Detecting the Dependence of Diversification on Multiple Traits from Phylogenetic Trees and Trait Data

Leonel Herrera-Alsina (Corresponding Author), Paul van Els, Rampal S Etienne

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

8 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Species diversification may be determined by many different variables, including the traits of the diversifying lineages. The state-dependent speciation and extinction (SSE) framework contains methods to detect the dependence of diversification on these traits. For the analysis of traits with multiple states, MuSSE (multiple-states dependent speciation and extinction) was developed. However, MuSSE and other SSE models have been shown to yield false positives, because they cannot separate differential diversification rates from dependence of diversification on the observed traits. The recently introduced method HiSSE (hidden-state-dependent speciation and extinction) resolves this problem by allowing a hidden state to affect diversification rates. Unfortunately, HiSSE does not allow traits with more than two states, and, perhaps more interestingly, the simultaneous action of multiple traits on diversification. Herein, we introduce an R package (SecSSE: several examined and concealed states-dependent speciation and extinction) that combines the features of HiSSE and MuSSE to simultaneously infer state-dependent diversification across two or more examined (observed) traits or states while accounting for the role of a possible concealed (hidden) trait. Moreover, SecSSE also has improved functionality when compared with its two “parents.” First, it allows for an observed trait being in two or more states simultaneously, which is useful for example when a taxon is a generalist or when the exact state is not precisely known. Second, it provides the correct likelihood when conditioned on nonextinction, which has been incorrectly implemented in HiSSE and other SSE models. To illustrate our method, we apply SecSSE to seven previous studies that used MuSSE, and find that in five out of seven cases, the conclusions drawn based on MuSSE were premature. We test with simulations whether SecSSE sacrifices statistical power to avoid the high Type I error problem of MuSSE, but we find that this is not the case: for the majority of simulations where the observed traits affect diversification, SecSSE detects this.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)317-328
Number of pages11
JournalSystematic Biology
Volume68
Issue number2
Early online date26 Sep 2018
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Mar 2019

Fingerprint

extinction
phylogenetics
phylogeny
generalist
simulation
methodology

Keywords

  • evolving traits
  • macroevolution
  • phylogenetic tools
  • speciation rates
  • Evolving traits
  • TESTS
  • EVOLUTION
  • SPECIATION
  • RADIATIONS
  • DIVERSITY
  • EXTINCTION RATES

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Genetics
  • Ecology, Evolution, Behavior and Systematics

Cite this

Detecting the Dependence of Diversification on Multiple Traits from Phylogenetic Trees and Trait Data. / Herrera-Alsina, Leonel (Corresponding Author); Els, Paul van; Etienne, Rampal S.

In: Systematic Biology, Vol. 68, No. 2, 03.2019, p. 317-328.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{2f057fdc67f54237ad9ae3479567f8d0,
title = "Detecting the Dependence of Diversification on Multiple Traits from Phylogenetic Trees and Trait Data",
abstract = "Species diversification may be determined by many different variables, including the traits of the diversifying lineages. The state-dependent speciation and extinction (SSE) framework contains methods to detect the dependence of diversification on these traits. For the analysis of traits with multiple states, MuSSE (multiple-states dependent speciation and extinction) was developed. However, MuSSE and other SSE models have been shown to yield false positives, because they cannot separate differential diversification rates from dependence of diversification on the observed traits. The recently introduced method HiSSE (hidden-state-dependent speciation and extinction) resolves this problem by allowing a hidden state to affect diversification rates. Unfortunately, HiSSE does not allow traits with more than two states, and, perhaps more interestingly, the simultaneous action of multiple traits on diversification. Herein, we introduce an R package (SecSSE: several examined and concealed states-dependent speciation and extinction) that combines the features of HiSSE and MuSSE to simultaneously infer state-dependent diversification across two or more examined (observed) traits or states while accounting for the role of a possible concealed (hidden) trait. Moreover, SecSSE also has improved functionality when compared with its two “parents.” First, it allows for an observed trait being in two or more states simultaneously, which is useful for example when a taxon is a generalist or when the exact state is not precisely known. Second, it provides the correct likelihood when conditioned on nonextinction, which has been incorrectly implemented in HiSSE and other SSE models. To illustrate our method, we apply SecSSE to seven previous studies that used MuSSE, and find that in five out of seven cases, the conclusions drawn based on MuSSE were premature. We test with simulations whether SecSSE sacrifices statistical power to avoid the high Type I error problem of MuSSE, but we find that this is not the case: for the majority of simulations where the observed traits affect diversification, SecSSE detects this.",
keywords = "evolving traits, macroevolution, phylogenetic tools, speciation rates, Evolving traits, TESTS, EVOLUTION, SPECIATION, RADIATIONS, DIVERSITY, EXTINCTION RATES",
author = "Leonel Herrera-Alsina and Els, {Paul van} and Etienne, {Rampal S}",
note = "This work was financially supported by Consejo Nacional de Ciencia y Tecnologia (CVU 385304 L.H.-A.), the Netherlands Organisation for Scientific Research (NWO-VICI grant awarded to R.S.E.) and the Faculty of Science and Engineering and the Groningen Institute for Evolutionary Life Sciences at the University of Groningen (Adaptive Life Program P.V.E.).",
year = "2019",
month = "3",
doi = "10.1093/sysbio/syy057",
language = "English",
volume = "68",
pages = "317--328",
journal = "Systematic Biology",
issn = "1063-5157",
publisher = "Oxford University Press",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Detecting the Dependence of Diversification on Multiple Traits from Phylogenetic Trees and Trait Data

