Critical impact energies for scabbing and perforation of concrete target

Stephen R Reid, Q. M. Li, A. M. Ahmad-Zaidi

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

41 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

In this paper, the influences of the relative target thickness (H/d) on those critical impact energies, at which local damage of various forms in concrete targets are initiated, are explored. The empirical formulae developed in the R3 Impact Assessment Procedure [BNFL, 2003. Reinforced Concrete Slab Local Damage Assessment, R3 Impact Assessment Procedure, vol. 3, Appendix H. Magnox Electric plc & Nuclear Electric Limited] are rationalized by different methods. A dimensional analysis was conducted to identify influential non-dimensional numbers, which were subsequently employed in the analyses of the experimental results relevant to scabbing and perforation by flat nosed missiles.

The relationships between the non-dimensional impact energy 1/2 MV02(d(3)f) at failure and the non-dimensional target thickness H/d are presented 2 for all of the relevant experimental data in the "World Impact Data" collection [Bainbridge, P., 1988. World Impact Data-S.R.D. Impact Database Version Pre 3i, CCSD/CIWP(88)107(P)]. This collated hundreds of experimental data on local damage in concrete targets due to missile impact from various sources of nuclear industries, as well as experimental data from the UK electrical power industry used to develop empirical formulae in the R3 Impact Assessment Procedure [BNFL, 2003. Reinforced concrete slab local damage assessment, R3 Impact Assessment Procedure, vol. 3, Appendix H. Magnox Electric plc & Nuclear Electric Limited]. The experimental data in Bainbridge [Bainbridge, P., 1988. World Impact Data-S.R.D. Impact Database Version Pre 3i, CCSD/CIWP(88)107(P)] are compared with empirical and semi-empirical formulae for scabbing and perforation in order to examine the effects of H/d on the critical non-dimensional impact energy for these two local failures. An analytical formula based on a penetration-plugging model is employed to give the relationship between the critical impact energy and target thickness for perforation by a flat-ended projectile. Comparisons between these formulae and experimental data are presented. (C) 2005 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1140-1148
Number of pages8
JournalNuclear Engineering and Design
Volume236
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2006

Keywords

  • PROJECTILE IMPACT

Cite this

Critical impact energies for scabbing and perforation of concrete target. / Reid, Stephen R; Li, Q. M.; Ahmad-Zaidi, A. M.

In: Nuclear Engineering and Design, Vol. 236, 2006, p. 1140-1148.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{697f27ca0d6340dda2560a857708368f,
title = "Critical impact energies for scabbing and perforation of concrete target",
abstract = "In this paper, the influences of the relative target thickness (H/d) on those critical impact energies, at which local damage of various forms in concrete targets are initiated, are explored. The empirical formulae developed in the R3 Impact Assessment Procedure [BNFL, 2003. Reinforced Concrete Slab Local Damage Assessment, R3 Impact Assessment Procedure, vol. 3, Appendix H. Magnox Electric plc & Nuclear Electric Limited] are rationalized by different methods. A dimensional analysis was conducted to identify influential non-dimensional numbers, which were subsequently employed in the analyses of the experimental results relevant to scabbing and perforation by flat nosed missiles.The relationships between the non-dimensional impact energy 1/2 MV02(d(3)f) at failure and the non-dimensional target thickness H/d are presented 2 for all of the relevant experimental data in the {"}World Impact Data{"} collection [Bainbridge, P., 1988. World Impact Data-S.R.D. Impact Database Version Pre 3i, CCSD/CIWP(88)107(P)]. This collated hundreds of experimental data on local damage in concrete targets due to missile impact from various sources of nuclear industries, as well as experimental data from the UK electrical power industry used to develop empirical formulae in the R3 Impact Assessment Procedure [BNFL, 2003. Reinforced concrete slab local damage assessment, R3 Impact Assessment Procedure, vol. 3, Appendix H. Magnox Electric plc & Nuclear Electric Limited]. The experimental data in Bainbridge [Bainbridge, P., 1988. World Impact Data-S.R.D. Impact Database Version Pre 3i, CCSD/CIWP(88)107(P)] are compared with empirical and semi-empirical formulae for scabbing and perforation in order to examine the effects of H/d on the critical non-dimensional impact energy for these two local failures. An analytical formula based on a penetration-plugging model is employed to give the relationship between the critical impact energy and target thickness for perforation by a flat-ended projectile. Comparisons between these formulae and experimental data are presented. (C) 2005 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.",
keywords = "PROJECTILE IMPACT",
author = "Reid, {Stephen R} and Li, {Q. M.} and Ahmad-Zaidi, {A. M.}",
year = "2006",
doi = "10.1016/j.nucengdes.2005.10.017",
language = "English",
volume = "236",
pages = "1140--1148",
journal = "Nuclear Engineering and Design",
issn = "0029-5493",
publisher = "Elsevier BV",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Critical impact energies for scabbing and perforation of concrete target

AU - Reid, Stephen R

AU - Li, Q. M.

