Can Radiologists Detect Osteopenia on Plain Radiographs

M J Garton, Elizabeth Robertson, Fiona Jane Gilbert, L Gomersall, David M Reid

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

23 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The main purpose of this study was to compare subjective estimates of vertebral osteopenia with bone mineral density (BMD) measurements of the same region in 200 (107 male, 93 female) subjects, aged 52-90 years, invited randomly from the community. Standardized plain thoracolumbar radiographs were examined by three senior radiologists, and given a semiquantitative osteopenia score using the method of Saville. The BMD of the anteroposterior (AP) lumbar spine and femoral neck was measured by dual energy X-ray absorptiometry. In addition BMD measurements were compared in subjects without significant vertebral deformity, and those with mild (20-25%) or definite (> 25%) reductions of vertebral height. For the Saville score, intraobserver agreement was moderate to good (kappa 0.46-0.57), and interobserver agreement was fair to moderate kappa 0.25-0.41). Although the overlap between gradings was considerable, BMD was significantly related to visually estimated osteopenia. Subjects without apparent radiographic osteopenia (Saville grade 0) had a low risk (9-15%), compared to those with definite osteopenia (64-86%), of falling below the lowest quartile of BMD at either the femoral neck or the AP spine. In women (but not men), BMD measured at the hip and spine was related to vertebral deformity.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)118-122
Number of pages5
JournalClinical Radiology
Volume49
Issue number2
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Feb 1994

Keywords

  • BONE DENSITOMETRY
  • VERTEBRAL FRACTURES
  • OSTEOPOROSIS
  • DEFORMITY
  • WOMEN
  • SPINE
  • MASS
  • Bone Densitometry
  • Vertebral Fractures
  • Osteoperosis
  • Deformity
  • Women
  • Spine
  • Mass

Cite this

Garton, M. J., Robertson, E., Gilbert, F. J., Gomersall, L., & Reid, D. M. (1994). Can Radiologists Detect Osteopenia on Plain Radiographs . Clinical Radiology, 49(2), 118-122. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0009-9260(05)83453-1

Can Radiologists Detect Osteopenia on Plain Radiographs . / Garton, M J ; Robertson, Elizabeth; Gilbert, Fiona Jane; Gomersall, L ; Reid, David M.

In: Clinical Radiology, Vol. 49, No. 2, 02.1994, p. 118-122.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Garton, MJ, Robertson, E, Gilbert, FJ, Gomersall, L & Reid, DM 1994, 'Can Radiologists Detect Osteopenia on Plain Radiographs ', Clinical Radiology, vol. 49, no. 2, pp. 118-122. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0009-9260(05)83453-1
Garton MJ, Robertson E, Gilbert FJ, Gomersall L, Reid DM. Can Radiologists Detect Osteopenia on Plain Radiographs . Clinical Radiology. 1994 Feb;49(2):118-122. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0009-9260(05)83453-1
Garton, M J ; Robertson, Elizabeth ; Gilbert, Fiona Jane ; Gomersall, L ; Reid, David M. / Can Radiologists Detect Osteopenia on Plain Radiographs . In: Clinical Radiology. 1994 ; Vol. 49, No. 2. pp. 118-122.
@article{66075f5fd45143d8b9397be7c97ce163,
title = "Can Radiologists Detect Osteopenia on Plain Radiographs",
abstract = "The main purpose of this study was to compare subjective estimates of vertebral osteopenia with bone mineral density (BMD) measurements of the same region in 200 (107 male, 93 female) subjects, aged 52-90 years, invited randomly from the community. Standardized plain thoracolumbar radiographs were examined by three senior radiologists, and given a semiquantitative osteopenia score using the method of Saville. The BMD of the anteroposterior (AP) lumbar spine and femoral neck was measured by dual energy X-ray absorptiometry. In addition BMD measurements were compared in subjects without significant vertebral deformity, and those with mild (20-25{\%}) or definite (> 25{\%}) reductions of vertebral height. For the Saville score, intraobserver agreement was moderate to good (kappa 0.46-0.57), and interobserver agreement was fair to moderate kappa 0.25-0.41). Although the overlap between gradings was considerable, BMD was significantly related to visually estimated osteopenia. Subjects without apparent radiographic osteopenia (Saville grade 0) had a low risk (9-15{\%}), compared to those with definite osteopenia (64-86{\%}), of falling below the lowest quartile of BMD at either the femoral neck or the AP spine. In women (but not men), BMD measured at the hip and spine was related to vertebral deformity.",
keywords = "BONE DENSITOMETRY, VERTEBRAL FRACTURES, OSTEOPOROSIS, DEFORMITY, WOMEN, SPINE, MASS, Bone Densitometry, Vertebral Fractures, Osteoperosis, Deformity, Women , Spine , Mass",
author = "Garton, {M J} and Elizabeth Robertson and Gilbert, {Fiona Jane} and L Gomersall and Reid, {David M}",
year = "1994",
month = "2",
doi = "10.1016/S0009-9260(05)83453-1",
language = "English",
volume = "49",
pages = "118--122",
journal = "Clinical Radiology",
issn = "0009-9260",
publisher = "W.B. Saunders Ltd",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Can Radiologists Detect Osteopenia on Plain Radiographs

