-GER) and shoot length at death for dark-grown seedlings are predicted to scale with the cube root of seed embryo and endosperm mass (m). We confirmed this expectation for ten neotropical gap-dependent tree species with an embryo and endosperm dry mass >1 mg. However, for nine smaller seeded species (m < 1 mg) with photoblastic germination, root and shoot diameters were larger than expected, and consequently, R-GER was slower than expected. The maximum shoot thrust of seedlings from seeds with masses >= 1 mg was comparable to the estimated force required to displace overlying litter, supporting the hypothesis that photoblastic behaviour only occurs in seeds with insufficient shoot thrust to displace overlying leaves. Using the model soil water, energy and transpiration to predict soil drying in small and large gaps, we showed that: (1) gaps that receive a significant amount of direct sunlight will dry more quickly than small gaps that do not, (2) compared to the wet-season, soil that is already dry at depth (i.e. the dry-season) will dry faster after rainfall (this drying would most likely kill seedlings from small seeds) and (3) even during the wet-season, dry periods of a few days in large gaps can kill shallow-rooted seedlings. We conclude that the smaller the seed, the more vulnerable its seedling would be to both covering by litter and soil drying because it can only emerge from shallow depths and has a slow R-GER. Consequently, we suggest that these allometrically related factors contribute to the reduced establishment success of smaller-seeded species that underpins the seed size-seed number trade-off.",
keywords = "allometric relationships, Barro Colorado Island, soil water availability, sweat, tropical forest, topographic position, soil-water, size, growth, establishment, germination, herbivory, Panama, model",
author = "Daws, {Matthew I.} and Christopher Ballard and Mullins, {Christopher E.} and Garwood, {Nancy C.} and Brian Murray and Pearson, {Timothy R. H.} and Burslem, {David F. R. P.}",
year = "2007",
month = "12",
doi = "10.1007/s00442-007-0848-2",
language = "English",
volume = "154",
pages = "445--454",
journal = "Oecologia",
issn = "0029-8549",
publisher = "Springer",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Allometric relationships between seed mass and seedling characteristics reveal trade-offs for neotropical gap-dependent species

AU - Daws, Matthew I.

AU - Ballard, Christopher

AU - Mullins, Christopher E.

AU - Garwood, Nancy C.

AU - Murray, Brian

AU - Pearson, Timothy R. H.

AU - Burslem, David F. R. P.

PY - 2007/12

Y1 - 2007/12

N2 - A seed size-seed number trade-off exists because smaller seeds are produced in greater number but have a lower probability of establishment. This reduced establishment success of smaller-seeded species may be determined by biophysical constraints imposed by scaling rules. Root and shoot diameter, root growth extension rate (R-GER) and shoot length at death for dark-grown seedlings are predicted to scale with the cube root of seed embryo and endosperm mass (m). We confirmed this expectation for ten neotropical gap-dependent tree species with an embryo and endosperm dry mass >1 mg. However, for nine smaller seeded species (m < 1 mg) with photoblastic germination, root and shoot diameters were larger than expected, and consequently, R-GER was slower than expected. The maximum shoot thrust of seedlings from seeds with masses >= 1 mg was comparable to the estimated force required to displace overlying litter, supporting the hypothesis that photoblastic behaviour only occurs in seeds with insufficient shoot thrust to displace overlying leaves. Using the model soil water, energy and transpiration to predict soil drying in small and large gaps, we showed that: (1) gaps that receive a significant amount of direct sunlight will dry more quickly than small gaps that do not, (2) compared to the wet-season, soil that is already dry at depth (i.e. the dry-season) will dry faster after rainfall (this drying would most likely kill seedlings from small seeds) and (3) even during the wet-season, dry periods of a few days in large gaps can kill shallow-rooted seedlings. We conclude that the smaller the seed, the more vulnerable its seedling would be to both covering by litter and soil drying because it can only emerge from shallow depths and has a slow R-GER. Consequently, we suggest that these allometrically related factors contribute to the reduced establishment success of smaller-seeded species that underpins the seed size-seed number trade-off.

AB - A seed size-seed number trade-off exists because smaller seeds are produced in greater number but have a lower probability of establishment. This reduced establishment success of smaller-seeded species may be determined by biophysical constraints imposed by scaling rules. Root and shoot diameter, root growth extension rate (R-GER) and shoot length at death for dark-grown seedlings are predicted to scale with the cube root of seed embryo and endosperm mass (m). We confirmed this expectation for ten neotropical gap-dependent tree species with an embryo and endosperm dry mass >1 mg. However, for nine smaller seeded species (m < 1 mg) with photoblastic germination, root and shoot diameters were larger than expected, and consequently, R-GER was slower than expected. The maximum shoot thrust of seedlings from seeds with masses >= 1 mg was comparable to the estimated force required to displace overlying litter, supporting the hypothesis that photoblastic behaviour only occurs in seeds with insufficient shoot thrust to displace overlying leaves. Using the model soil water, energy and transpiration to predict soil drying in small and large gaps, we showed that: (1) gaps that receive a significant amount of direct sunlight will dry more quickly than small gaps that do not, (2) compared to the wet-season, soil that is already dry at depth (i.e. the dry-season) will dry faster after rainfall (this drying would most likely kill seedlings from small seeds) and (3) even during the wet-season, dry periods of a few days in large gaps can kill shallow-rooted seedlings. We conclude that the smaller the seed, the more vulnerable its seedling would be to both covering by litter and soil drying because it can only emerge from shallow depths and has a slow R-GER. Consequently, we suggest that these allometrically related factors contribute to the reduced establishment success of smaller-seeded species that underpins the seed size-seed number trade-off.

KW - allometric relationships

KW - Barro Colorado Island

KW - soil water availability

KW - sweat

KW - tropical forest

KW - topographic position

KW - soil-water

KW - size

KW - growth

KW - establishment

KW - germination

KW - herbivory

KW - Panama

KW - model

U2 - 10.1007/s00442-007-0848-2

DO - 10.1007/s00442-007-0848-2

M3 - Article

VL - 154

SP - 445

EP - 454

JO - Oecologia

JF - Oecologia

SN - 0029-8549

IS - 3

ER -