Challenges in assessing the ecological impacts of tree diseases and mitigation measures: the case of Hymenoscyphus fraxineus and Fraxinus excelsior

R. J. Mitchell, A. Broome, Joan K. Beaton, Paul E. Bellamy, Chris J. Ellis, Alison J. Hester, Nick G. Hodgetts, Glenn R. Iason, Nick A. Littlewood, Scott Newey, Gabor Pozsgai, Scot Ramsay, David Riach, Jenni A. Stockan, Andy F. S. Taylor, Steve Woodward

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Forests worldwide are currently threatened by a number of non-native tree diseases. Widespread death of a tree species will have ecological impacts on species that in some way depend on that tree species to complete their life-cycle. One measure to mitigate these impacts is to establish alternative tree species to replace the threatened tree species. These alternative tree species should be as similar as possible to the threatened tree species in terms of species supported, tree traits and the environmental conditions under which the tree will grow. This study assesses the availability and quality of data to assess the ecological impact of Hymenoscyphus fraxineus on Fraxinus excelsior and the suitability of 48 alternative trees to replace F. excelsior in the UK. To make this assessment data were collected on 1) species use (whether the 955 ash-associated species will use the alternative tree species), 2) traits (bark pH, deciduous, floral reward, fruit type, height, leaf dry matter content, leaf shape, length of flowering time, mycorrhizal association, pollen vector and specific leaf area) and 3) site requirements (occurrence within northern/southern and upland/lowland Britain, detailed climatic and soil nutrient requirements). For all three assessment methods there was lower confidence in the suitability of non-native tree species to replace F. excelsior due to lack of data. Different alternative tree species were ranked most suitable depending on the methods used. We conclude that no one species is suited to all the site types associated with F. excelsior, nor will any one tree species support a high percentage of the ash-associated species while also matching many of the traits of F. excelsior. Our work provides broad guidance on the suitability of the 48 alternatives but site specific information is required to refine this selection at each site. The study highlights a lack of information to make a full assessment of the suitability of many species, particularly non-native species and calls for the collation of biological records so that rapid assessments of the potential ecological impacts of the loss of any given tree species and the suitability of their alternative tree species can be made.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)116-140
Number of pages25
JournalBaltic Forestry
Volume23
Issue number1
Publication statusPublished - Jan 2017

Fingerprint

tree diseases
Fraxinus excelsior
ecological impact
Hymenoscyphus fraxineus
mitigation measure
tree mortality
ash

Cite this

Challenges in assessing the ecological impacts of tree diseases and mitigation measures : the case of Hymenoscyphus fraxineus and Fraxinus excelsior. / Mitchell, R. J.; Broome, A.; Beaton, Joan K.; Bellamy, Paul E.; Ellis, Chris J.; Hester, Alison J.; Hodgetts, Nick G.; Iason, Glenn R.; Littlewood, Nick A.; Newey, Scott; Pozsgai, Gabor; Ramsay, Scot; Riach, David; Stockan, Jenni A.; Taylor, Andy F. S.; Woodward, Steve.

In: Baltic Forestry, Vol. 23, No. 1, 01.2017, p. 116-140.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Mitchell, RJ, Broome, A, Beaton, JK, Bellamy, PE, Ellis, CJ, Hester, AJ, Hodgetts, NG, Iason, GR, Littlewood, NA, Newey, S, Pozsgai, G, Ramsay, S, Riach, D, Stockan, JA, Taylor, AFS & Woodward, S 2017, 'Challenges in assessing the ecological impacts of tree diseases and mitigation measures: the case of Hymenoscyphus fraxineus and Fraxinus excelsior', Baltic Forestry, vol. 23, no. 1, pp. 116-140.
Mitchell, R. J. ; Broome, A. ; Beaton, Joan K. ; Bellamy, Paul E. ; Ellis, Chris J. ; Hester, Alison J. ; Hodgetts, Nick G. ; Iason, Glenn R. ; Littlewood, Nick A. ; Newey, Scott ; Pozsgai, Gabor ; Ramsay, Scot ; Riach, David ; Stockan, Jenni A. ; Taylor, Andy F. S. ; Woodward, Steve. / Challenges in assessing the ecological impacts of tree diseases and mitigation measures : the case of Hymenoscyphus fraxineus and Fraxinus excelsior. In: Baltic Forestry. 2017 ; Vol. 23, No. 1. pp. 116-140.
@article{82b8c8da1cc94d8093c6aa648ccec030,
title = "Challenges in assessing the ecological impacts of tree diseases and mitigation measures: the case of Hymenoscyphus fraxineus and Fraxinus excelsior",
abstract = "Forests worldwide are currently threatened by a number of non-native tree diseases. Widespread death of a tree species will have ecological impacts on species that in some way depend on that tree species to complete their life-cycle. One measure to mitigate these impacts is to establish alternative tree species to replace the threatened tree species. These alternative tree species should be as similar as possible to the threatened tree species in terms of species supported, tree traits and the environmental conditions under which the tree will grow. This study assesses the availability and quality of data to assess the ecological impact of Hymenoscyphus fraxineus on Fraxinus excelsior and the suitability of 48 alternative trees to replace F. excelsior in the UK. To make this assessment data were collected on 1) species use (whether the 955 ash-associated species will use the alternative tree species), 2) traits (bark pH, deciduous, floral reward, fruit type, height, leaf dry matter content, leaf shape, length of flowering time, mycorrhizal association, pollen vector and specific leaf area) and 3) site requirements (occurrence within northern/southern and upland/lowland Britain, detailed climatic and soil nutrient requirements). For all three assessment methods there was lower confidence in the suitability of non-native tree species to replace F. excelsior due to lack of data. Different alternative tree species were ranked most suitable depending on the methods used. We conclude that no one species is suited to all the site types associated with F. excelsior, nor will any one tree species support a high percentage of the ash-associated species while also matching many of the traits of F. excelsior. Our work provides broad guidance on the suitability of the 48 alternatives but site specific information is required to refine this selection at each site. The study highlights a lack of information to make a full assessment of the suitability of many species, particularly non-native species and calls for the collation of biological records so that rapid assessments of the potential ecological impacts of the loss of any given tree species and the suitability of their alternative tree species can be made.",
author = "Mitchell, {R. J.} and A. Broome and Beaton, {Joan K.} and Bellamy, {Paul E.} and Ellis, {Chris J.} and Hester, {Alison J.} and Hodgetts, {Nick G.} and Iason, {Glenn R.} and Littlewood, {Nick A.} and Scott Newey and Gabor Pozsgai and Scot Ramsay and David Riach and Stockan, {Jenni A.} and Taylor, {Andy F. S.} and Steve Woodward",
note = "Journal open online, not CC-BY. REF Exception required.",
year = "2017",
month = "1",
language = "English",
volume = "23",
pages = "116--140",
journal = "Baltic Forestry",
issn = "1392-1355",
publisher = "Lietuvos Misku Institutas",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Challenges in assessing the ecological impacts of tree diseases and mitigation measures