AU - Herrera-Alsina, Leonel

AU - Els, Paul van

AU - Etienne, Rampal S

N1 - This work was financially supported by Consejo Nacional de Ciencia y Tecnologia (CVU 385304 L.H.-A.), the Netherlands Organisation for Scientific Research (NWO-VICI grant awarded to R.S.E.) and the Faculty of Science and Engineering and the Groningen Institute for Evolutionary Life Sciences at the University of Groningen (Adaptive Life Program P.V.E.).

PY - 2019/3

Y1 - 2019/3

N2 - Species diversification may be determined by many different variables, including the traits of the diversifying lineages. The state-dependent speciation and extinction (SSE) framework contains methods to detect the dependence of diversification on these traits. For the analysis of traits with multiple states, MuSSE (multiple-states dependent speciation and extinction) was developed. However, MuSSE and other SSE models have been shown to yield false positives, because they cannot separate differential diversification rates from dependence of diversification on the observed traits. The recently introduced method HiSSE (hidden-state-dependent speciation and extinction) resolves this problem by allowing a hidden state to affect diversification rates. Unfortunately, HiSSE does not allow traits with more than two states, and, perhaps more interestingly, the simultaneous action of multiple traits on diversification. Herein, we introduce an R package (SecSSE: several examined and concealed states-dependent speciation and extinction) that combines the features of HiSSE and MuSSE to simultaneously infer state-dependent diversification across two or more examined (observed) traits or states while accounting for the role of a possible concealed (hidden) trait. Moreover, SecSSE also has improved functionality when compared with its two “parents.” First, it allows for an observed trait being in two or more states simultaneously, which is useful for example when a taxon is a generalist or when the exact state is not precisely known. Second, it provides the correct likelihood when conditioned on nonextinction, which has been incorrectly implemented in HiSSE and other SSE models. To illustrate our method, we apply SecSSE to seven previous studies that used MuSSE, and find that in five out of seven cases, the conclusions drawn based on MuSSE were premature. We test with simulations whether SecSSE sacrifices statistical power to avoid the high Type I error problem of MuSSE, but we find that this is not the case: for the majority of simulations where the observed traits affect diversification, SecSSE detects this.

AB - Species diversification may be determined by many different variables, including the traits of the diversifying lineages. The state-dependent speciation and extinction (SSE) framework contains methods to detect the dependence of diversification on these traits. For the analysis of traits with multiple states, MuSSE (multiple-states dependent speciation and extinction) was developed. However, MuSSE and other SSE models have been shown to yield false positives, because they cannot separate differential diversification rates from dependence of diversification on the observed traits. The recently introduced method HiSSE (hidden-state-dependent speciation and extinction) resolves this problem by allowing a hidden state to affect diversification rates. Unfortunately, HiSSE does not allow traits with more than two states, and, perhaps more interestingly, the simultaneous action of multiple traits on diversification. Herein, we introduce an R package (SecSSE: several examined and concealed states-dependent speciation and extinction) that combines the features of HiSSE and MuSSE to simultaneously infer state-dependent diversification across two or more examined (observed) traits or states while accounting for the role of a possible concealed (hidden) trait. Moreover, SecSSE also has improved functionality when compared with its two “parents.” First, it allows for an observed trait being in two or more states simultaneously, which is useful for example when a taxon is a generalist or when the exact state is not precisely known. Second, it provides the correct likelihood when conditioned on nonextinction, which has been incorrectly implemented in HiSSE and other SSE models. To illustrate our method, we apply SecSSE to seven previous studies that used MuSSE, and find that in five out of seven cases, the conclusions drawn based on MuSSE were premature. We test with simulations whether SecSSE sacrifices statistical power to avoid the high Type I error problem of MuSSE, but we find that this is not the case: for the majority of simulations where the observed traits affect diversification, SecSSE detects this.

KW - evolving traits

KW - macroevolution

KW - phylogenetic tools

KW - speciation rates

KW - Evolving traits

KW - TESTS

KW - EVOLUTION

KW - SPECIATION

KW - RADIATIONS

KW - DIVERSITY

KW - EXTINCTION RATES

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85061475393&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.mendeley.com/research/detecting-dependence-diversification-multiple-traits-phylogenetic-trees-trait-data

U2 - 10.1093/sysbio/syy057

DO - 10.1093/sysbio/syy057

M3 - Article

VL - 68

SP - 317

EP - 328

JO - Systematic Biology

JF - Systematic Biology

SN - 1063-5157

IS - 2

ER -