Comparison of effects of different methods of culling red deer (Cervus elaphus) by shooting on behaviour and post-mortem measurements of blood chemistry, muscle glycogen and carcase characteristics

M.S. Cockram, D.J. Shaw, E.M. Milne, Rosalind Bryce, C. McClean, M.J. Daniels

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

5 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Methods for culling wild red deer (Cervus elaphus) were compared by observing behaviour and collecting post mortem samples from wild deer shot: (i) by a single stalker during daytime; (ii) by more than one stalker during daytime; (iii) by using a helicopter for the deployment of stalkers and carcase extraction; or (iv) by a single stalker at night, and compared with farmed red deer shot in a field or killed at a slaughterhouse. Culling by a single stalker during the day and shooting in a field were the most accurate in achieving placement of a shot in a target area, but when compared across all methods, there were no significant differences in the percentages of deer that were either wounded or appeared to have died immediately after the first shot. Plasma cortisol concentrations in deer shot using helicopter assistance were similar to those in deer at the slaughterhouse, but higher than deer shot at night or during the day by a single stalker, or in a field. Deer shot using helicopter assistance and also deer culled by a collaborative and single stalking during the day had lower muscle glycogen concentrations than those culled by a single stalker at night. There was no evidence that a particular culling method was associated with an increased risk of accidental or pre-culling injury. If a helicopter is used to assist culling, the deer are more likely to be disturbed before they are shot and therefore, measures should be taken to minimise the disturbance to the deer.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)211-224
Number of pages14
JournalAnimal Welfare
Volume20
Issue number2
Publication statusPublished - 1 May 2011

Fingerprint

culling (animals)
blood chemistry
Deer
Cervus elaphus
Glycogen
Helicopters
deer
glycogen
Muscle
Blood
Muscles
muscles
helicopters
Aircraft
methodology
Abattoirs
Hydrocortisone
slaughterhouses
Plasmas
Stalking

Cite this

Comparison of effects of different methods of culling red deer (Cervus elaphus) by shooting on behaviour and post-mortem measurements of blood chemistry, muscle glycogen and carcase characteristics. / Cockram, M.S.; Shaw, D.J.; Milne, E.M.; Bryce, Rosalind; McClean, C.; Daniels, M.J.

In: Animal Welfare, Vol. 20, No. 2, 01.05.2011, p. 211-224.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{21e7be06601d459f8772cf83cc9ca99b,
title = "Comparison of effects of different methods of culling red deer (Cervus elaphus) by shooting on behaviour and post-mortem measurements of blood chemistry, muscle glycogen and carcase characteristics",
abstract = "Methods for culling wild red deer (Cervus elaphus) were compared by observing behaviour and collecting post mortem samples from wild deer shot: (i) by a single stalker during daytime; (ii) by more than one stalker during daytime; (iii) by using a helicopter for the deployment of stalkers and carcase extraction; or (iv) by a single stalker at night, and compared with farmed red deer shot in a field or killed at a slaughterhouse. Culling by a single stalker during the day and shooting in a field were the most accurate in achieving placement of a shot in a target area, but when compared across all methods, there were no significant differences in the percentages of deer that were either wounded or appeared to have died immediately after the first shot. Plasma cortisol concentrations in deer shot using helicopter assistance were similar to those in deer at the slaughterhouse, but higher than deer shot at night or during the day by a single stalker, or in a field. Deer shot using helicopter assistance and also deer culled by a collaborative and single stalking during the day had lower muscle glycogen concentrations than those culled by a single stalker at night. There was no evidence that a particular culling method was associated with an increased risk of accidental or pre-culling injury. If a helicopter is used to assist culling, the deer are more likely to be disturbed before they are shot and therefore, measures should be taken to minimise the disturbance to the deer.",
author = "M.S. Cockram and D.J. Shaw and E.M. Milne and Rosalind Bryce and C. McClean and M.J. Daniels",
year = "2011",
month = "5",
day = "1",
language = "English",
volume = "20",
pages = "211--224",
journal = "Animal Welfare",
issn = "0962-7286",
publisher = "Universities Federation for Animal Welfare",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Comparison of effects of different methods of culling red deer (Cervus elaphus) by shooting on behaviour and post-mortem measurements of blood chemistry, muscle glycogen and carcase characteristics

AU - Cockram, M.S.

AU - Shaw, D.J.

AU - Milne, E.M.

AU - Bryce, Rosalind

AU - McClean, C.

AU - Daniels, M.J.

PY - 2011/5/1

Y1 - 2011/5/1

N2 - Methods for culling wild red deer (Cervus elaphus) were compared by observing behaviour and collecting post mortem samples from wild deer shot: (i) by a single stalker during daytime; (ii) by more than one stalker during daytime; (iii) by using a helicopter for the deployment of stalkers and carcase extraction; or (iv) by a single stalker at night, and compared with farmed red deer shot in a field or killed at a slaughterhouse. Culling by a single stalker during the day and shooting in a field were the most accurate in achieving placement of a shot in a target area, but when compared across all methods, there were no significant differences in the percentages of deer that were either wounded or appeared to have died immediately after the first shot. Plasma cortisol concentrations in deer shot using helicopter assistance were similar to those in deer at the slaughterhouse, but higher than deer shot at night or during the day by a single stalker, or in a field. Deer shot using helicopter assistance and also deer culled by a collaborative and single stalking during the day had lower muscle glycogen concentrations than those culled by a single stalker at night. There was no evidence that a particular culling method was associated with an increased risk of accidental or pre-culling injury. If a helicopter is used to assist culling, the deer are more likely to be disturbed before they are shot and therefore, measures should be taken to minimise the disturbance to the deer.

AB - Methods for culling wild red deer (Cervus elaphus) were compared by observing behaviour and collecting post mortem samples from wild deer shot: (i) by a single stalker during daytime; (ii) by more than one stalker during daytime; (iii) by using a helicopter for the deployment of stalkers and carcase extraction; or (iv) by a single stalker at night, and compared with farmed red deer shot in a field or killed at a slaughterhouse. Culling by a single stalker during the day and shooting in a field were the most accurate in achieving placement of a shot in a target area, but when compared across all methods, there were no significant differences in the percentages of deer that were either wounded or appeared to have died immediately after the first shot. Plasma cortisol concentrations in deer shot using helicopter assistance were similar to those in deer at the slaughterhouse, but higher than deer shot at night or during the day by a single stalker, or in a field. Deer shot using helicopter assistance and also deer culled by a collaborative and single stalking during the day had lower muscle glycogen concentrations than those culled by a single stalker at night. There was no evidence that a particular culling method was associated with an increased risk of accidental or pre-culling injury. If a helicopter is used to assist culling, the deer are more likely to be disturbed before they are shot and therefore, measures should be taken to minimise the disturbance to the deer.

M3 - Article

VL - 20

SP - 211

EP - 224

JO - Animal Welfare

JF - Animal Welfare

SN - 0962-7286

IS - 2

ER -