Defying State Amnesia and Memory Wars

Non-Sectarian Memory Activism in Beirut and Belfast City Centres

John Nagle (Corresponding Author)

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

In divided societies that endure intrastate violence, ethnonational groups harness memory to support claims for territorial sovereignty and victimhood. Yet, in peace processes, rather than seek to deal with the legacy of the past, the state often enacts a culture of amnesia to support the logic of political transition, while at the communal level the rival ethnic groups proliferate commemorative practices as part of memorywars. These twin forces – amnesia and ethnicized memory – are also often embedded into postconflict urban reconstruction, particularly the city centres of the municipal capitals. In this paper, I explore how non-sectarian movements imprint memory into city centre space to challenge the paradoxical forces of forgetting and ethnic communal remembrance. Towards this, I explore the memorywork of non-sectarian groups whose politics transcend established ethnic cleavages, such as trade unionists, movements resisting the privatization of public space and activists mobilizing to protect public services. In this paper I draw on a range of theoretical frameworks, including reflective nostalgia and ghosts and hauntings. Using fieldwork data, I look at non-sectarian memorywork in Beirut and Belfast city centres. These city centres generate contrasting uses and meanings for the local population.
Original languageEnglish
JournalSocial & Cultural Geography
Early online date20 Jul 2018
DOIs
Publication statusE-pub ahead of print - 20 Jul 2018

Fingerprint

city center
territorial sovereignty
peace process
nostalgia
public space
sovereignty
ethnic group
public service
local population
privatization
violence
cleavage
fieldwork
politics
reconstruction
Group
city centre
society

Keywords

  • memory
  • nostalgia
  • social movements
  • peacebuilding
  • Northern Ireland
  • Lebanon

Cite this

@article{ea06db3fe1eb425f8225db25b57bee06,
title = "Defying State Amnesia and Memory Wars: Non-Sectarian Memory Activism in Beirut and Belfast City Centres",
abstract = "In divided societies that endure intrastate violence, ethnonational groups harness memory to support claims for territorial sovereignty and victimhood. Yet, in peace processes, rather than seek to deal with the legacy of the past, the state often enacts a culture of amnesia to support the logic of political transition, while at the communal level the rival ethnic groups proliferate commemorative practices as part of memorywars. These twin forces – amnesia and ethnicized memory – are also often embedded into postconflict urban reconstruction, particularly the city centres of the municipal capitals. In this paper, I explore how non-sectarian movements imprint memory into city centre space to challenge the paradoxical forces of forgetting and ethnic communal remembrance. Towards this, I explore the memorywork of non-sectarian groups whose politics transcend established ethnic cleavages, such as trade unionists, movements resisting the privatization of public space and activists mobilizing to protect public services. In this paper I draw on a range of theoretical frameworks, including reflective nostalgia and ghosts and hauntings. Using fieldwork data, I look at non-sectarian memorywork in Beirut and Belfast city centres. These city centres generate contrasting uses and meanings for the local population.",
keywords = "memory, nostalgia, social movements, peacebuilding, Northern Ireland, Lebanon",
author = "John Nagle",
note = "Funding This work was supported by the Leverhulme Trust [RG13732-10].",
year = "2018",
month = "7",
day = "20",
doi = "10.1080/14649365.2018.1497191",
language = "English",
journal = "Social & Cultural Geography",
issn = "1464-9365",
publisher = "Routledge",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Defying State Amnesia and Memory Wars

T2 - Non-Sectarian Memory Activism in Beirut and Belfast City Centres

AU - Nagle, John

N1 - Funding This work was supported by the Leverhulme Trust [RG13732-10].

PY - 2018/7/20

Y1 - 2018/7/20

N2 - In divided societies that endure intrastate violence, ethnonational groups harness memory to support claims for territorial sovereignty and victimhood. Yet, in peace processes, rather than seek to deal with the legacy of the past, the state often enacts a culture of amnesia to support the logic of political transition, while at the communal level the rival ethnic groups proliferate commemorative practices as part of memorywars. These twin forces – amnesia and ethnicized memory – are also often embedded into postconflict urban reconstruction, particularly the city centres of the municipal capitals. In this paper, I explore how non-sectarian movements imprint memory into city centre space to challenge the paradoxical forces of forgetting and ethnic communal remembrance. Towards this, I explore the memorywork of non-sectarian groups whose politics transcend established ethnic cleavages, such as trade unionists, movements resisting the privatization of public space and activists mobilizing to protect public services. In this paper I draw on a range of theoretical frameworks, including reflective nostalgia and ghosts and hauntings. Using fieldwork data, I look at non-sectarian memorywork in Beirut and Belfast city centres. These city centres generate contrasting uses and meanings for the local population.

AB - In divided societies that endure intrastate violence, ethnonational groups harness memory to support claims for territorial sovereignty and victimhood. Yet, in peace processes, rather than seek to deal with the legacy of the past, the state often enacts a culture of amnesia to support the logic of political transition, while at the communal level the rival ethnic groups proliferate commemorative practices as part of memorywars. These twin forces – amnesia and ethnicized memory – are also often embedded into postconflict urban reconstruction, particularly the city centres of the municipal capitals. In this paper, I explore how non-sectarian movements imprint memory into city centre space to challenge the paradoxical forces of forgetting and ethnic communal remembrance. Towards this, I explore the memorywork of non-sectarian groups whose politics transcend established ethnic cleavages, such as trade unionists, movements resisting the privatization of public space and activists mobilizing to protect public services. In this paper I draw on a range of theoretical frameworks, including reflective nostalgia and ghosts and hauntings. Using fieldwork data, I look at non-sectarian memorywork in Beirut and Belfast city centres. These city centres generate contrasting uses and meanings for the local population.

KW - memory

KW - nostalgia

KW - social movements

KW - peacebuilding

KW - Northern Ireland

KW - Lebanon

U2 - 10.1080/14649365.2018.1497191

DO - 10.1080/14649365.2018.1497191

M3 - Article

JO - Social & Cultural Geography

JF - Social & Cultural Geography

SN - 1464-9365

ER -