Assessing the cumulative impacts of hydropower regulation on the flow characteristics of a large atlantic salmon river system

Christian Birkel*, Christopher Soulsby, Genevieve Aicha Ali, Doerthe Tetzlaff

*Corresponding author for this work

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

16 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

We assessed the influence of hydropower on the flow characteristics of the river Tay, one of the UK's most heavily regulated catchments and important Atlantic salmon fisheries. Hydropower developments in the mid-20th century preceded flow data collection, resulting in knowledge gaps over how far regulated flows deviate from natural and how ecosystem functioning might have been impacted. We used 29 unregulated catchments in and around the Tay to assess the relationships between hydroclimatic conditions, landscape structure and the overall flow regime, as well as the annual, monthly and daily flow metrics. This allowed the identification of flow characteristics by using an integrated suite of regression approaches (nonlinear, MLR and random forests) to assess likely impacts at 11 regulated sites. The results showed that the impacts of regulation are highly variable in both space and time. Headwater sub-catchments are most heavily affected, and water imports or exports as part of hydropower schemes can increase or decrease annual runoff by up to 50%, respectively. On a monthly basis, regulation primarily increased summer low flows; winter high flows increased in catchments affected by water imports and reduced where there was a net water export. At larger catchment scales, impacts were relatively small, as unregulated tributaries re-naturalize the flows and the effects of intra-basin transfers balance. Non-stationarity in climate and water use in the catchment dictates that adaptive management of flows may be necessary to protect ecosystems services.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)456-475
Number of pages20
JournalRiver Research and Applications
Volume30
Issue number4
Early online date5 Apr 2013
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - May 2014

Fingerprint

Catchments
river system
Rivers
catchment
Water
Ecosystems
import
Fisheries
Runoff
regulation
adaptive management
landscape structure
ecosystem service
headwater
low flow
water
water use
tributary
fishery
runoff

Keywords

  • Catchment characteristics
  • Gamma distribution
  • Hydropower
  • Impact assessment
  • Random forests
  • Stream regulation
  • Streamflow dynamics

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Environmental Science(all)
  • Environmental Chemistry
  • Water Science and Technology

Cite this

@article{bf7cdc0a6a3643729e6f67b12e2e46f3,
title = "Assessing the cumulative impacts of hydropower regulation on the flow characteristics of a large atlantic salmon river system",
abstract = "We assessed the influence of hydropower on the flow characteristics of the river Tay, one of the UK's most heavily regulated catchments and important Atlantic salmon fisheries. Hydropower developments in the mid-20th century preceded flow data collection, resulting in knowledge gaps over how far regulated flows deviate from natural and how ecosystem functioning might have been impacted. We used 29 unregulated catchments in and around the Tay to assess the relationships between hydroclimatic conditions, landscape structure and the overall flow regime, as well as the annual, monthly and daily flow metrics. This allowed the identification of flow characteristics by using an integrated suite of regression approaches (nonlinear, MLR and random forests) to assess likely impacts at 11 regulated sites. The results showed that the impacts of regulation are highly variable in both space and time. Headwater sub-catchments are most heavily affected, and water imports or exports as part of hydropower schemes can increase or decrease annual runoff by up to 50{\%}, respectively. On a monthly basis, regulation primarily increased summer low flows; winter high flows increased in catchments affected by water imports and reduced where there was a net water export. At larger catchment scales, impacts were relatively small, as unregulated tributaries re-naturalize the flows and the effects of intra-basin transfers balance. Non-stationarity in climate and water use in the catchment dictates that adaptive management of flows may be necessary to protect ecosystems services.",
keywords = "Catchment characteristics, Gamma distribution, Hydropower, Impact assessment, Random forests, Stream regulation, Streamflow dynamics",
author = "Christian Birkel and Christopher Soulsby and Ali, {Genevieve Aicha} and Doerthe Tetzlaff",
note = "ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS We gratefully acknowledge the data provided for this study by several Scottish and UK institutions: discharge and climate data were kindly provided by the Scottish Environmental Protection Agency (Una Thom, Joe Glennie and Kirsty-Anne Wilson), climate data were also compiled from the British Atmospheric Data Center, topographic data were analysed using the data provided by EDINA and general catchment information was taken from the Centre for Ecology and Hydrology National River Archive. We would also like to thank two anonymous reviewers for their helpful and constructive criticism that significantly improved an earlier version of this manuscript.",
year = "2014",
month = "5",
doi = "10.1002/rra.2656",
language = "English",
volume = "30",
pages = "456--475",
journal = "River Research and Applications",
issn = "1535-1459",
publisher = "John Wiley and Sons Ltd",
number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Assessing the cumulative impacts of hydropower regulation on the flow characteristics of a large atlantic salmon river system

