Boundaries of the wolf and the wild: a conceptual examination of the relationship between rewilding and animal reintroduction

Koen Arts, Anke Fischer, Rene van der Wal

Research output: Contribution to journalLiterature review

12 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Animal reintroduction and rewilding are two widely appealing and frequently connected forms of ecological restoration. However, the critical assumption that animal reintroduction automatically helps to restore formerly wild places is under-theorized. To fill this void, we identified three common rewilding elements from the literatureecological functioning, wilderness experience, and natural autonomyand screened these against a hypothetical wolf reintroduction to Scotland. Each of the rewilding elements was likely to be positively impacted by a wolf reintroduction. Yet, there is a key conceptual difficulty in that the different rewilding elements do not necessarily enforce each other, and at times may even collide. Thus, a reintroduced species like the wolf may obfuscate the clear-cut, purified nature category to which rewilding often aspires. As a way forward, we suggest that there is merit in actively engaging with the tensions created by rewilding and reintroductions. A reconceptualisation of the nature-culture spectrum as consisting of multiple layers (e.g. ecological functioning, wilderness experience, and natural autonomy) may help to interpret ecological restoration as a tentative, deliberative, and gradual enterprise. This bears some resemblance to the notion of approaching a landscape like a palimpsest' (i.e. a text built up of different layers written on top of each other), which may support the reconciliation of conflicting views without necessarily making those disappear. When viewed as feeding into a multilayered nature-culture spectrum, animal reintroduction and rewilding can be promoted as inspiring and essentially non-controlling forms of ecological restoration and human interaction with nature.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)27-34
Number of pages8
JournalRestoration Ecology
Volume24
Issue number1
Early online date26 Nov 2015
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jan 2016

Keywords

  • control
  • ecological restoration
  • grey wolf (Canis lupus)
  • Scotland
  • wild
  • red deer management
  • Scottish Highlands
  • wilderness restoration
  • species management
  • large carnivores
  • national-park
  • landscapes
  • wolves
  • conservation

Cite this

Boundaries of the wolf and the wild : a conceptual examination of the relationship between rewilding and animal reintroduction. / Arts, Koen; Fischer, Anke; van der Wal, Rene.

In: Restoration Ecology, Vol. 24, No. 1, 01.2016, p. 27-34.

Research output: Contribution to journalLiterature review

@article{51fe3c08e67b4f0e8813b89fe6f0afff,
title = "Boundaries of the wolf and the wild: a conceptual examination of the relationship between rewilding and animal reintroduction",
abstract = "Animal reintroduction and rewilding are two widely appealing and frequently connected forms of ecological restoration. However, the critical assumption that animal reintroduction automatically helps to restore formerly wild places is under-theorized. To fill this void, we identified three common rewilding elements from the literatureecological functioning, wilderness experience, and natural autonomyand screened these against a hypothetical wolf reintroduction to Scotland. Each of the rewilding elements was likely to be positively impacted by a wolf reintroduction. Yet, there is a key conceptual difficulty in that the different rewilding elements do not necessarily enforce each other, and at times may even collide. Thus, a reintroduced species like the wolf may obfuscate the clear-cut, purified nature category to which rewilding often aspires. As a way forward, we suggest that there is merit in actively engaging with the tensions created by rewilding and reintroductions. A reconceptualisation of the nature-culture spectrum as consisting of multiple layers (e.g. ecological functioning, wilderness experience, and natural autonomy) may help to interpret ecological restoration as a tentative, deliberative, and gradual enterprise. This bears some resemblance to the notion of approaching a landscape like a palimpsest' (i.e. a text built up of different layers written on top of each other), which may support the reconciliation of conflicting views without necessarily making those disappear. When viewed as feeding into a multilayered nature-culture spectrum, animal reintroduction and rewilding can be promoted as inspiring and essentially non-controlling forms of ecological restoration and human interaction with nature.",
keywords = "control, ecological restoration, grey wolf (Canis lupus), Scotland, wild, red deer management, Scottish Highlands, wilderness restoration , species management, large carnivores, national-park, landscapes, wolves , conservation",
author = "Koen Arts and Anke Fischer and {van der Wal}, Rene",
note = "Funded by University of Aberdeen The Macaulay Development Trust The Scottish Rural and Environment Research and Analysis Directorate Programme 3 CNPq. Grant Number: 314033/2014-9",
year = "2016",
month = "1",
doi = "10.1111/rec.12309",
language = "English",
volume = "24",
pages = "27--34",
journal = "Restoration Ecology",
issn = "1061-2971",
publisher = "Wiley",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Boundaries of the wolf and the wild

