Counting Llamas and Accounting for People

Livestock, Land and Citizens in Southern Bolivia

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

2 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

This paper uses historical and ethnographic data to examine the struggles that surround livestock enumeration in highland Bolivia. Colonial officials counted llamas for purposes of taxation, while present-day government agencies and NGOs enumerate animals to attract money from aid agencies and promote entrepreneurial activity. In both instances, livestock enumeration serves not just to count animals but to render accountable their owners. The paper argues, drawing upon the work of Timothy Mitchell (2002) that such enumerative procedures carried out by experts do not simply record a reality, but by rendering herders accountable, seek to produce particular kinds of people within particular economic realities. Far from being a culturally neutral practice, the enumeration of llamas can constitute an act of symbolic violence that seeks to erase specific relationships between herders and animals and to prioritise the individual over the communal. In both colonial and contemporary cases, Andean people seek to produce themselves in ways that contest those in which others would produce them.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)5-21
Number of pages17
JournalThe Sociological Review
Volume55
Issue number1
Early online date24 Jan 2007
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Feb 2007

Fingerprint

Bolivia
animal
citizen
symbolic violence
aid agency
government agency
taxation
non-governmental organization
money
expert
present
economics

Keywords

  • Andes
  • expertise
  • indigenous identity

Cite this

Counting Llamas and Accounting for People : Livestock, Land and Citizens in Southern Bolivia. / Bolton, Maggie.

In: The Sociological Review, Vol. 55, No. 1, 02.2007, p. 5-21.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{0efea542659d45868702198a9f50fc52,
title = "Counting Llamas and Accounting for People: Livestock, Land and Citizens in Southern Bolivia",
abstract = "This paper uses historical and ethnographic data to examine the struggles that surround livestock enumeration in highland Bolivia. Colonial officials counted llamas for purposes of taxation, while present-day government agencies and NGOs enumerate animals to attract money from aid agencies and promote entrepreneurial activity. In both instances, livestock enumeration serves not just to count animals but to render accountable their owners. The paper argues, drawing upon the work of Timothy Mitchell (2002) that such enumerative procedures carried out by experts do not simply record a reality, but by rendering herders accountable, seek to produce particular kinds of people within particular economic realities. Far from being a culturally neutral practice, the enumeration of llamas can constitute an act of symbolic violence that seeks to erase specific relationships between herders and animals and to prioritise the individual over the communal. In both colonial and contemporary cases, Andean people seek to produce themselves in ways that contest those in which others would produce them.",
keywords = "Andes , expertise, indigenous identity",
author = "Maggie Bolton",
year = "2007",
month = "2",
doi = "10.1111/j.1467-954X.2007.00680.x",
language = "English",
volume = "55",
pages = "5--21",
journal = "The Sociological Review",
issn = "0038-0261",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Counting Llamas and Accounting for People

T2 - Livestock, Land and Citizens in Southern Bolivia

AU - Bolton, Maggie

PY - 2007/2

Y1 - 2007/2

N2 - This paper uses historical and ethnographic data to examine the struggles that surround livestock enumeration in highland Bolivia. Colonial officials counted llamas for purposes of taxation, while present-day government agencies and NGOs enumerate animals to attract money from aid agencies and promote entrepreneurial activity. In both instances, livestock enumeration serves not just to count animals but to render accountable their owners. The paper argues, drawing upon the work of Timothy Mitchell (2002) that such enumerative procedures carried out by experts do not simply record a reality, but by rendering herders accountable, seek to produce particular kinds of people within particular economic realities. Far from being a culturally neutral practice, the enumeration of llamas can constitute an act of symbolic violence that seeks to erase specific relationships between herders and animals and to prioritise the individual over the communal. In both colonial and contemporary cases, Andean people seek to produce themselves in ways that contest those in which others would produce them.

AB - This paper uses historical and ethnographic data to examine the struggles that surround livestock enumeration in highland Bolivia. Colonial officials counted llamas for purposes of taxation, while present-day government agencies and NGOs enumerate animals to attract money from aid agencies and promote entrepreneurial activity. In both instances, livestock enumeration serves not just to count animals but to render accountable their owners. The paper argues, drawing upon the work of Timothy Mitchell (2002) that such enumerative procedures carried out by experts do not simply record a reality, but by rendering herders accountable, seek to produce particular kinds of people within particular economic realities. Far from being a culturally neutral practice, the enumeration of llamas can constitute an act of symbolic violence that seeks to erase specific relationships between herders and animals and to prioritise the individual over the communal. In both colonial and contemporary cases, Andean people seek to produce themselves in ways that contest those in which others would produce them.

KW - Andes

KW - expertise

KW - indigenous identity

U2 - 10.1111/j.1467-954X.2007.00680.x

DO - 10.1111/j.1467-954X.2007.00680.x

M3 - Article

VL - 55

SP - 5

EP - 21

JO - The Sociological Review

JF - The Sociological Review

SN - 0038-0261

IS - 1

ER -