Challenges in confirming eradication success of invasive red-eared sliders

Pablo García-Díaz (Corresponding Author), David S. L. Ramsey, Andrew P. Woolnough, Marc Franch, Gustavo A. Llorente, Albert Montori, Xabier Buenetxea, Asier R. Larrinaga, Matthieu Lasceve, Alberto Álvarez, José María Traverso, Aitor Valdeón, Ariñe Crespo, Virginia Rada, Enrique Ayllón, Vicente Sancho, J. Ignacio Lacomba, José Vicente Bataller, Miguel Lizana

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

4 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Confirming eradication success can be notoriously difficult and costly, especially when the species is still present but remains undetected, due to very low population densities and imperfect detection methods. There has been a lack of research on appropriate guidelines and estimation procedures for declaring eradication success for programs aimed at eradicating alien reptiles. Here we develop quantitative rules for confirmation monitoring in eradication campaigns of the red-eared slider turtle (Trachemys scripta elegans). We used a database of slider trapping data from control and eradication campaigns conducted in localities across the Iberian Peninsula and southern France to construct models for inferring appropriate trapping efforts for confirming slider turtle eradication. Basking traps were slightly more efficient than net traps in capturing sliders, although trapping was an inefficient monitoring method given the low capture probabilities estimated. The results of our spatially-explicit eradication scenarios revealed the importance of habitat configuration in declaring eradication success. Declaration of eradication success is contingent on the thresholds set to minimise false positives (i.e., falsely declaring eradication successful), but in any scenario large trapping efforts were required to confirm eradication. Given the low estimated capture probabilities, alternative methods such as eDNA and visual surveys should be considered for monitoring sliders. We suggest that if the costs associated with the impact of alien sliders can be adequately estimated, then eradication can be confirmed by rules minimising both false positive and negative error rates. Otherwise, rules minimising false positive errors would be more appropriate.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)2739-2750
Number of pages11
JournalBiological Invasions
Volume19
Issue number9
Early online date16 Jun 2017
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Sep 2017

Fingerprint

trapping
turtle
turtles
monitoring
traps
Trachemys scripta
detection method
reptile
Iberian Peninsula
reptiles
population density
France
methodology
habitat
habitats
cost
method

Keywords

  • Alien reptile
  • Capture probability
  • Environmental decision-making
  • False positive
  • Monitoring
  • Trachemys scripta elegans

Cite this

García-Díaz, P., Ramsey, D. S. L., Woolnough, A. P., Franch, M., Llorente, G. A., Montori, A., ... Lizana, M. (2017). Challenges in confirming eradication success of invasive red-eared sliders. Biological Invasions, 19(9), 2739-2750. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10530-017-1480-7

Challenges in confirming eradication success of invasive red-eared sliders. / García-Díaz, Pablo (Corresponding Author); Ramsey, David S. L.; Woolnough, Andrew P.; Franch, Marc; Llorente, Gustavo A.; Montori, Albert; Buenetxea, Xabier; Larrinaga, Asier R.; Lasceve, Matthieu; Álvarez, Alberto; Traverso, José María; Valdeón, Aitor; Crespo, Ariñe; Rada, Virginia; Ayllón, Enrique; Sancho, Vicente; Lacomba, J. Ignacio; Bataller, José Vicente; Lizana, Miguel.

In: Biological Invasions, Vol. 19, No. 9, 09.2017, p. 2739-2750.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

