Direct disclosure of bone density results to patients: Effect on knowledge of osteoporosis risk and anxiety level

M K Campbell, D J Torgerson, R E Thomas, J D McClure, D M Reid

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

17 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

If bone mineral density (BMD) screening is to achieve the aim of preventing the complications of osteoporosis, women with low BMD measurements must learn that they are at risk, and women at risk must know about and be willing to adopt and persist with measures that can prevent osteoporosis. In this paper we present the results of a randomized controlled trial designed to examine whether disclosing the results of a BMD scan directly to women, as well as through their general practitioners (GPs), improves their knowledge of their bone density results without adverse psychological sequelae. Direct disclosure resulted in 19% (59% vs 40% 95% CI for difference in proportions: 9.8% to 27.8%) more women being aware of their BMD status at the spine and 22% (58% vs 36%; 95% CI for difference: 12.2% to 29.8%) at the hip. These differences were observed irrespective of risk status. There was no significant difference in anxiety levels between the randomized groups. We conclude, therefore, that direct disclosure of BMD results to women, as well as to their GPs, leads to increased knowledge of BMD status without increasing anxiety, and that BMD measurement services should consider informing women routinely of their results directly as well as through their GPs.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)584-590
Number of pages7
JournalOsteoporosis International
Volume8
Publication statusPublished - 1998

Keywords

  • anxiety
  • bone density
  • direct disclosure
  • knowledge of risk
  • HORMONE REPLACEMENT THERAPY
  • REGIONAL OSTEOPOROSIS
  • RECRUITMENT METHODS
  • SCREENING PROGRAMS
  • FRACTURES
  • PREDICTION
  • WOMEN
  • TRIAL

Cite this

Direct disclosure of bone density results to patients: Effect on knowledge of osteoporosis risk and anxiety level. / Campbell, M K ; Torgerson, D J ; Thomas, R E ; McClure, J D ; Reid, D M .

In: Osteoporosis International, Vol. 8, 1998, p. 584-590.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{f6c297116d8547748995d20618413606,
title = "Direct disclosure of bone density results to patients: Effect on knowledge of osteoporosis risk and anxiety level",
abstract = "If bone mineral density (BMD) screening is to achieve the aim of preventing the complications of osteoporosis, women with low BMD measurements must learn that they are at risk, and women at risk must know about and be willing to adopt and persist with measures that can prevent osteoporosis. In this paper we present the results of a randomized controlled trial designed to examine whether disclosing the results of a BMD scan directly to women, as well as through their general practitioners (GPs), improves their knowledge of their bone density results without adverse psychological sequelae. Direct disclosure resulted in 19{\%} (59{\%} vs 40{\%} 95{\%} CI for difference in proportions: 9.8{\%} to 27.8{\%}) more women being aware of their BMD status at the spine and 22{\%} (58{\%} vs 36{\%}; 95{\%} CI for difference: 12.2{\%} to 29.8{\%}) at the hip. These differences were observed irrespective of risk status. There was no significant difference in anxiety levels between the randomized groups. We conclude, therefore, that direct disclosure of BMD results to women, as well as to their GPs, leads to increased knowledge of BMD status without increasing anxiety, and that BMD measurement services should consider informing women routinely of their results directly as well as through their GPs.",
keywords = "anxiety, bone density, direct disclosure, knowledge of risk, HORMONE REPLACEMENT THERAPY, REGIONAL OSTEOPOROSIS, RECRUITMENT METHODS, SCREENING PROGRAMS, FRACTURES, PREDICTION, WOMEN, TRIAL",
author = "Campbell, {M K} and Torgerson, {D J} and Thomas, {R E} and McClure, {J D} and Reid, {D M}",
year = "1998",
language = "English",
volume = "8",
pages = "584--590",
journal = "Osteoporosis International",
issn = "0937-941X",
publisher = "SPRINGER-VERLAG LONDON LTD",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Direct disclosure of bone density results to patients: Effect on knowledge of osteoporosis risk and anxiety level

AU - Campbell, M K

AU - Torgerson, D J

AU - Thomas, R E

AU - McClure, J D

AU - Reid, D M

PY - 1998

Y1 - 1998

N2 - If bone mineral density (BMD) screening is to achieve the aim of preventing the complications of osteoporosis, women with low BMD measurements must learn that they are at risk, and women at risk must know about and be willing to adopt and persist with measures that can prevent osteoporosis. In this paper we present the results of a randomized controlled trial designed to examine whether disclosing the results of a BMD scan directly to women, as well as through their general practitioners (GPs), improves their knowledge of their bone density results without adverse psychological sequelae. Direct disclosure resulted in 19% (59% vs 40% 95% CI for difference in proportions: 9.8% to 27.8%) more women being aware of their BMD status at the spine and 22% (58% vs 36%; 95% CI for difference: 12.2% to 29.8%) at the hip. These differences were observed irrespective of risk status. There was no significant difference in anxiety levels between the randomized groups. We conclude, therefore, that direct disclosure of BMD results to women, as well as to their GPs, leads to increased knowledge of BMD status without increasing anxiety, and that BMD measurement services should consider informing women routinely of their results directly as well as through their GPs.

AB - If bone mineral density (BMD) screening is to achieve the aim of preventing the complications of osteoporosis, women with low BMD measurements must learn that they are at risk, and women at risk must know about and be willing to adopt and persist with measures that can prevent osteoporosis. In this paper we present the results of a randomized controlled trial designed to examine whether disclosing the results of a BMD scan directly to women, as well as through their general practitioners (GPs), improves their knowledge of their bone density results without adverse psychological sequelae. Direct disclosure resulted in 19% (59% vs 40% 95% CI for difference in proportions: 9.8% to 27.8%) more women being aware of their BMD status at the spine and 22% (58% vs 36%; 95% CI for difference: 12.2% to 29.8%) at the hip. These differences were observed irrespective of risk status. There was no significant difference in anxiety levels between the randomized groups. We conclude, therefore, that direct disclosure of BMD results to women, as well as to their GPs, leads to increased knowledge of BMD status without increasing anxiety, and that BMD measurement services should consider informing women routinely of their results directly as well as through their GPs.

KW - anxiety

KW - bone density

KW - direct disclosure

KW - knowledge of risk

KW - HORMONE REPLACEMENT THERAPY

KW - REGIONAL OSTEOPOROSIS

KW - RECRUITMENT METHODS

KW - SCREENING PROGRAMS

KW - FRACTURES

KW - PREDICTION

KW - WOMEN

KW - TRIAL

M3 - Article

VL - 8

SP - 584

EP - 590

JO - Osteoporosis International

JF - Osteoporosis International

SN - 0937-941X

ER -