Dummett and the problem of the vanishing past

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Dummett has recently presented his most mature and sophisticated version of justificationism, i.e. the view
that meaning and truth are to be analysed in terms of justifiability. In this paper, I argue that this conception does not
resolve a difficulty that also affected Dummett’s earlier version of justificationism: the problem that large tracts of the
past continuously vanish as their traces in the present dissipate. Since Dummett’s justificationism is essentially based on
the assumption that the speaker has limited (i.e. non-idealized) cognitive powers, no further refinement of this position is
likely to settle the problem of the vanishing past.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)37-47
Number of pages11
JournalLinguistic & Philosophical Investigations
Volume7
Publication statusPublished - 2008

Fingerprint

present
Conception
Michael Dummett

Cite this

Dummett and the problem of the vanishing past. / Moretti, Luca.

In: Linguistic & Philosophical Investigations, Vol. 7, 2008, p. 37-47.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{d437f9d679924556a159ef9d67a9d098,
title = "Dummett and the problem of the vanishing past",
abstract = "Dummett has recently presented his most mature and sophisticated version of justificationism, i.e. the view that meaning and truth are to be analysed in terms of justifiability. In this paper, I argue that this conception does not resolve a difficulty that also affected Dummett’s earlier version of justificationism: the problem that large tracts of the past continuously vanish as their traces in the present dissipate. Since Dummett’s justificationism is essentially based on the assumption that the speaker has limited (i.e. non-idealized) cognitive powers, no further refinement of this position is likely to settle the problem of the vanishing past.",
author = "Luca Moretti",
year = "2008",
language = "English",
volume = "7",
pages = "37--47",
journal = "Linguistic & Philosophical Investigations",
issn = "1841-2394",
publisher = "Addleton Academic Publishers",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Dummett and the problem of the vanishing past

AU - Moretti, Luca

PY - 2008

Y1 - 2008

N2 - Dummett has recently presented his most mature and sophisticated version of justificationism, i.e. the view that meaning and truth are to be analysed in terms of justifiability. In this paper, I argue that this conception does not resolve a difficulty that also affected Dummett’s earlier version of justificationism: the problem that large tracts of the past continuously vanish as their traces in the present dissipate. Since Dummett’s justificationism is essentially based on the assumption that the speaker has limited (i.e. non-idealized) cognitive powers, no further refinement of this position is likely to settle the problem of the vanishing past.

AB - Dummett has recently presented his most mature and sophisticated version of justificationism, i.e. the view that meaning and truth are to be analysed in terms of justifiability. In this paper, I argue that this conception does not resolve a difficulty that also affected Dummett’s earlier version of justificationism: the problem that large tracts of the past continuously vanish as their traces in the present dissipate. Since Dummett’s justificationism is essentially based on the assumption that the speaker has limited (i.e. non-idealized) cognitive powers, no further refinement of this position is likely to settle the problem of the vanishing past.

M3 - Article

VL - 7

SP - 37

EP - 47

JO - Linguistic & Philosophical Investigations

JF - Linguistic & Philosophical Investigations

SN - 1841-2394

ER -