Comparison of sensorineural symptoms between UK orthopaedic surgeons and gynaecologists

S. C. Roberts, Kirsten Ann Harrild, J. Mollison, Elizabeth Murphy, George Patrick Ashcroft

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

2 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Background We have previously described significant differences in self-reported neurological symptoms of orthopaedic surgeons when compared to a group of gynaecologists. We suggested that this may be secondary to occupational sources of hand-transmitted vibration. The original study was intentionally brief and failed to address potential confounders. Aims To compare the prevalence of sensorineural symptoms between UK orthopaedic surgeons and gynaecologists and adjust for potential confounding factors.
Methods Postal questionnaires were sent to 2040 members of the British Orthopaedic Association and 1797 members of the Royal College of Gynaecologists requesting information about demographics and self-reported neurological symptoms. Demographics of the orthopaedic surgeons and gynaecologists were compared using chi-squared tests and independent t-tests. Multiple logistic regressions were carried out to compare the prevalence of symptoms while adjusting for potential confounding factors.
Results Differences in the demographic profile of the orthopaedic surgeons and gynaecologists were identified: orthopaedic surgeons were predominantly male, were more junior in grade, were younger, used double gloving more often, had larger glove size, were more likely to be ambidextrous, to use vibrating tools outside of work and to consume greater amounts of alcohol. Orthopaedic surgeons reported a higher prevalence of tingling and numbness of fingers while at work and at other times. These differences were significant even after adjusting for potential confounding factors.
Conclusion Observed differences could be related to exposure to hand-transmitted vibration at work. Further assessment of risk to orthopaedic surgeons from hand-held power tools used in the course of their work is recommended.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)104-111
Number of pages8
JournalOccupational Medicine
Volume57
Issue number2
Early online date6 Dec 2006
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Mar 2007

Keywords

  • hand-transmitted vibration
  • occupational health
  • orthopaedic surgeons
  • power tools
  • sensorineural symptoms
  • upper limb
  • arm vibration syndrome
  • Raynauds phenomenon
  • white finger
  • disability

Cite this

Comparison of sensorineural symptoms between UK orthopaedic surgeons and gynaecologists. / Roberts, S. C.; Harrild, Kirsten Ann; Mollison, J.; Murphy, Elizabeth; Ashcroft, George Patrick.

In: Occupational Medicine, Vol. 57, No. 2, 03.2007, p. 104-111.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Roberts, S. C. ; Harrild, Kirsten Ann ; Mollison, J. ; Murphy, Elizabeth ; Ashcroft, George Patrick. / Comparison of sensorineural symptoms between UK orthopaedic surgeons and gynaecologists. In: Occupational Medicine. 2007 ; Vol. 57, No. 2. pp. 104-111.
@article{a93e358b031f4beeb1b13a10cd973ed8,
title = "Comparison of sensorineural symptoms between UK orthopaedic surgeons and gynaecologists",
abstract = "Background We have previously described significant differences in self-reported neurological symptoms of orthopaedic surgeons when compared to a group of gynaecologists. We suggested that this may be secondary to occupational sources of hand-transmitted vibration. The original study was intentionally brief and failed to address potential confounders. Aims To compare the prevalence of sensorineural symptoms between UK orthopaedic surgeons and gynaecologists and adjust for potential confounding factors. Methods Postal questionnaires were sent to 2040 members of the British Orthopaedic Association and 1797 members of the Royal College of Gynaecologists requesting information about demographics and self-reported neurological symptoms. Demographics of the orthopaedic surgeons and gynaecologists were compared using chi-squared tests and independent t-tests. Multiple logistic regressions were carried out to compare the prevalence of symptoms while adjusting for potential confounding factors. Results Differences in the demographic profile of the orthopaedic surgeons and gynaecologists were identified: orthopaedic surgeons were predominantly male, were more junior in grade, were younger, used double gloving more often, had larger glove size, were more likely to be ambidextrous, to use vibrating tools outside of work and to consume greater amounts of alcohol. Orthopaedic surgeons reported a higher prevalence of tingling and numbness of fingers while at work and at other times. These differences were significant even after adjusting for potential confounding factors. Conclusion Observed differences could be related to exposure to hand-transmitted vibration at work. Further assessment of risk to orthopaedic surgeons from hand-held power tools used in the course of their work is recommended.",
keywords = "hand-transmitted vibration, occupational health, orthopaedic surgeons, power tools, sensorineural symptoms, upper limb, arm vibration syndrome, Raynauds phenomenon, white finger, disability",
author = "Roberts, {S. C.} and Harrild, {Kirsten Ann} and J. Mollison and Elizabeth Murphy and Ashcroft, {George Patrick}",
year = "2007",
month = "3",
doi = "10.1093/occmed/kql141",
language = "English",
volume = "57",
pages = "104--111",
journal = "Occupational Medicine",
issn = "0962-7480",
publisher = "Oxford University Press",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Comparison of sensorineural symptoms between UK orthopaedic surgeons and gynaecologists

