Democracy in schools, Dewey and the referendum on Scottish independence

Rachel Shanks, Claire Molloy

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

8 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

The aim of this study was to investigate young people’s perceptions of authority, representation and their involvement in decision-making in school, beyond school and in the referendum on Scottish independence. The study took place during the year leading up to the vote on independence for Scotland which included voters aged 16 and 17 years old for the first time in a national poll in the UK.

The research was conducted at six secondary schools across two local authorities. Focus groups were held with 202 young people aged 15 to 18 years. Young people referred to the police and most frequently to teachers having authority over their lives and making rules for them to follow, rather than government or other institutions. In relation to schools, many said that they did not have any voice and that consultation with them was a pretence.

Most students felt that at 16 people were old enough to vote in the referendum but they did not feel well-informed with the exception of those studying the subjects Politics or Modern Studies. They saw the referendum as an important decision affecting their future and felt that residence in Scotland, rather than citizenship status, should be the main criterion for eligibility to vote. We considered the data in light of Dewey’s work on democratic practices in schools and education for democratic participation in wider society. We note how Dewey’s work continues to inform and educate us in democratic citizenship.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)53-71
Number of pages19
JournalEducation in the North
Volume24
Issue number1
Early online date31 Oct 2017
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Oct 2017

Fingerprint

referendum
democracy
eligibility to vote
school
voter
citizenship
secondary school
police
decision making
participation
politics
teacher
education
Group
student

Keywords

  • Voting age
  • Democratic education
  • citizenship education
  • schools
  • political literacy

Cite this

Democracy in schools, Dewey and the referendum on Scottish independence. / Shanks, Rachel; Molloy, Claire.

In: Education in the North, Vol. 24, No. 1, 10.2017, p. 53-71.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{d198c0b76764456999d2551514287d34,
title = "Democracy in schools, Dewey and the referendum on Scottish independence",
abstract = "The aim of this study was to investigate young people’s perceptions of authority, representation and their involvement in decision-making in school, beyond school and in the referendum on Scottish independence. The study took place during the year leading up to the vote on independence for Scotland which included voters aged 16 and 17 years old for the first time in a national poll in the UK.The research was conducted at six secondary schools across two local authorities. Focus groups were held with 202 young people aged 15 to 18 years. Young people referred to the police and most frequently to teachers having authority over their lives and making rules for them to follow, rather than government or other institutions. In relation to schools, many said that they did not have any voice and that consultation with them was a pretence.Most students felt that at 16 people were old enough to vote in the referendum but they did not feel well-informed with the exception of those studying the subjects Politics or Modern Studies. They saw the referendum as an important decision affecting their future and felt that residence in Scotland, rather than citizenship status, should be the main criterion for eligibility to vote. We considered the data in light of Dewey’s work on democratic practices in schools and education for democratic participation in wider society. We note how Dewey’s work continues to inform and educate us in democratic citizenship.",
keywords = "Voting age, Democratic education, citizenship education, schools, political literacy",
author = "Rachel Shanks and Claire Molloy",
year = "2017",
month = "10",
doi = "10.26203/WJSA-5H14",
language = "English",
volume = "24",
pages = "53--71",
journal = "Education in the North",
issn = "0424-5512",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Democracy in schools, Dewey and the referendum on Scottish independence

AU - Shanks, Rachel

AU - Molloy, Claire

PY - 2017/10

Y1 - 2017/10

N2 - The aim of this study was to investigate young people’s perceptions of authority, representation and their involvement in decision-making in school, beyond school and in the referendum on Scottish independence. The study took place during the year leading up to the vote on independence for Scotland which included voters aged 16 and 17 years old for the first time in a national poll in the UK.The research was conducted at six secondary schools across two local authorities. Focus groups were held with 202 young people aged 15 to 18 years. Young people referred to the police and most frequently to teachers having authority over their lives and making rules for them to follow, rather than government or other institutions. In relation to schools, many said that they did not have any voice and that consultation with them was a pretence.Most students felt that at 16 people were old enough to vote in the referendum but they did not feel well-informed with the exception of those studying the subjects Politics or Modern Studies. They saw the referendum as an important decision affecting their future and felt that residence in Scotland, rather than citizenship status, should be the main criterion for eligibility to vote. We considered the data in light of Dewey’s work on democratic practices in schools and education for democratic participation in wider society. We note how Dewey’s work continues to inform and educate us in democratic citizenship.

AB - The aim of this study was to investigate young people’s perceptions of authority, representation and their involvement in decision-making in school, beyond school and in the referendum on Scottish independence. The study took place during the year leading up to the vote on independence for Scotland which included voters aged 16 and 17 years old for the first time in a national poll in the UK.The research was conducted at six secondary schools across two local authorities. Focus groups were held with 202 young people aged 15 to 18 years. Young people referred to the police and most frequently to teachers having authority over their lives and making rules for them to follow, rather than government or other institutions. In relation to schools, many said that they did not have any voice and that consultation with them was a pretence.Most students felt that at 16 people were old enough to vote in the referendum but they did not feel well-informed with the exception of those studying the subjects Politics or Modern Studies. They saw the referendum as an important decision affecting their future and felt that residence in Scotland, rather than citizenship status, should be the main criterion for eligibility to vote. We considered the data in light of Dewey’s work on democratic practices in schools and education for democratic participation in wider society. We note how Dewey’s work continues to inform and educate us in democratic citizenship.

KW - Voting age

KW - Democratic education

KW - citizenship education

KW - schools

KW - political literacy

U2 - 10.26203/WJSA-5H14

DO - 10.26203/WJSA-5H14

M3 - Article

VL - 24

SP - 53

EP - 71

JO - Education in the North

JF - Education in the North

SN - 0424-5512

IS - 1

ER -