Consequences of invasion by the alien plant Mimulus guttatus on the species composition and soil properties of riparian plant communities in Scotland

Anne-Marie Truscott, Christopher Soulsby, Steve C Palmer, Chris Soulsby, Sally Westaway, Phil E Hulme

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

27 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Invasive plantspecies are widely recognised to have severe ecological impacts in a wide range of ecosystems throughout the world, yet there are few experimental studies measuring community-level effects of invasive plantspecies. Thus most evidence is from correlative studies, and as such often cannot easily disentangle cause and effect. Through a combination of an addition and removal experiment and a correlative approach (multi-site comparisons), this study aimed to quantify the effects of a widespread invasive species, Mimulusguttatus, on species richness and soilproperties of riparianplantcommunities.

The marked negative association between Mimulus cover and plantspecies richness identified through correlative multi-site comparisons was consistent with experimental removal studies which indicate Mimulus significantly alters the structure of riparianplantcommunities. Total C and N and soil moisture were marginally higher in invaded than in uninvaded disturbed sediment plots. Following Mimulus removal, there was an increase in the occurrence and abundance of another non-native species, Claytonia sibirica, as well as germination and establishment of Mimulus seedlings. This highlights that, although removal increased richness, bringing the plantcommunity closer structurally to uninvaded vegetation, the application of removal as a management tool needs to be undertaken with caution, as it may create opportunities for other invaders.

The impact of Mimulus appeared restricted to disturbed sediment communities, as addition experiments into herb–grass communities were relatively unsuccessful in establishing Mimulus. These patterns were consistent with the distribution of the species in riparianplantcommunities. The addition experiments highlight that, as well as competition from the resident vegetation community, mollusc herbivory further hinders the establishment of Mimulus. Many manipulation studies have removed invasive plantspecies from heavily invaded communities, and it is often thought that invasive species usually affect plantcommunity structure only where their cover is high. This study is unique in demonstrating impacts where cover of the invasive plant is relatively low.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)231-240
Number of pages10
JournalPerspectives in plant ecology, evolution and systematics
Volume10
Issue number4
Early online date24 Jun 2008
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Oct 2008

Fingerprint

Mimulus guttatus
Mimulus
introduced plants
Scotland
plant community
plant communities
soil properties
soil property
species diversity
invasive species
removal experiment
vegetation
ecological impact
herbivory
Claytonia
mollusc
sediment
germination
experimental study
soil moisture

Keywords

  • addition experiments
  • biodiversity
  • biological invasions
  • ecosystems impacts
  • removal experiments

Cite this

@article{67b8ad8a2a584b2681d88bc8478cfef0,
title = "Consequences of invasion by the alien plant Mimulus guttatus on the species composition and soil properties of riparian plant communities in Scotland",
abstract = "Invasive plantspecies are widely recognised to have severe ecological impacts in a wide range of ecosystems throughout the world, yet there are few experimental studies measuring community-level effects of invasive plantspecies. Thus most evidence is from correlative studies, and as such often cannot easily disentangle cause and effect. Through a combination of an addition and removal experiment and a correlative approach (multi-site comparisons), this study aimed to quantify the effects of a widespread invasive species, Mimulusguttatus, on species richness and soilproperties of riparianplantcommunities. The marked negative association between Mimulus cover and plantspecies richness identified through correlative multi-site comparisons was consistent with experimental removal studies which indicate Mimulus significantly alters the structure of riparianplantcommunities. Total C and N and soil moisture were marginally higher in invaded than in uninvaded disturbed sediment plots. Following Mimulus removal, there was an increase in the occurrence and abundance of another non-native species, Claytonia sibirica, as well as germination and establishment of Mimulus seedlings. This highlights that, although removal increased richness, bringing the plantcommunity closer structurally to uninvaded vegetation, the application of removal as a management tool needs to be undertaken with caution, as it may create opportunities for other invaders. The impact of Mimulus appeared restricted to disturbed sediment communities, as addition experiments into herb–grass communities were relatively unsuccessful in establishing Mimulus. These patterns were consistent with the distribution of the species in riparianplantcommunities. The addition experiments highlight that, as well as competition from the resident vegetation community, mollusc herbivory further hinders the establishment of Mimulus. Many manipulation studies have removed invasive plantspecies from heavily invaded communities, and it is often thought that invasive species usually affect plantcommunity structure only where their cover is high. This study is unique in demonstrating impacts where cover of the invasive plant is relatively low.",
keywords = "addition experiments, biodiversity, biological invasions, ecosystems impacts, removal experiments",
author = "Anne-Marie Truscott and Christopher Soulsby and Palmer, {Steve C} and Chris Soulsby and Sally Westaway and Hulme, {Phil E}",
year = "2008",
month = "10",
doi = "10.1016/j.ppees.2008.04.001",
language = "English",
volume = "10",
pages = "231--240",
journal = "Perspectives in plant ecology, evolution and systematics",
issn = "1433-8319",
publisher = "Urban und Fischer Verlag Jena",
number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Consequences of invasion by the alien plant Mimulus guttatus on the species composition and soil properties of riparian plant communities in Scotland

