Auditory Hallucinations: Psychotic Symptom or Dissociative Experience?

Andrew Moskowitz, Dirk Corstens

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    Abstract

    While auditory hallucinations are considered a core psychotic symptom, central to the diagnosis of schizophrenia, it has long been recognized that persons who are not psychotic may also hear voices. There is an entrenched clinical belief that distinctions can be made between these groups, typically, on the basis of the perceived location or the ‘third-person’ perspective of the voices. While it is generally believed that such characteristics of voices have significant clinical implications, and are important in the differential diagnosis between dissociative and psychotic disorders, there is no research evidence in support of this. Voices heard by persons diagnosed schizophrenic appear to be indistinguishable, on the basis of their experienced characteristics, from voices heard by persons with dissociative disorders or by persons with no mental disorder at all. On this and other bases outlined in this article, we argue that hearing voices should be considered a dissociative experience, which under some conditions may have pathological consequences. In other words, we believe that, while voices may occur in the context of a psychotic disorder, they should not be considered a psychotic symptom.
    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)35-63
    Number of pages29
    JournalJournal of Psychological Trauma
    Volume6
    Issue number2-3
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 2008

    Fingerprint

    human being
    experience
    mental disorder
    schizophrenia
    evidence
    Group

    Keywords

    • auditory hallucinations
    • dissociation
    • psychosis
    • diagnosis

    Cite this

    Auditory Hallucinations : Psychotic Symptom or Dissociative Experience? / Moskowitz, Andrew; Corstens, Dirk.

    In: Journal of Psychological Trauma, Vol. 6, No. 2-3, 2008, p. 35-63.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    Moskowitz, Andrew ; Corstens, Dirk. / Auditory Hallucinations : Psychotic Symptom or Dissociative Experience?. In: Journal of Psychological Trauma. 2008 ; Vol. 6, No. 2-3. pp. 35-63.
    @article{af7a7fd9d0014e0da85e69267a8e02b4,
    title = "Auditory Hallucinations: Psychotic Symptom or Dissociative Experience?",
    abstract = "While auditory hallucinations are considered a core psychotic symptom, central to the diagnosis of schizophrenia, it has long been recognized that persons who are not psychotic may also hear voices. There is an entrenched clinical belief that distinctions can be made between these groups, typically, on the basis of the perceived location or the ‘third-person’ perspective of the voices. While it is generally believed that such characteristics of voices have significant clinical implications, and are important in the differential diagnosis between dissociative and psychotic disorders, there is no research evidence in support of this. Voices heard by persons diagnosed schizophrenic appear to be indistinguishable, on the basis of their experienced characteristics, from voices heard by persons with dissociative disorders or by persons with no mental disorder at all. On this and other bases outlined in this article, we argue that hearing voices should be considered a dissociative experience, which under some conditions may have pathological consequences. In other words, we believe that, while voices may occur in the context of a psychotic disorder, they should not be considered a psychotic symptom.",
    keywords = "auditory hallucinations, dissociation, psychosis, diagnosis",
    author = "Andrew Moskowitz and Dirk Corstens",
    year = "2008",
    doi = "10.1300/J513v06n02_04",
    language = "English",
    volume = "6",
    pages = "35--63",
    journal = "Journal of Psychological Trauma",
    issn = "1932-2887",
    number = "2-3",

    }

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Auditory Hallucinations

    T2 - Psychotic Symptom or Dissociative Experience?

    AU - Moskowitz, Andrew

    AU - Corstens, Dirk

    PY - 2008

    Y1 - 2008

    N2 - While auditory hallucinations are considered a core psychotic symptom, central to the diagnosis of schizophrenia, it has long been recognized that persons who are not psychotic may also hear voices. There is an entrenched clinical belief that distinctions can be made between these groups, typically, on the basis of the perceived location or the ‘third-person’ perspective of the voices. While it is generally believed that such characteristics of voices have significant clinical implications, and are important in the differential diagnosis between dissociative and psychotic disorders, there is no research evidence in support of this. Voices heard by persons diagnosed schizophrenic appear to be indistinguishable, on the basis of their experienced characteristics, from voices heard by persons with dissociative disorders or by persons with no mental disorder at all. On this and other bases outlined in this article, we argue that hearing voices should be considered a dissociative experience, which under some conditions may have pathological consequences. In other words, we believe that, while voices may occur in the context of a psychotic disorder, they should not be considered a psychotic symptom.

    AB - While auditory hallucinations are considered a core psychotic symptom, central to the diagnosis of schizophrenia, it has long been recognized that persons who are not psychotic may also hear voices. There is an entrenched clinical belief that distinctions can be made between these groups, typically, on the basis of the perceived location or the ‘third-person’ perspective of the voices. While it is generally believed that such characteristics of voices have significant clinical implications, and are important in the differential diagnosis between dissociative and psychotic disorders, there is no research evidence in support of this. Voices heard by persons diagnosed schizophrenic appear to be indistinguishable, on the basis of their experienced characteristics, from voices heard by persons with dissociative disorders or by persons with no mental disorder at all. On this and other bases outlined in this article, we argue that hearing voices should be considered a dissociative experience, which under some conditions may have pathological consequences. In other words, we believe that, while voices may occur in the context of a psychotic disorder, they should not be considered a psychotic symptom.

    KW - auditory hallucinations

    KW - dissociation

    KW - psychosis

    KW - diagnosis

    U2 - 10.1300/J513v06n02_04

    DO - 10.1300/J513v06n02_04

    M3 - Article

    VL - 6

    SP - 35

    EP - 63

    JO - Journal of Psychological Trauma

    JF - Journal of Psychological Trauma

    SN - 1932-2887

    IS - 2-3

    ER -