AU - Roberts, S. C.

AU - Harrild, Kirsten Ann

AU - Mollison, J.

AU - Murphy, Elizabeth

AU - Ashcroft, George Patrick

PY - 2007/3

Y1 - 2007/3

N2 - Background We have previously described significant differences in self-reported neurological symptoms of orthopaedic surgeons when compared to a group of gynaecologists. We suggested that this may be secondary to occupational sources of hand-transmitted vibration. The original study was intentionally brief and failed to address potential confounders. Aims To compare the prevalence of sensorineural symptoms between UK orthopaedic surgeons and gynaecologists and adjust for potential confounding factors. Methods Postal questionnaires were sent to 2040 members of the British Orthopaedic Association and 1797 members of the Royal College of Gynaecologists requesting information about demographics and self-reported neurological symptoms. Demographics of the orthopaedic surgeons and gynaecologists were compared using chi-squared tests and independent t-tests. Multiple logistic regressions were carried out to compare the prevalence of symptoms while adjusting for potential confounding factors. Results Differences in the demographic profile of the orthopaedic surgeons and gynaecologists were identified: orthopaedic surgeons were predominantly male, were more junior in grade, were younger, used double gloving more often, had larger glove size, were more likely to be ambidextrous, to use vibrating tools outside of work and to consume greater amounts of alcohol. Orthopaedic surgeons reported a higher prevalence of tingling and numbness of fingers while at work and at other times. These differences were significant even after adjusting for potential confounding factors. Conclusion Observed differences could be related to exposure to hand-transmitted vibration at work. Further assessment of risk to orthopaedic surgeons from hand-held power tools used in the course of their work is recommended.

AB - Background We have previously described significant differences in self-reported neurological symptoms of orthopaedic surgeons when compared to a group of gynaecologists. We suggested that this may be secondary to occupational sources of hand-transmitted vibration. The original study was intentionally brief and failed to address potential confounders. Aims To compare the prevalence of sensorineural symptoms between UK orthopaedic surgeons and gynaecologists and adjust for potential confounding factors. Methods Postal questionnaires were sent to 2040 members of the British Orthopaedic Association and 1797 members of the Royal College of Gynaecologists requesting information about demographics and self-reported neurological symptoms. Demographics of the orthopaedic surgeons and gynaecologists were compared using chi-squared tests and independent t-tests. Multiple logistic regressions were carried out to compare the prevalence of symptoms while adjusting for potential confounding factors. Results Differences in the demographic profile of the orthopaedic surgeons and gynaecologists were identified: orthopaedic surgeons were predominantly male, were more junior in grade, were younger, used double gloving more often, had larger glove size, were more likely to be ambidextrous, to use vibrating tools outside of work and to consume greater amounts of alcohol. Orthopaedic surgeons reported a higher prevalence of tingling and numbness of fingers while at work and at other times. These differences were significant even after adjusting for potential confounding factors. Conclusion Observed differences could be related to exposure to hand-transmitted vibration at work. Further assessment of risk to orthopaedic surgeons from hand-held power tools used in the course of their work is recommended.

KW - hand-transmitted vibration

KW - occupational health

KW - orthopaedic surgeons

KW - power tools

KW - sensorineural symptoms

KW - upper limb

KW - arm vibration syndrome

KW - Raynauds phenomenon

KW - white finger

KW - disability

U2 - 10.1093/occmed/kql141

DO - 10.1093/occmed/kql141

M3 - Article

VL - 57

SP - 104

EP - 111

JO - Occupational Medicine

JF - Occupational Medicine

SN - 0962-7480

IS - 2

ER -