AU - Truscott, Anne-Marie

AU - Soulsby, Christopher

AU - Palmer, Steve C

AU - Soulsby, Chris

AU - Westaway, Sally

AU - Hulme, Phil E

PY - 2008/10

Y1 - 2008/10

N2 - Invasive plantspecies are widely recognised to have severe ecological impacts in a wide range of ecosystems throughout the world, yet there are few experimental studies measuring community-level effects of invasive plantspecies. Thus most evidence is from correlative studies, and as such often cannot easily disentangle cause and effect. Through a combination of an addition and removal experiment and a correlative approach (multi-site comparisons), this study aimed to quantify the effects of a widespread invasive species, Mimulusguttatus, on species richness and soilproperties of riparianplantcommunities. The marked negative association between Mimulus cover and plantspecies richness identified through correlative multi-site comparisons was consistent with experimental removal studies which indicate Mimulus significantly alters the structure of riparianplantcommunities. Total C and N and soil moisture were marginally higher in invaded than in uninvaded disturbed sediment plots. Following Mimulus removal, there was an increase in the occurrence and abundance of another non-native species, Claytonia sibirica, as well as germination and establishment of Mimulus seedlings. This highlights that, although removal increased richness, bringing the plantcommunity closer structurally to uninvaded vegetation, the application of removal as a management tool needs to be undertaken with caution, as it may create opportunities for other invaders. The impact of Mimulus appeared restricted to disturbed sediment communities, as addition experiments into herb–grass communities were relatively unsuccessful in establishing Mimulus. These patterns were consistent with the distribution of the species in riparianplantcommunities. The addition experiments highlight that, as well as competition from the resident vegetation community, mollusc herbivory further hinders the establishment of Mimulus. Many manipulation studies have removed invasive plantspecies from heavily invaded communities, and it is often thought that invasive species usually affect plantcommunity structure only where their cover is high. This study is unique in demonstrating impacts where cover of the invasive plant is relatively low.

AB - Invasive plantspecies are widely recognised to have severe ecological impacts in a wide range of ecosystems throughout the world, yet there are few experimental studies measuring community-level effects of invasive plantspecies. Thus most evidence is from correlative studies, and as such often cannot easily disentangle cause and effect. Through a combination of an addition and removal experiment and a correlative approach (multi-site comparisons), this study aimed to quantify the effects of a widespread invasive species, Mimulusguttatus, on species richness and soilproperties of riparianplantcommunities. The marked negative association between Mimulus cover and plantspecies richness identified through correlative multi-site comparisons was consistent with experimental removal studies which indicate Mimulus significantly alters the structure of riparianplantcommunities. Total C and N and soil moisture were marginally higher in invaded than in uninvaded disturbed sediment plots. Following Mimulus removal, there was an increase in the occurrence and abundance of another non-native species, Claytonia sibirica, as well as germination and establishment of Mimulus seedlings. This highlights that, although removal increased richness, bringing the plantcommunity closer structurally to uninvaded vegetation, the application of removal as a management tool needs to be undertaken with caution, as it may create opportunities for other invaders. The impact of Mimulus appeared restricted to disturbed sediment communities, as addition experiments into herb–grass communities were relatively unsuccessful in establishing Mimulus. These patterns were consistent with the distribution of the species in riparianplantcommunities. The addition experiments highlight that, as well as competition from the resident vegetation community, mollusc herbivory further hinders the establishment of Mimulus. Many manipulation studies have removed invasive plantspecies from heavily invaded communities, and it is often thought that invasive species usually affect plantcommunity structure only where their cover is high. This study is unique in demonstrating impacts where cover of the invasive plant is relatively low.

KW - addition experiments

KW - biodiversity

KW - biological invasions

KW - ecosystems impacts

KW - removal experiments

U2 - 10.1016/j.ppees.2008.04.001

DO - 10.1016/j.ppees.2008.04.001

M3 - Article

VL - 10

SP - 231

EP - 240

JO - Perspectives in plant ecology, evolution and systematics

JF - Perspectives in plant ecology, evolution and systematics

SN - 1433-8319

IS - 4

ER -