T2 - a conceptual examination of the relationship between rewilding and animal reintroduction

AU - Arts, Koen

AU - Fischer, Anke

AU - van der Wal, Rene

N1 - Funded by University of Aberdeen The Macaulay Development Trust The Scottish Rural and Environment Research and Analysis Directorate Programme 3 CNPq. Grant Number: 314033/2014-9

PY - 2016/1

Y1 - 2016/1

N2 - Animal reintroduction and rewilding are two widely appealing and frequently connected forms of ecological restoration. However, the critical assumption that animal reintroduction automatically helps to restore formerly wild places is under-theorized. To fill this void, we identified three common rewilding elements from the literatureecological functioning, wilderness experience, and natural autonomyand screened these against a hypothetical wolf reintroduction to Scotland. Each of the rewilding elements was likely to be positively impacted by a wolf reintroduction. Yet, there is a key conceptual difficulty in that the different rewilding elements do not necessarily enforce each other, and at times may even collide. Thus, a reintroduced species like the wolf may obfuscate the clear-cut, purified nature category to which rewilding often aspires. As a way forward, we suggest that there is merit in actively engaging with the tensions created by rewilding and reintroductions. A reconceptualisation of the nature-culture spectrum as consisting of multiple layers (e.g. ecological functioning, wilderness experience, and natural autonomy) may help to interpret ecological restoration as a tentative, deliberative, and gradual enterprise. This bears some resemblance to the notion of approaching a landscape like a palimpsest' (i.e. a text built up of different layers written on top of each other), which may support the reconciliation of conflicting views without necessarily making those disappear. When viewed as feeding into a multilayered nature-culture spectrum, animal reintroduction and rewilding can be promoted as inspiring and essentially non-controlling forms of ecological restoration and human interaction with nature.

AB - Animal reintroduction and rewilding are two widely appealing and frequently connected forms of ecological restoration. However, the critical assumption that animal reintroduction automatically helps to restore formerly wild places is under-theorized. To fill this void, we identified three common rewilding elements from the literatureecological functioning, wilderness experience, and natural autonomyand screened these against a hypothetical wolf reintroduction to Scotland. Each of the rewilding elements was likely to be positively impacted by a wolf reintroduction. Yet, there is a key conceptual difficulty in that the different rewilding elements do not necessarily enforce each other, and at times may even collide. Thus, a reintroduced species like the wolf may obfuscate the clear-cut, purified nature category to which rewilding often aspires. As a way forward, we suggest that there is merit in actively engaging with the tensions created by rewilding and reintroductions. A reconceptualisation of the nature-culture spectrum as consisting of multiple layers (e.g. ecological functioning, wilderness experience, and natural autonomy) may help to interpret ecological restoration as a tentative, deliberative, and gradual enterprise. This bears some resemblance to the notion of approaching a landscape like a palimpsest' (i.e. a text built up of different layers written on top of each other), which may support the reconciliation of conflicting views without necessarily making those disappear. When viewed as feeding into a multilayered nature-culture spectrum, animal reintroduction and rewilding can be promoted as inspiring and essentially non-controlling forms of ecological restoration and human interaction with nature.

KW - control

KW - ecological restoration

KW - grey wolf (Canis lupus)

KW - Scotland

KW - wild

KW - red deer management

KW - Scottish Highlands

KW - wilderness restoration

KW - species management

KW - large carnivores

KW - national-park

KW - landscapes

KW - wolves

KW - conservation

U2 - 10.1111/rec.12309

DO - 10.1111/rec.12309

M3 - Literature review

VL - 24

SP - 27

EP - 34

JO - Restoration Ecology

JF - Restoration Ecology

SN - 1061-2971

IS - 1

ER -