Discussion on a Paper by Jennison and Turnbull: Interim Analyses: The Repeated Confidence Interval Approach

M K Parmar, S P Stenning, P M Fayers, D Machin

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Most medical trials are monitored for early evidence of treatment differences or harmful side-effects and many sequential methods have been proposed for this. Similarly, data collected in a prospective epidemiological study are likely to be reviewed periodically in the course of the study. The repeated confidence interval approach, which combines aspects of sequential estimation and testing, allows a full exploration of the data at each interim analysis and does not depend on a rigidly enforced statistical stopping rule. In this paper we present the general principles underlying the construction of repeated confidence intervals and describe how they can be used in reaching a decision to terminate a study early. We discuss design considerations, which depend on the form of early stopping anticipated, and explain how the basic method can be adapted to cope with the problems of unpredictable group sizes or, more generally, unequal increments in information between analyses. Extensions of the method to handle survival data, categorical data, normal responses with unknown variance and multivariate normal observations are also presented.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)339-341
Number of pages3
JournalJournal of the Royal Statistical Society. Series B
Volume51
Issue number3
Publication statusPublished - 1989

Fingerprint

Confidence interval
Interim Analysis
Early Stopping
Sequential Testing
Sequential Estimation
Sequential Methods
Stopping Rule
Nominal or categorical data
Survival Data
Multivariate Normal
Terminate
Unequal
Increment
Likely
Unknown
Observation
Form
Evidence
Design

Cite this

Discussion on a Paper by Jennison and Turnbull: Interim Analyses: The Repeated Confidence Interval Approach. / Parmar, M K; Stenning, S P; Fayers, P M; Machin, D.

In: Journal of the Royal Statistical Society. Series B , Vol. 51, No. 3, 1989, p. 339-341.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{6a6b52810bc54bddb78224055448491b,
title = "Discussion on a Paper by Jennison and Turnbull: Interim Analyses: The Repeated Confidence Interval Approach",
abstract = "Most medical trials are monitored for early evidence of treatment differences or harmful side-effects and many sequential methods have been proposed for this. Similarly, data collected in a prospective epidemiological study are likely to be reviewed periodically in the course of the study. The repeated confidence interval approach, which combines aspects of sequential estimation and testing, allows a full exploration of the data at each interim analysis and does not depend on a rigidly enforced statistical stopping rule. In this paper we present the general principles underlying the construction of repeated confidence intervals and describe how they can be used in reaching a decision to terminate a study early. We discuss design considerations, which depend on the form of early stopping anticipated, and explain how the basic method can be adapted to cope with the problems of unpredictable group sizes or, more generally, unequal increments in information between analyses. Extensions of the method to handle survival data, categorical data, normal responses with unknown variance and multivariate normal observations are also presented.",
author = "Parmar, {M K} and Stenning, {S P} and Fayers, {P M} and D Machin",
year = "1989",
language = "English",
volume = "51",
pages = "339--341",
journal = "Journal of the Royal Statistical Society. Series B",
issn = "1467-9868",
publisher = "Wiley",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Discussion on a Paper by Jennison and Turnbull: Interim Analyses: The Repeated Confidence Interval Approach

AU - Parmar, M K

AU - Stenning, S P

AU - Fayers, P M

AU - Machin, D

PY - 1989

Y1 - 1989

N2 - Most medical trials are monitored for early evidence of treatment differences or harmful side-effects and many sequential methods have been proposed for this. Similarly, data collected in a prospective epidemiological study are likely to be reviewed periodically in the course of the study. The repeated confidence interval approach, which combines aspects of sequential estimation and testing, allows a full exploration of the data at each interim analysis and does not depend on a rigidly enforced statistical stopping rule. In this paper we present the general principles underlying the construction of repeated confidence intervals and describe how they can be used in reaching a decision to terminate a study early. We discuss design considerations, which depend on the form of early stopping anticipated, and explain how the basic method can be adapted to cope with the problems of unpredictable group sizes or, more generally, unequal increments in information between analyses. Extensions of the method to handle survival data, categorical data, normal responses with unknown variance and multivariate normal observations are also presented.

AB - Most medical trials are monitored for early evidence of treatment differences or harmful side-effects and many sequential methods have been proposed for this. Similarly, data collected in a prospective epidemiological study are likely to be reviewed periodically in the course of the study. The repeated confidence interval approach, which combines aspects of sequential estimation and testing, allows a full exploration of the data at each interim analysis and does not depend on a rigidly enforced statistical stopping rule. In this paper we present the general principles underlying the construction of repeated confidence intervals and describe how they can be used in reaching a decision to terminate a study early. We discuss design considerations, which depend on the form of early stopping anticipated, and explain how the basic method can be adapted to cope with the problems of unpredictable group sizes or, more generally, unequal increments in information between analyses. Extensions of the method to handle survival data, categorical data, normal responses with unknown variance and multivariate normal observations are also presented.

M3 - Article

VL - 51

SP - 339

EP - 341

JO - Journal of the Royal Statistical Society. Series B

JF - Journal of the Royal Statistical Society. Series B

SN - 1467-9868

IS - 3

ER -