Critical resolution: A superior measure of crowding

Leili Soo (Corresponding Author), Ramakrishna Chakravarthi, Soren K. Andersen

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

6 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Visual object recognition is essential for adaptive interactions with the environment. It is fundamentally limited by crowding, a breakdown of object recognition in clutter. The spatial extent over which crowding occurs is proportional to the eccentricity of the target object, but nevertheless varies substantially depending on various stimulus factors (e.g. viewing time, contrast). However, a lack of studies jointly manipulating such factors precludes predictions of crowding in more heterogeneous scenes, such as the majority of real life situations.
To establish how such co-occurring variations affect crowding, we manipulated combinations of 1) flanker contrast and backward masking, 2) flanker contrast and presentation duration, and 3) flanker preview and pop-out while measuring participants’ ability to correctly report the orientation of a target stimulus. In all three experiments, combining two manipulations consistently modulated the spatial extent of crowding in a way that could not be predicted from an additive combination. However, a simple transformation of the measurement scale completely abolished these interactions and all effects became additive. Precise quantitative predictions of the magnitude of crowding when combining multiple manipulations are thus possible when it is expressed in terms of what we label the ‘critical resolution’. Critical resolution is proportional to the inverse of the smallest flanker free area surrounding the target object necessary for its unimpaired identification. It offers a more parsimonious description of crowding than the traditionally used critical spacing and may thus constitute a measure of fundamental importance for understanding object recognition.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)13-23
Number of pages11
JournalVision Research
Volume153
Early online date18 Sep 2018
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Dec 2018

Keywords

  • object recognition
  • visual crowding
  • psychophysics
  • critical spacing
  • critical resolution
  • visual perception
  • flanker interference

Cite this

Critical resolution : A superior measure of crowding. / Soo, Leili (Corresponding Author); Chakravarthi, Ramakrishna; Andersen, Soren K.

In: Vision Research, Vol. 153, 12.2018, p. 13-23.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{e1a50788e7ac4c489875e2316d413bae,
title = "Critical resolution: A superior measure of crowding",
abstract = "Visual object recognition is essential for adaptive interactions with the environment. It is fundamentally limited by crowding, a breakdown of object recognition in clutter. The spatial extent over which crowding occurs is proportional to the eccentricity of the target object, but nevertheless varies substantially depending on various stimulus factors (e.g. viewing time, contrast). However, a lack of studies jointly manipulating such factors precludes predictions of crowding in more heterogeneous scenes, such as the majority of real life situations.To establish how such co-occurring variations affect crowding, we manipulated combinations of 1) flanker contrast and backward masking, 2) flanker contrast and presentation duration, and 3) flanker preview and pop-out while measuring participants’ ability to correctly report the orientation of a target stimulus. In all three experiments, combining two manipulations consistently modulated the spatial extent of crowding in a way that could not be predicted from an additive combination. However, a simple transformation of the measurement scale completely abolished these interactions and all effects became additive. Precise quantitative predictions of the magnitude of crowding when combining multiple manipulations are thus possible when it is expressed in terms of what we label the ‘critical resolution’. Critical resolution is proportional to the inverse of the smallest flanker free area surrounding the target object necessary for its unimpaired identification. It offers a more parsimonious description of crowding than the traditionally used critical spacing and may thus constitute a measure of fundamental importance for understanding object recognition.",
keywords = "object recognition, visual crowding, psychophysics, critical spacing, critical resolution, visual perception, flanker interference",
author = "Leili Soo and Ramakrishna Chakravarthi and Andersen, {Soren K.}",
note = "This work was supported by the Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (BBSRC) [grant number BB/J01446X/1]. We would like to thank our anonymous reviewers for their thoughtful feedback, which helped us fine-tune our proposal about critical resolution.",
year = "2018",
month = "12",
doi = "10.1016/j.visres.2018.08.005",
language = "English",
volume = "153",
pages = "13--23",
journal = "Vision Research",
issn = "0042-6989",
publisher = "Elsevier",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Critical resolution

T2 - A superior measure of crowding

AU - Soo, Leili

AU - Chakravarthi, Ramakrishna

AU - Andersen, Soren K.

N1 - This work was supported by the Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (BBSRC) [grant number BB/J01446X/1]. We would like to thank our anonymous reviewers for their thoughtful feedback, which helped us fine-tune our proposal about critical resolution.

PY - 2018/12

Y1 - 2018/12

N2 - Visual object recognition is essential for adaptive interactions with the environment. It is fundamentally limited by crowding, a breakdown of object recognition in clutter. The spatial extent over which crowding occurs is proportional to the eccentricity of the target object, but nevertheless varies substantially depending on various stimulus factors (e.g. viewing time, contrast). However, a lack of studies jointly manipulating such factors precludes predictions of crowding in more heterogeneous scenes, such as the majority of real life situations.To establish how such co-occurring variations affect crowding, we manipulated combinations of 1) flanker contrast and backward masking, 2) flanker contrast and presentation duration, and 3) flanker preview and pop-out while measuring participants’ ability to correctly report the orientation of a target stimulus. In all three experiments, combining two manipulations consistently modulated the spatial extent of crowding in a way that could not be predicted from an additive combination. However, a simple transformation of the measurement scale completely abolished these interactions and all effects became additive. Precise quantitative predictions of the magnitude of crowding when combining multiple manipulations are thus possible when it is expressed in terms of what we label the ‘critical resolution’. Critical resolution is proportional to the inverse of the smallest flanker free area surrounding the target object necessary for its unimpaired identification. It offers a more parsimonious description of crowding than the traditionally used critical spacing and may thus constitute a measure of fundamental importance for understanding object recognition.

AB - Visual object recognition is essential for adaptive interactions with the environment. It is fundamentally limited by crowding, a breakdown of object recognition in clutter. The spatial extent over which crowding occurs is proportional to the eccentricity of the target object, but nevertheless varies substantially depending on various stimulus factors (e.g. viewing time, contrast). However, a lack of studies jointly manipulating such factors precludes predictions of crowding in more heterogeneous scenes, such as the majority of real life situations.To establish how such co-occurring variations affect crowding, we manipulated combinations of 1) flanker contrast and backward masking, 2) flanker contrast and presentation duration, and 3) flanker preview and pop-out while measuring participants’ ability to correctly report the orientation of a target stimulus. In all three experiments, combining two manipulations consistently modulated the spatial extent of crowding in a way that could not be predicted from an additive combination. However, a simple transformation of the measurement scale completely abolished these interactions and all effects became additive. Precise quantitative predictions of the magnitude of crowding when combining multiple manipulations are thus possible when it is expressed in terms of what we label the ‘critical resolution’. Critical resolution is proportional to the inverse of the smallest flanker free area surrounding the target object necessary for its unimpaired identification. It offers a more parsimonious description of crowding than the traditionally used critical spacing and may thus constitute a measure of fundamental importance for understanding object recognition.

KW - object recognition

KW - visual crowding

KW - psychophysics

KW - critical spacing

KW - critical resolution

KW - visual perception

KW - flanker interference

U2 - 10.1016/j.visres.2018.08.005

DO - 10.1016/j.visres.2018.08.005

M3 - Article

VL - 153

SP - 13

EP - 23

JO - Vision Research

JF - Vision Research

SN - 0042-6989

ER -