AU - Garton, M J

AU - Robertson, Elizabeth

AU - Gilbert, Fiona Jane

AU - Gomersall, L

AU - Reid, David M

PY - 1994/2

Y1 - 1994/2

N2 - The main purpose of this study was to compare subjective estimates of vertebral osteopenia with bone mineral density (BMD) measurements of the same region in 200 (107 male, 93 female) subjects, aged 52-90 years, invited randomly from the community. Standardized plain thoracolumbar radiographs were examined by three senior radiologists, and given a semiquantitative osteopenia score using the method of Saville. The BMD of the anteroposterior (AP) lumbar spine and femoral neck was measured by dual energy X-ray absorptiometry. In addition BMD measurements were compared in subjects without significant vertebral deformity, and those with mild (20-25%) or definite (> 25%) reductions of vertebral height. For the Saville score, intraobserver agreement was moderate to good (kappa 0.46-0.57), and interobserver agreement was fair to moderate kappa 0.25-0.41). Although the overlap between gradings was considerable, BMD was significantly related to visually estimated osteopenia. Subjects without apparent radiographic osteopenia (Saville grade 0) had a low risk (9-15%), compared to those with definite osteopenia (64-86%), of falling below the lowest quartile of BMD at either the femoral neck or the AP spine. In women (but not men), BMD measured at the hip and spine was related to vertebral deformity.

AB - The main purpose of this study was to compare subjective estimates of vertebral osteopenia with bone mineral density (BMD) measurements of the same region in 200 (107 male, 93 female) subjects, aged 52-90 years, invited randomly from the community. Standardized plain thoracolumbar radiographs were examined by three senior radiologists, and given a semiquantitative osteopenia score using the method of Saville. The BMD of the anteroposterior (AP) lumbar spine and femoral neck was measured by dual energy X-ray absorptiometry. In addition BMD measurements were compared in subjects without significant vertebral deformity, and those with mild (20-25%) or definite (> 25%) reductions of vertebral height. For the Saville score, intraobserver agreement was moderate to good (kappa 0.46-0.57), and interobserver agreement was fair to moderate kappa 0.25-0.41). Although the overlap between gradings was considerable, BMD was significantly related to visually estimated osteopenia. Subjects without apparent radiographic osteopenia (Saville grade 0) had a low risk (9-15%), compared to those with definite osteopenia (64-86%), of falling below the lowest quartile of BMD at either the femoral neck or the AP spine. In women (but not men), BMD measured at the hip and spine was related to vertebral deformity.

KW - BONE DENSITOMETRY

KW - VERTEBRAL FRACTURES

KW - OSTEOPOROSIS

KW - DEFORMITY

KW - WOMEN

KW - SPINE

KW - MASS

KW - Bone Densitometry

KW - Vertebral Fractures

KW - Osteoperosis

KW - Deformity

KW - Women

KW - Spine

KW - Mass

U2 - 10.1016/S0009-9260(05)83453-1

DO - 10.1016/S0009-9260(05)83453-1

M3 - Article

VL - 49

SP - 118

EP - 122

JO - Clinical Radiology

JF - Clinical Radiology

SN - 0009-9260

IS - 2

ER -