T2 - the case of Hymenoscyphus fraxineus and Fraxinus excelsior

AU - Mitchell, R. J.

AU - Broome, A.

AU - Beaton, Joan K.

AU - Bellamy, Paul E.

AU - Ellis, Chris J.

AU - Hester, Alison J.

AU - Hodgetts, Nick G.

AU - Iason, Glenn R.

AU - Littlewood, Nick A.

AU - Newey, Scott

AU - Pozsgai, Gabor

AU - Ramsay, Scot

AU - Riach, David

AU - Stockan, Jenni A.

AU - Taylor, Andy F. S.

AU - Woodward, Steve

N1 - Journal open online, not CC-BY. REF Exception required.

PY - 2017/1

Y1 - 2017/1

N2 - Forests worldwide are currently threatened by a number of non-native tree diseases. Widespread death of a tree species will have ecological impacts on species that in some way depend on that tree species to complete their life-cycle. One measure to mitigate these impacts is to establish alternative tree species to replace the threatened tree species. These alternative tree species should be as similar as possible to the threatened tree species in terms of species supported, tree traits and the environmental conditions under which the tree will grow. This study assesses the availability and quality of data to assess the ecological impact of Hymenoscyphus fraxineus on Fraxinus excelsior and the suitability of 48 alternative trees to replace F. excelsior in the UK. To make this assessment data were collected on 1) species use (whether the 955 ash-associated species will use the alternative tree species), 2) traits (bark pH, deciduous, floral reward, fruit type, height, leaf dry matter content, leaf shape, length of flowering time, mycorrhizal association, pollen vector and specific leaf area) and 3) site requirements (occurrence within northern/southern and upland/lowland Britain, detailed climatic and soil nutrient requirements). For all three assessment methods there was lower confidence in the suitability of non-native tree species to replace F. excelsior due to lack of data. Different alternative tree species were ranked most suitable depending on the methods used. We conclude that no one species is suited to all the site types associated with F. excelsior, nor will any one tree species support a high percentage of the ash-associated species while also matching many of the traits of F. excelsior. Our work provides broad guidance on the suitability of the 48 alternatives but site specific information is required to refine this selection at each site. The study highlights a lack of information to make a full assessment of the suitability of many species, particularly non-native species and calls for the collation of biological records so that rapid assessments of the potential ecological impacts of the loss of any given tree species and the suitability of their alternative tree species can be made.

AB - Forests worldwide are currently threatened by a number of non-native tree diseases. Widespread death of a tree species will have ecological impacts on species that in some way depend on that tree species to complete their life-cycle. One measure to mitigate these impacts is to establish alternative tree species to replace the threatened tree species. These alternative tree species should be as similar as possible to the threatened tree species in terms of species supported, tree traits and the environmental conditions under which the tree will grow. This study assesses the availability and quality of data to assess the ecological impact of Hymenoscyphus fraxineus on Fraxinus excelsior and the suitability of 48 alternative trees to replace F. excelsior in the UK. To make this assessment data were collected on 1) species use (whether the 955 ash-associated species will use the alternative tree species), 2) traits (bark pH, deciduous, floral reward, fruit type, height, leaf dry matter content, leaf shape, length of flowering time, mycorrhizal association, pollen vector and specific leaf area) and 3) site requirements (occurrence within northern/southern and upland/lowland Britain, detailed climatic and soil nutrient requirements). For all three assessment methods there was lower confidence in the suitability of non-native tree species to replace F. excelsior due to lack of data. Different alternative tree species were ranked most suitable depending on the methods used. We conclude that no one species is suited to all the site types associated with F. excelsior, nor will any one tree species support a high percentage of the ash-associated species while also matching many of the traits of F. excelsior. Our work provides broad guidance on the suitability of the 48 alternatives but site specific information is required to refine this selection at each site. The study highlights a lack of information to make a full assessment of the suitability of many species, particularly non-native species and calls for the collation of biological records so that rapid assessments of the potential ecological impacts of the loss of any given tree species and the suitability of their alternative tree species can be made.

M3 - Article

VL - 23

SP - 116

EP - 140

JO - Baltic Forestry

JF - Baltic Forestry

SN - 1392-1355

IS - 1

ER -