García-Díaz, P, Ramsey, DSL, Woolnough, AP, Franch, M, Llorente, GA, Montori, A, Buenetxea, X, Larrinaga, AR, Lasceve, M, Álvarez, A, Traverso, JM, Valdeón, A, Crespo, A, Rada, V, Ayllón, E, Sancho, V, Lacomba, JI, Bataller, JV & Lizana, M 2017, 'Challenges in confirming eradication success of invasive red-eared sliders', Biological Invasions, vol. 19, no. 9, pp. 2739-2750. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10530-017-1480-7
García-Díaz, Pablo ; Ramsey, David S. L. ; Woolnough, Andrew P. ; Franch, Marc ; Llorente, Gustavo A. ; Montori, Albert ; Buenetxea, Xabier ; Larrinaga, Asier R. ; Lasceve, Matthieu ; Álvarez, Alberto ; Traverso, José María ; Valdeón, Aitor ; Crespo, Ariñe ; Rada, Virginia ; Ayllón, Enrique ; Sancho, Vicente ; Lacomba, J. Ignacio ; Bataller, José Vicente ; Lizana, Miguel. / Challenges in confirming eradication success of invasive red-eared sliders. In: Biological Invasions. 2017 ; Vol. 19, No. 9. pp. 2739-2750.
@article{14eff7aa31f04e9eb899d9a6852067a7,
title = "Challenges in confirming eradication success of invasive red-eared sliders",
abstract = "Confirming eradication success can be notoriously difficult and costly, especially when the species is still present but remains undetected, due to very low population densities and imperfect detection methods. There has been a lack of research on appropriate guidelines and estimation procedures for declaring eradication success for programs aimed at eradicating alien reptiles. Here we develop quantitative rules for confirmation monitoring in eradication campaigns of the red-eared slider turtle (Trachemys scripta elegans). We used a database of slider trapping data from control and eradication campaigns conducted in localities across the Iberian Peninsula and southern France to construct models for inferring appropriate trapping efforts for confirming slider turtle eradication. Basking traps were slightly more efficient than net traps in capturing sliders, although trapping was an inefficient monitoring method given the low capture probabilities estimated. The results of our spatially-explicit eradication scenarios revealed the importance of habitat configuration in declaring eradication success. Declaration of eradication success is contingent on the thresholds set to minimise false positives (i.e., falsely declaring eradication successful), but in any scenario large trapping efforts were required to confirm eradication. Given the low estimated capture probabilities, alternative methods such as eDNA and visual surveys should be considered for monitoring sliders. We suggest that if the costs associated with the impact of alien sliders can be adequately estimated, then eradication can be confirmed by rules minimising both false positive and negative error rates. Otherwise, rules minimising false positive errors would be more appropriate.",
keywords = "Alien reptile, Capture probability, Environmental decision-making, False positive, Monitoring, Trachemys scripta elegans",
author = "Pablo Garc{\'i}a-D{\'i}az and Ramsey, {David S. L.} and Woolnough, {Andrew P.} and Marc Franch and Llorente, {Gustavo A.} and Albert Montori and Xabier Buenetxea and Larrinaga, {Asier R.} and Matthieu Lasceve and Alberto {\'A}lvarez and Traverso, {Jos{\'e} Mar{\'i}a} and Aitor Valde{\'o}n and Ari{\~n}e Crespo and Virginia Rada and Enrique Ayll{\'o}n and Vicente Sancho and Lacomba, {J. Ignacio} and Bataller, {Jos{\'e} Vicente} and Miguel Lizana",
note = "This research was conducted thanks to the Department of Economic Development, Jobs, Transport and Resources Invasive Plants and Animals Research Project When to stop: Defining rules for surveillance of red-eared slider turtles (Victoria State Government, Australia). We want to thank C. Ayres, J.V. Ross, A. Rodr{\'i}guez-Pereira, P. Cassey, N. Ainsworth, two anonymous reviewers, and the editor for their comments, support and help. The slider trapping campaigns were possible thanks to the funding, help and support provided by many institutions and people. Full acknowledgments are available in Online Resource 1.",
year = "2017",
month = "9",
doi = "10.1007/s10530-017-1480-7",
language = "English",
volume = "19",
pages = "2739--2750",
journal = "Biological Invasions",
issn = "1387-3547",
publisher = "Springer Netherlands",
number = "9",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Challenges in confirming eradication success of invasive red-eared sliders

AU - García-Díaz, Pablo

AU - Ramsey, David S. L.

AU - Woolnough, Andrew P.

AU - Franch, Marc

AU - Llorente, Gustavo A.

AU - Montori, Albert

AU - Buenetxea, Xabier

AU - Larrinaga, Asier R.