AU - Birkel, Christian

AU - Soulsby, Christopher

AU - Ali, Genevieve Aicha

AU - Tetzlaff, Doerthe

N1 - ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS We gratefully acknowledge the data provided for this study by several Scottish and UK institutions: discharge and climate data were kindly provided by the Scottish Environmental Protection Agency (Una Thom, Joe Glennie and Kirsty-Anne Wilson), climate data were also compiled from the British Atmospheric Data Center, topographic data were analysed using the data provided by EDINA and general catchment information was taken from the Centre for Ecology and Hydrology National River Archive. We would also like to thank two anonymous reviewers for their helpful and constructive criticism that significantly improved an earlier version of this manuscript.

PY - 2014/5

Y1 - 2014/5

N2 - We assessed the influence of hydropower on the flow characteristics of the river Tay, one of the UK's most heavily regulated catchments and important Atlantic salmon fisheries. Hydropower developments in the mid-20th century preceded flow data collection, resulting in knowledge gaps over how far regulated flows deviate from natural and how ecosystem functioning might have been impacted. We used 29 unregulated catchments in and around the Tay to assess the relationships between hydroclimatic conditions, landscape structure and the overall flow regime, as well as the annual, monthly and daily flow metrics. This allowed the identification of flow characteristics by using an integrated suite of regression approaches (nonlinear, MLR and random forests) to assess likely impacts at 11 regulated sites. The results showed that the impacts of regulation are highly variable in both space and time. Headwater sub-catchments are most heavily affected, and water imports or exports as part of hydropower schemes can increase or decrease annual runoff by up to 50%, respectively. On a monthly basis, regulation primarily increased summer low flows; winter high flows increased in catchments affected by water imports and reduced where there was a net water export. At larger catchment scales, impacts were relatively small, as unregulated tributaries re-naturalize the flows and the effects of intra-basin transfers balance. Non-stationarity in climate and water use in the catchment dictates that adaptive management of flows may be necessary to protect ecosystems services.

AB - We assessed the influence of hydropower on the flow characteristics of the river Tay, one of the UK's most heavily regulated catchments and important Atlantic salmon fisheries. Hydropower developments in the mid-20th century preceded flow data collection, resulting in knowledge gaps over how far regulated flows deviate from natural and how ecosystem functioning might have been impacted. We used 29 unregulated catchments in and around the Tay to assess the relationships between hydroclimatic conditions, landscape structure and the overall flow regime, as well as the annual, monthly and daily flow metrics. This allowed the identification of flow characteristics by using an integrated suite of regression approaches (nonlinear, MLR and random forests) to assess likely impacts at 11 regulated sites. The results showed that the impacts of regulation are highly variable in both space and time. Headwater sub-catchments are most heavily affected, and water imports or exports as part of hydropower schemes can increase or decrease annual runoff by up to 50%, respectively. On a monthly basis, regulation primarily increased summer low flows; winter high flows increased in catchments affected by water imports and reduced where there was a net water export. At larger catchment scales, impacts were relatively small, as unregulated tributaries re-naturalize the flows and the effects of intra-basin transfers balance. Non-stationarity in climate and water use in the catchment dictates that adaptive management of flows may be necessary to protect ecosystems services.

KW - Catchment characteristics

KW - Gamma distribution

KW - Hydropower

KW - Impact assessment

KW - Random forests

KW - Stream regulation

KW - Streamflow dynamics

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84899055165&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1002/rra.2656

DO - 10.1002/rra.2656

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:84899055165

VL - 30

SP - 456

EP - 475

JO - River Research and Applications

JF - River Research and Applications

SN - 1535-1459

IS - 4

ER -