'Disempowered by Nature'

Spinoza on the political capabilities of women

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

7 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

This paper examines Spinoza's remarks on women in the Political Treatise in the context of his views in the Ethics about human community and similitude. Although these remarks appear to exclude women from democratic participation on the basis of essential incapacities, I aim to show that Spinoza intended these remarks not as true statements, but as prompts for critical consideration of the place of women in the progressive democratic polity. In common with other scholars, I argue that women, in Spinoza's system, are deprived of freedom and political participation not by their essential natures, but by their social and historical circumstances. I differ from other scholars, however, in basing this conclusion on the different critical functions of the Political Treatise and the Ethics. Following that critical comparison, I consider Spinoza's views on the `natural right' of women and their equal capacity for political participation in terms of his arguments for the compositional similarity of men and women. Finally, I argue that Spinoza offers an explanation for women's actual disempowerment through his account of economic dependence within marriage.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1085-1106
Number of pages22
JournalBritish Journal for the History of Philosophy
Volume19
Issue number6
Early online date15 Dec 2011
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2011

Fingerprint

Baruch Spinoza
Political Participation
Treatise
Participation
Marriage
Economics
Natural Rights
Prompts
Polity

Keywords

  • Spinoza
  • politics
  • women
  • feminism
  • equality
  • democracy

Cite this

'Disempowered by Nature' : Spinoza on the political capabilities of women. / Lord, Beth.

In: British Journal for the History of Philosophy, Vol. 19, No. 6, 2011, p. 1085-1106.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{be0a384068b54e289012a20e28882e55,
title = "'Disempowered by Nature': Spinoza on the political capabilities of women",
abstract = "This paper examines Spinoza's remarks on women in the Political Treatise in the context of his views in the Ethics about human community and similitude. Although these remarks appear to exclude women from democratic participation on the basis of essential incapacities, I aim to show that Spinoza intended these remarks not as true statements, but as prompts for critical consideration of the place of women in the progressive democratic polity. In common with other scholars, I argue that women, in Spinoza's system, are deprived of freedom and political participation not by their essential natures, but by their social and historical circumstances. I differ from other scholars, however, in basing this conclusion on the different critical functions of the Political Treatise and the Ethics. Following that critical comparison, I consider Spinoza's views on the `natural right' of women and their equal capacity for political participation in terms of his arguments for the compositional similarity of men and women. Finally, I argue that Spinoza offers an explanation for women's actual disempowerment through his account of economic dependence within marriage.",
keywords = "Spinoza, politics, women , feminism, equality, democracy",
author = "Beth Lord",
year = "2011",
doi = "10.1080/09608788.2011.624704",
language = "English",
volume = "19",
pages = "1085--1106",
journal = "British Journal for the History of Philosophy",
issn = "0960-8788",
publisher = "Routledge",
number = "6",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - 'Disempowered by Nature'

T2 - Spinoza on the political capabilities of women

AU - Lord, Beth

PY - 2011

Y1 - 2011

N2 - This paper examines Spinoza's remarks on women in the Political Treatise in the context of his views in the Ethics about human community and similitude. Although these remarks appear to exclude women from democratic participation on the basis of essential incapacities, I aim to show that Spinoza intended these remarks not as true statements, but as prompts for critical consideration of the place of women in the progressive democratic polity. In common with other scholars, I argue that women, in Spinoza's system, are deprived of freedom and political participation not by their essential natures, but by their social and historical circumstances. I differ from other scholars, however, in basing this conclusion on the different critical functions of the Political Treatise and the Ethics. Following that critical comparison, I consider Spinoza's views on the `natural right' of women and their equal capacity for political participation in terms of his arguments for the compositional similarity of men and women. Finally, I argue that Spinoza offers an explanation for women's actual disempowerment through his account of economic dependence within marriage.

AB - This paper examines Spinoza's remarks on women in the Political Treatise in the context of his views in the Ethics about human community and similitude. Although these remarks appear to exclude women from democratic participation on the basis of essential incapacities, I aim to show that Spinoza intended these remarks not as true statements, but as prompts for critical consideration of the place of women in the progressive democratic polity. In common with other scholars, I argue that women, in Spinoza's system, are deprived of freedom and political participation not by their essential natures, but by their social and historical circumstances. I differ from other scholars, however, in basing this conclusion on the different critical functions of the Political Treatise and the Ethics. Following that critical comparison, I consider Spinoza's views on the `natural right' of women and their equal capacity for political participation in terms of his arguments for the compositional similarity of men and women. Finally, I argue that Spinoza offers an explanation for women's actual disempowerment through his account of economic dependence within marriage.

KW - Spinoza

KW - politics

KW - women

KW - feminism

KW - equality

KW - democracy

U2 - 10.1080/09608788.2011.624704

DO - 10.1080/09608788.2011.624704

M3 - Article

VL - 19

SP - 1085

EP - 1106

JO - British Journal for the History of Philosophy

JF - British Journal for the History of Philosophy

SN - 0960-8788

IS - 6

ER -