Constructions of Ageing and Narrative Resistance in a Commercial Slimming Group

Debra Lynne Gimlin

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

10 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

This study focuses on the role of organisational setting and age in shaping individuals' narratives of embodied selfhood. It compares older and younger women's use of 'narrative resistance' to negotiate identity in light of their ageing and the negative social and personal meanings of being fat. Cordell and Ronai (1999) observed three types of narrative resistance among overweight people: loopholes, exemplars and continuums. This paper identifies two others: 'justifications', for behaviour that associated with weight gain, and 'repentance', for behaviour that reaffirmed a commitment to losing weight. Drawing from six months of participant-observation and in-depth interviews with 20 older and younger female clients of a commercial weight-loss organisation, this article shows that both the meanings women attributed to their experiences of slimming, and their opportunities for benefiting from organisational resources, varied by their stage in the lifecourse. The weight-loss group generated narrative strategies and opportunities for its members that were informed by both cultural constructions of ageing and the organisation's interests. While these strategies stopped short of empowering the clients to abandon restrictive dieting altogether, they did enable the older respondents to excuse temporary setbacks in weight loss and their deviation from (what they described as) the more exacting appearance standards of youth. At the same time, the strategic narratives reaffirmed constructions of ageing that present the older female body as uncontrollable and older women as unconcerned with physical attractiveness.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)407-424
Number of pages18
JournalAgeing and Society
Volume27
Issue number3
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2007

Keywords

  • women
  • ageing
  • body
  • weight loss
  • appearance
  • older womens perceptions
  • young adulthood
  • body-weight
  • adolescence
  • identity
  • slimness
  • images
  • life
  • men

Cite this

Constructions of Ageing and Narrative Resistance in a Commercial Slimming Group. / Gimlin, Debra Lynne.

In: Ageing and Society, Vol. 27, No. 3, 2007, p. 407-424.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Gimlin, Debra Lynne. / Constructions of Ageing and Narrative Resistance in a Commercial Slimming Group. In: Ageing and Society. 2007 ; Vol. 27, No. 3. pp. 407-424.
@article{ff5cc1d55897477498650824f61310d6,
title = "Constructions of Ageing and Narrative Resistance in a Commercial Slimming Group",
abstract = "This study focuses on the role of organisational setting and age in shaping individuals' narratives of embodied selfhood. It compares older and younger women's use of 'narrative resistance' to negotiate identity in light of their ageing and the negative social and personal meanings of being fat. Cordell and Ronai (1999) observed three types of narrative resistance among overweight people: loopholes, exemplars and continuums. This paper identifies two others: 'justifications', for behaviour that associated with weight gain, and 'repentance', for behaviour that reaffirmed a commitment to losing weight. Drawing from six months of participant-observation and in-depth interviews with 20 older and younger female clients of a commercial weight-loss organisation, this article shows that both the meanings women attributed to their experiences of slimming, and their opportunities for benefiting from organisational resources, varied by their stage in the lifecourse. The weight-loss group generated narrative strategies and opportunities for its members that were informed by both cultural constructions of ageing and the organisation's interests. While these strategies stopped short of empowering the clients to abandon restrictive dieting altogether, they did enable the older respondents to excuse temporary setbacks in weight loss and their deviation from (what they described as) the more exacting appearance standards of youth. At the same time, the strategic narratives reaffirmed constructions of ageing that present the older female body as uncontrollable and older women as unconcerned with physical attractiveness.",
keywords = "women, ageing, body, weight loss, appearance, older womens perceptions, young adulthood, body-weight, adolescence, identity, slimness, images, life, men",
author = "Gimlin, {Debra Lynne}",
year = "2007",
doi = "10.1017/S0144686X06005757",
language = "English",
volume = "27",
pages = "407--424",
journal = "Ageing and Society",
issn = "0144-686X",
publisher = "Cambridge University Press",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Constructions of Ageing and Narrative Resistance in a Commercial Slimming Group

AU - Gimlin, Debra Lynne

PY - 2007

Y1 - 2007

N2 - This study focuses on the role of organisational setting and age in shaping individuals' narratives of embodied selfhood. It compares older and younger women's use of 'narrative resistance' to negotiate identity in light of their ageing and the negative social and personal meanings of being fat. Cordell and Ronai (1999) observed three types of narrative resistance among overweight people: loopholes, exemplars and continuums. This paper identifies two others: 'justifications', for behaviour that associated with weight gain, and 'repentance', for behaviour that reaffirmed a commitment to losing weight. Drawing from six months of participant-observation and in-depth interviews with 20 older and younger female clients of a commercial weight-loss organisation, this article shows that both the meanings women attributed to their experiences of slimming, and their opportunities for benefiting from organisational resources, varied by their stage in the lifecourse. The weight-loss group generated narrative strategies and opportunities for its members that were informed by both cultural constructions of ageing and the organisation's interests. While these strategies stopped short of empowering the clients to abandon restrictive dieting altogether, they did enable the older respondents to excuse temporary setbacks in weight loss and their deviation from (what they described as) the more exacting appearance standards of youth. At the same time, the strategic narratives reaffirmed constructions of ageing that present the older female body as uncontrollable and older women as unconcerned with physical attractiveness.

AB - This study focuses on the role of organisational setting and age in shaping individuals' narratives of embodied selfhood. It compares older and younger women's use of 'narrative resistance' to negotiate identity in light of their ageing and the negative social and personal meanings of being fat. Cordell and Ronai (1999) observed three types of narrative resistance among overweight people: loopholes, exemplars and continuums. This paper identifies two others: 'justifications', for behaviour that associated with weight gain, and 'repentance', for behaviour that reaffirmed a commitment to losing weight. Drawing from six months of participant-observation and in-depth interviews with 20 older and younger female clients of a commercial weight-loss organisation, this article shows that both the meanings women attributed to their experiences of slimming, and their opportunities for benefiting from organisational resources, varied by their stage in the lifecourse. The weight-loss group generated narrative strategies and opportunities for its members that were informed by both cultural constructions of ageing and the organisation's interests. While these strategies stopped short of empowering the clients to abandon restrictive dieting altogether, they did enable the older respondents to excuse temporary setbacks in weight loss and their deviation from (what they described as) the more exacting appearance standards of youth. At the same time, the strategic narratives reaffirmed constructions of ageing that present the older female body as uncontrollable and older women as unconcerned with physical attractiveness.

KW - women

KW - ageing

KW - body

KW - weight loss

KW - appearance

KW - older womens perceptions

KW - young adulthood

KW - body-weight

KW - adolescence

KW - identity

KW - slimness

KW - images

KW - life

KW - men

U2 - 10.1017/S0144686X06005757

DO - 10.1017/S0144686X06005757

M3 - Article

VL - 27

SP - 407

EP - 424

JO - Ageing and Society

JF - Ageing and Society

SN - 0144-686X

IS - 3

ER -