Do Economic Inequalities Harm Health? Evidence from Europe

Jean-Michel Etienne, Ali Skalli, Ioannis Theodossiou

Research output: Working paperDiscussion paper

Abstract

Until recently, there has been a consensus among empirical health economists that there is an association between income inequality and individual health, in line with Wilkinson’s (1992) idea that the psychosocial effects of the former are detrimental to the latter. However, using US data, Mellor and Milyo (2002) (MM) found no evidence of such association and claimed that the previously reported results are statistical artefacts, arising from the use of aggregate data. This paper uses the European Community Household Panel (ECHP) to check the robustness of MM results. It replicates the MM methodology to assess the effect of country-level income inequality on individuals’ health. It is shown that income inequality, whether measured at the regional or the national level, systematically harms individuals’ health, regardless of their positions in the income distribution. The results are also robust to a number of aspects MM do not account for. First, random effect models are estimated to account for unobserved heterogeneity. Second, self-assessed and objective measures of health status are also considered. Third, besides the traditional aggregate measures of income inequality, a further measure is constructed reflecting first, how unequal the distribution is and second the relative position of individuals in the income distribution of their own country.
Original languageEnglish
PublisherUniversity of Aberdeen
Number of pages31
Publication statusPublished - Mar 2007

Publication series

NameUniversity of Aberdeen Business School Working Paper Series
No.13
Volume2007
ISSN (Print)0143-4543

Fingerprint

Economic inequality
Income inequality
Health
Random effects model
Income distribution
European Community Household Panel
Methodology
Economists
Distribution of income
Aggregate data
Unobserved heterogeneity
Health status
Robustness

Keywords

  • income inequality
  • individual health status
  • income inequality hypothesis

Cite this

Etienne, J-M., Skalli, A., & Theodossiou, I. (2007). Do Economic Inequalities Harm Health? Evidence from Europe. (University of Aberdeen Business School Working Paper Series; Vol. 2007, No. 13). University of Aberdeen.

Do Economic Inequalities Harm Health? Evidence from Europe. / Etienne, Jean-Michel ; Skalli, Ali ; Theodossiou, Ioannis.

University of Aberdeen, 2007. (University of Aberdeen Business School Working Paper Series; Vol. 2007, No. 13).

Research output: Working paperDiscussion paper

Etienne, J-M, Skalli, A & Theodossiou, I 2007 'Do Economic Inequalities Harm Health? Evidence from Europe' University of Aberdeen Business School Working Paper Series, no. 13, vol. 2007, University of Aberdeen.
Etienne J-M, Skalli A, Theodossiou I. Do Economic Inequalities Harm Health? Evidence from Europe. University of Aberdeen. 2007 Mar. (University of Aberdeen Business School Working Paper Series; 13).
Etienne, Jean-Michel ; Skalli, Ali ; Theodossiou, Ioannis. / Do Economic Inequalities Harm Health? Evidence from Europe. University of Aberdeen, 2007. (University of Aberdeen Business School Working Paper Series; 13).
@techreport{63d409eac5b4431493b083992dd858dd,
title = "Do Economic Inequalities Harm Health? Evidence from Europe",
abstract = "Until recently, there has been a consensus among empirical health economists that there is an association between income inequality and individual health, in line with Wilkinson’s (1992) idea that the psychosocial effects of the former are detrimental to the latter. However, using US data, Mellor and Milyo (2002) (MM) found no evidence of such association and claimed that the previously reported results are statistical artefacts, arising from the use of aggregate data. This paper uses the European Community Household Panel (ECHP) to check the robustness of MM results. It replicates the MM methodology to assess the effect of country-level income inequality on individuals’ health. It is shown that income inequality, whether measured at the regional or the national level, systematically harms individuals’ health, regardless of their positions in the income distribution. The results are also robust to a number of aspects MM do not account for. First, random effect models are estimated to account for unobserved heterogeneity. Second, self-assessed and objective measures of health status are also considered. Third, besides the traditional aggregate measures of income inequality, a further measure is constructed reflecting first, how unequal the distribution is and second the relative position of individuals in the income distribution of their own country.",
keywords = "income inequality, individual health status, income inequality hypothesis",
author = "Jean-Michel Etienne and Ali Skalli and Ioannis Theodossiou",
year = "2007",
month = "3",
language = "English",
series = "University of Aberdeen Business School Working Paper Series",
publisher = "University of Aberdeen",
number = "13",
type = "WorkingPaper",
institution = "University of Aberdeen",

}

TY - UNPB

T1 - Do Economic Inequalities Harm Health? Evidence from Europe

AU - Etienne, Jean-Michel

AU - Skalli, Ali

AU - Theodossiou, Ioannis

PY - 2007/3

Y1 - 2007/3

N2 - Until recently, there has been a consensus among empirical health economists that there is an association between income inequality and individual health, in line with Wilkinson’s (1992) idea that the psychosocial effects of the former are detrimental to the latter. However, using US data, Mellor and Milyo (2002) (MM) found no evidence of such association and claimed that the previously reported results are statistical artefacts, arising from the use of aggregate data. This paper uses the European Community Household Panel (ECHP) to check the robustness of MM results. It replicates the MM methodology to assess the effect of country-level income inequality on individuals’ health. It is shown that income inequality, whether measured at the regional or the national level, systematically harms individuals’ health, regardless of their positions in the income distribution. The results are also robust to a number of aspects MM do not account for. First, random effect models are estimated to account for unobserved heterogeneity. Second, self-assessed and objective measures of health status are also considered. Third, besides the traditional aggregate measures of income inequality, a further measure is constructed reflecting first, how unequal the distribution is and second the relative position of individuals in the income distribution of their own country.

AB - Until recently, there has been a consensus among empirical health economists that there is an association between income inequality and individual health, in line with Wilkinson’s (1992) idea that the psychosocial effects of the former are detrimental to the latter. However, using US data, Mellor and Milyo (2002) (MM) found no evidence of such association and claimed that the previously reported results are statistical artefacts, arising from the use of aggregate data. This paper uses the European Community Household Panel (ECHP) to check the robustness of MM results. It replicates the MM methodology to assess the effect of country-level income inequality on individuals’ health. It is shown that income inequality, whether measured at the regional or the national level, systematically harms individuals’ health, regardless of their positions in the income distribution. The results are also robust to a number of aspects MM do not account for. First, random effect models are estimated to account for unobserved heterogeneity. Second, self-assessed and objective measures of health status are also considered. Third, besides the traditional aggregate measures of income inequality, a further measure is constructed reflecting first, how unequal the distribution is and second the relative position of individuals in the income distribution of their own country.

KW - income inequality

KW - individual health status

KW - income inequality hypothesis

M3 - Discussion paper

T3 - University of Aberdeen Business School Working Paper Series

BT - Do Economic Inequalities Harm Health? Evidence from Europe

PB - University of Aberdeen

ER -