Breaking symmetry: The marine environment, prey size, and the evolution of asymmetry in cetacean skulls

Colin D MacLeod, J. S. Reidenberg, M. Weller, Maria Begona Santos Vazquez, J. Herman, J. Goold, Graham John Pierce

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

51 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Skulls of odontocetes (toothed whales, including dolphins and porpoises) are typified by directional asymmetry, particularly in elements associated with the airway. Generally, it is assumed this asymmetry is related to biosonar production. However, skull asymmetry may actually be a by-product of selection pressure for an asymmetrically positioned larynx. The odontocete larynx traverses the pharynx and is held permanently in place by a ring of muscle. This allows prey swallowing while remaining underwater without risking water entering the lungs and causing injury or death. However, protrusion of the larynx through the pharynx causes a restriction around which prey must pass to reach the stomach. The larynx and associated hyoid apparatus has, therefore, been shifted to the left to provide a larger right piriform, sinus (lateral pharyngeal food channel) for swallowing larger prey items, This asymmetry is reflected in the skull, particularly the dorsal openings of the nares. It is hypothesized that there is a relationship between prey size and skull asymmetry. This relationship was examined in 13 species of odontocete cetaceans from the northeast Atlantic, including four narrow-gaped genera (Mesoplodon, Ziphius, Hyperoodon, and Kogia) and eight wide-gaped genera (Phocoena, Delphinus, Stenella, Lagenorhynchus, Tursiops, Grampus, Globicephala, and Orcinus). Skulls were examined from 183 specimens to assess asymmetry of the anterior choanae. Stomach contents were examined from 294 specimens to assess prey size. Results show there is a significant positive relationship between maximum relative prey size consumed and average asymmetry relative to skull size in odontocete species (wide-gape species: R-2 = 0.642, P = 0.006; narrow-gape species: R-2 = 0.909, P = 0.031). This finding provides support for the hypothesis that the directional asymmetry found in odontocete skulls is related to an aquatic adaptation enabling swallowing large, whole prey while maintaining respiratory tract protection.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)539-545
Number of pages7
JournalThe Anatomical Record Advances in Integrative Anatomy and Evolutionary Biology
Volume290
Issue number6
Early online date21 May 2007
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jun 2007

Keywords

  • skull morphology
  • directional asymmetry
  • prey size
  • toothed whales
  • stomach contents
  • anatomy
  • porpoises phocoena-phocoena
  • odontoceti toothed whales
  • North-Sea
  • diet

Cite this

Breaking symmetry : The marine environment, prey size, and the evolution of asymmetry in cetacean skulls. / MacLeod, Colin D; Reidenberg, J. S.; Weller, M.; Santos Vazquez, Maria Begona; Herman, J.; Goold, J.; Pierce, Graham John.

In: The Anatomical Record Advances in Integrative Anatomy and Evolutionary Biology, Vol. 290, No. 6, 06.2007, p. 539-545.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

MacLeod, Colin D ; Reidenberg, J. S. ; Weller, M. ; Santos Vazquez, Maria Begona ; Herman, J. ; Goold, J. ; Pierce, Graham John. / Breaking symmetry : The marine environment, prey size, and the evolution of asymmetry in cetacean skulls. In: The Anatomical Record Advances in Integrative Anatomy and Evolutionary Biology. 2007 ; Vol. 290, No. 6. pp. 539-545.
@article{9acd9bdcc9e34dc8a92d577abcf61802,
title = "Breaking symmetry: The marine environment, prey size, and the evolution of asymmetry in cetacean skulls",
abstract = "Skulls of odontocetes (toothed whales, including dolphins and porpoises) are typified by directional asymmetry, particularly in elements associated with the airway. Generally, it is assumed this asymmetry is related to biosonar production. However, skull asymmetry may actually be a by-product of selection pressure for an asymmetrically positioned larynx. The odontocete larynx traverses the pharynx and is held permanently in place by a ring of muscle. This allows prey swallowing while remaining underwater without risking water entering the lungs and causing injury or death. However, protrusion of the larynx through the pharynx causes a restriction around which prey must pass to reach the stomach. The larynx and associated hyoid apparatus has, therefore, been shifted to the left to provide a larger right piriform, sinus (lateral pharyngeal food channel) for swallowing larger prey items, This asymmetry is reflected in the skull, particularly the dorsal openings of the nares. It is hypothesized that there is a relationship between prey size and skull asymmetry. This relationship was examined in 13 species of odontocete cetaceans from the northeast Atlantic, including four narrow-gaped genera (Mesoplodon, Ziphius, Hyperoodon, and Kogia) and eight wide-gaped genera (Phocoena, Delphinus, Stenella, Lagenorhynchus, Tursiops, Grampus, Globicephala, and Orcinus). Skulls were examined from 183 specimens to assess asymmetry of the anterior choanae. Stomach contents were examined from 294 specimens to assess prey size. Results show there is a significant positive relationship between maximum relative prey size consumed and average asymmetry relative to skull size in odontocete species (wide-gape species: R-2 = 0.642, P = 0.006; narrow-gape species: R-2 = 0.909, P = 0.031). This finding provides support for the hypothesis that the directional asymmetry found in odontocete skulls is related to an aquatic adaptation enabling swallowing large, whole prey while maintaining respiratory tract protection.",
keywords = "skull morphology, directional asymmetry, prey size, toothed whales, stomach contents, anatomy, porpoises phocoena-phocoena, odontoceti toothed whales, North-Sea, diet",
author = "MacLeod, {Colin D} and Reidenberg, {J. S.} and M. Weller and {Santos Vazquez}, {Maria Begona} and J. Herman and J. Goold and Pierce, {Graham John}",
year = "2007",
month = "6",
doi = "10.1002/ar.20539",
language = "English",
volume = "290",
pages = "539--545",
journal = "The Anatomical Record Advances in Integrative Anatomy and Evolutionary Biology",
issn = "1932-8494",
publisher = "John Wiley and Sons Inc.",
number = "6",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Breaking symmetry