AU - Ahmad-Zaidi, A. M.

PY - 2006

Y1 - 2006

N2 - In this paper, the influences of the relative target thickness (H/d) on those critical impact energies, at which local damage of various forms in concrete targets are initiated, are explored. The empirical formulae developed in the R3 Impact Assessment Procedure [BNFL, 2003. Reinforced Concrete Slab Local Damage Assessment, R3 Impact Assessment Procedure, vol. 3, Appendix H. Magnox Electric plc & Nuclear Electric Limited] are rationalized by different methods. A dimensional analysis was conducted to identify influential non-dimensional numbers, which were subsequently employed in the analyses of the experimental results relevant to scabbing and perforation by flat nosed missiles.The relationships between the non-dimensional impact energy 1/2 MV02(d(3)f) at failure and the non-dimensional target thickness H/d are presented 2 for all of the relevant experimental data in the "World Impact Data" collection [Bainbridge, P., 1988. World Impact Data-S.R.D. Impact Database Version Pre 3i, CCSD/CIWP(88)107(P)]. This collated hundreds of experimental data on local damage in concrete targets due to missile impact from various sources of nuclear industries, as well as experimental data from the UK electrical power industry used to develop empirical formulae in the R3 Impact Assessment Procedure [BNFL, 2003. Reinforced concrete slab local damage assessment, R3 Impact Assessment Procedure, vol. 3, Appendix H. Magnox Electric plc & Nuclear Electric Limited]. The experimental data in Bainbridge [Bainbridge, P., 1988. World Impact Data-S.R.D. Impact Database Version Pre 3i, CCSD/CIWP(88)107(P)] are compared with empirical and semi-empirical formulae for scabbing and perforation in order to examine the effects of H/d on the critical non-dimensional impact energy for these two local failures. An analytical formula based on a penetration-plugging model is employed to give the relationship between the critical impact energy and target thickness for perforation by a flat-ended projectile. Comparisons between these formulae and experimental data are presented. (C) 2005 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

AB - In this paper, the influences of the relative target thickness (H/d) on those critical impact energies, at which local damage of various forms in concrete targets are initiated, are explored. The empirical formulae developed in the R3 Impact Assessment Procedure [BNFL, 2003. Reinforced Concrete Slab Local Damage Assessment, R3 Impact Assessment Procedure, vol. 3, Appendix H. Magnox Electric plc & Nuclear Electric Limited] are rationalized by different methods. A dimensional analysis was conducted to identify influential non-dimensional numbers, which were subsequently employed in the analyses of the experimental results relevant to scabbing and perforation by flat nosed missiles.The relationships between the non-dimensional impact energy 1/2 MV02(d(3)f) at failure and the non-dimensional target thickness H/d are presented 2 for all of the relevant experimental data in the "World Impact Data" collection [Bainbridge, P., 1988. World Impact Data-S.R.D. Impact Database Version Pre 3i, CCSD/CIWP(88)107(P)]. This collated hundreds of experimental data on local damage in concrete targets due to missile impact from various sources of nuclear industries, as well as experimental data from the UK electrical power industry used to develop empirical formulae in the R3 Impact Assessment Procedure [BNFL, 2003. Reinforced concrete slab local damage assessment, R3 Impact Assessment Procedure, vol. 3, Appendix H. Magnox Electric plc & Nuclear Electric Limited]. The experimental data in Bainbridge [Bainbridge, P., 1988. World Impact Data-S.R.D. Impact Database Version Pre 3i, CCSD/CIWP(88)107(P)] are compared with empirical and semi-empirical formulae for scabbing and perforation in order to examine the effects of H/d on the critical non-dimensional impact energy for these two local failures. An analytical formula based on a penetration-plugging model is employed to give the relationship between the critical impact energy and target thickness for perforation by a flat-ended projectile. Comparisons between these formulae and experimental data are presented. (C) 2005 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

KW - PROJECTILE IMPACT

U2 - 10.1016/j.nucengdes.2005.10.017

DO - 10.1016/j.nucengdes.2005.10.017

M3 - Article

VL - 236

SP - 1140

EP - 1148

JO - Nuclear Engineering and Design

JF - Nuclear Engineering and Design

SN - 0029-5493

ER -