AU - Lasceve, Matthieu

AU - Álvarez, Alberto

AU - Traverso, José María

AU - Valdeón, Aitor

AU - Crespo, Ariñe

AU - Rada, Virginia

AU - Ayllón, Enrique

AU - Sancho, Vicente

AU - Lacomba, J. Ignacio

AU - Bataller, José Vicente

AU - Lizana, Miguel

N1 - This research was conducted thanks to the Department of Economic Development, Jobs, Transport and Resources Invasive Plants and Animals Research Project When to stop: Defining rules for surveillance of red-eared slider turtles (Victoria State Government, Australia). We want to thank C. Ayres, J.V. Ross, A. Rodríguez-Pereira, P. Cassey, N. Ainsworth, two anonymous reviewers, and the editor for their comments, support and help. The slider trapping campaigns were possible thanks to the funding, help and support provided by many institutions and people. Full acknowledgments are available in Online Resource 1.

PY - 2017/9

Y1 - 2017/9

N2 - Confirming eradication success can be notoriously difficult and costly, especially when the species is still present but remains undetected, due to very low population densities and imperfect detection methods. There has been a lack of research on appropriate guidelines and estimation procedures for declaring eradication success for programs aimed at eradicating alien reptiles. Here we develop quantitative rules for confirmation monitoring in eradication campaigns of the red-eared slider turtle (Trachemys scripta elegans). We used a database of slider trapping data from control and eradication campaigns conducted in localities across the Iberian Peninsula and southern France to construct models for inferring appropriate trapping efforts for confirming slider turtle eradication. Basking traps were slightly more efficient than net traps in capturing sliders, although trapping was an inefficient monitoring method given the low capture probabilities estimated. The results of our spatially-explicit eradication scenarios revealed the importance of habitat configuration in declaring eradication success. Declaration of eradication success is contingent on the thresholds set to minimise false positives (i.e., falsely declaring eradication successful), but in any scenario large trapping efforts were required to confirm eradication. Given the low estimated capture probabilities, alternative methods such as eDNA and visual surveys should be considered for monitoring sliders. We suggest that if the costs associated with the impact of alien sliders can be adequately estimated, then eradication can be confirmed by rules minimising both false positive and negative error rates. Otherwise, rules minimising false positive errors would be more appropriate.

AB - Confirming eradication success can be notoriously difficult and costly, especially when the species is still present but remains undetected, due to very low population densities and imperfect detection methods. There has been a lack of research on appropriate guidelines and estimation procedures for declaring eradication success for programs aimed at eradicating alien reptiles. Here we develop quantitative rules for confirmation monitoring in eradication campaigns of the red-eared slider turtle (Trachemys scripta elegans). We used a database of slider trapping data from control and eradication campaigns conducted in localities across the Iberian Peninsula and southern France to construct models for inferring appropriate trapping efforts for confirming slider turtle eradication. Basking traps were slightly more efficient than net traps in capturing sliders, although trapping was an inefficient monitoring method given the low capture probabilities estimated. The results of our spatially-explicit eradication scenarios revealed the importance of habitat configuration in declaring eradication success. Declaration of eradication success is contingent on the thresholds set to minimise false positives (i.e., falsely declaring eradication successful), but in any scenario large trapping efforts were required to confirm eradication. Given the low estimated capture probabilities, alternative methods such as eDNA and visual surveys should be considered for monitoring sliders. We suggest that if the costs associated with the impact of alien sliders can be adequately estimated, then eradication can be confirmed by rules minimising both false positive and negative error rates. Otherwise, rules minimising false positive errors would be more appropriate.

KW - Alien reptile

KW - Capture probability

KW - Environmental decision-making

KW - False positive

KW - Monitoring

KW - Trachemys scripta elegans

U2 - 10.1007/s10530-017-1480-7

DO - 10.1007/s10530-017-1480-7

M3 - Article

VL - 19

SP - 2739

EP - 2750

JO - Biological Invasions

JF - Biological Invasions

SN - 1387-3547

IS - 9

ER -