T2 - The marine environment, prey size, and the evolution of asymmetry in cetacean skulls

AU - MacLeod, Colin D

AU - Reidenberg, J. S.

AU - Weller, M.

AU - Santos Vazquez, Maria Begona

AU - Herman, J.

AU - Goold, J.

AU - Pierce, Graham John

PY - 2007/6

Y1 - 2007/6

N2 - Skulls of odontocetes (toothed whales, including dolphins and porpoises) are typified by directional asymmetry, particularly in elements associated with the airway. Generally, it is assumed this asymmetry is related to biosonar production. However, skull asymmetry may actually be a by-product of selection pressure for an asymmetrically positioned larynx. The odontocete larynx traverses the pharynx and is held permanently in place by a ring of muscle. This allows prey swallowing while remaining underwater without risking water entering the lungs and causing injury or death. However, protrusion of the larynx through the pharynx causes a restriction around which prey must pass to reach the stomach. The larynx and associated hyoid apparatus has, therefore, been shifted to the left to provide a larger right piriform, sinus (lateral pharyngeal food channel) for swallowing larger prey items, This asymmetry is reflected in the skull, particularly the dorsal openings of the nares. It is hypothesized that there is a relationship between prey size and skull asymmetry. This relationship was examined in 13 species of odontocete cetaceans from the northeast Atlantic, including four narrow-gaped genera (Mesoplodon, Ziphius, Hyperoodon, and Kogia) and eight wide-gaped genera (Phocoena, Delphinus, Stenella, Lagenorhynchus, Tursiops, Grampus, Globicephala, and Orcinus). Skulls were examined from 183 specimens to assess asymmetry of the anterior choanae. Stomach contents were examined from 294 specimens to assess prey size. Results show there is a significant positive relationship between maximum relative prey size consumed and average asymmetry relative to skull size in odontocete species (wide-gape species: R-2 = 0.642, P = 0.006; narrow-gape species: R-2 = 0.909, P = 0.031). This finding provides support for the hypothesis that the directional asymmetry found in odontocete skulls is related to an aquatic adaptation enabling swallowing large, whole prey while maintaining respiratory tract protection.

AB - Skulls of odontocetes (toothed whales, including dolphins and porpoises) are typified by directional asymmetry, particularly in elements associated with the airway. Generally, it is assumed this asymmetry is related to biosonar production. However, skull asymmetry may actually be a by-product of selection pressure for an asymmetrically positioned larynx. The odontocete larynx traverses the pharynx and is held permanently in place by a ring of muscle. This allows prey swallowing while remaining underwater without risking water entering the lungs and causing injury or death. However, protrusion of the larynx through the pharynx causes a restriction around which prey must pass to reach the stomach. The larynx and associated hyoid apparatus has, therefore, been shifted to the left to provide a larger right piriform, sinus (lateral pharyngeal food channel) for swallowing larger prey items, This asymmetry is reflected in the skull, particularly the dorsal openings of the nares. It is hypothesized that there is a relationship between prey size and skull asymmetry. This relationship was examined in 13 species of odontocete cetaceans from the northeast Atlantic, including four narrow-gaped genera (Mesoplodon, Ziphius, Hyperoodon, and Kogia) and eight wide-gaped genera (Phocoena, Delphinus, Stenella, Lagenorhynchus, Tursiops, Grampus, Globicephala, and Orcinus). Skulls were examined from 183 specimens to assess asymmetry of the anterior choanae. Stomach contents were examined from 294 specimens to assess prey size. Results show there is a significant positive relationship between maximum relative prey size consumed and average asymmetry relative to skull size in odontocete species (wide-gape species: R-2 = 0.642, P = 0.006; narrow-gape species: R-2 = 0.909, P = 0.031). This finding provides support for the hypothesis that the directional asymmetry found in odontocete skulls is related to an aquatic adaptation enabling swallowing large, whole prey while maintaining respiratory tract protection.

KW - skull morphology

KW - directional asymmetry

KW - prey size

KW - toothed whales

KW - stomach contents

KW - anatomy

KW - porpoises phocoena-phocoena

KW - odontoceti toothed whales

KW - North-Sea

KW - diet

U2 - 10.1002/ar.20539

DO - 10.1002/ar.20539

M3 - Article

VL - 290

SP - 539

EP - 545

JO - The Anatomical Record Advances in Integrative Anatomy and Evolutionary Biology

JF - The Anatomical Record Advances in Integrative Anatomy and Evolutionary Biology

SN - 1932-8494

IS - 6

ER -