Effects of impulsive noise on marine mammals: investigating range-dependent risk

Gordon Hastie (Corresponding Author), Nathan D. Merchant, Thomas Götz, Debbie J. F. Russell, Paul Thompson, Vincent M. Janik

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

2 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Concerns exist about the impacts of underwater noise on marine mammals. These include auditory damage, which is a significant risk for marine mammals exposed to impulsive sounds such as explosions, pile-driving, and seismic airguns. Currently, impact assessments use different risk criteria for impulsive and non-impulsive sounds (e.g. ships, drilling). However, as impulsive sounds dissipate through the environment, they potentially lose hazardous features (e.g. sudden onset) and become non-impulsive at some distance from the source. Despite management implications, a lack of data on range-dependent characteristics currently limits their inclusion in impact assessments. We address this using acoustic recordings of seismic airguns and pile-driving to quantify range-dependency in impulsive characteristics using four criteria: (i) rise time <25 ms; (ii) quotient of peak pressure and pulse duration >5,000 Pa.s-1; (iii) duration <1 s; (iv) crest factor >15 dB. We demonstrate that some characteristics changed markedly within ranges of ~10 km, and that the mean probability of exceeding criteria (i) and (ii) was <0.5 at ranges >3.5 km. In contrast, the mean probability of exceeding criteria (iii) remained >0.5 up to ~37.0 km, and the mean probability of exceeding criteria (iii) remained <0.5 throughout the range. These results suggest that a proportion of the recorded signals should be defined as impulsive based on each of the criteria, and that some of the criteria change markedly as a result of propagation. However, the impulsive nature of a sound is likely to be a complex interaction of all these criteria, and many other unrelated parameters such as duty cycle, recovery periods, and sound levels will also strongly affect the risk of hearing damage. We recommend future auditory damage studies and impact assessments explicitly consider the ranges at which sounds may lose some of their potentially hazardous characteristics.
Original languageEnglish
Article numbere01906
Number of pages10
JournalEcological Applications
Volume29
Issue number5
Early online date15 Apr 2019
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Jul 2019

Fingerprint

marine mammal
pile driving
damage
underwater noise
hearing
explosion
acoustics
drilling
impulsive noise
sound
effect
impact assessment

Keywords

  • seismic survey
  • pile driving
  • underwater noise
  • auditory damage
  • marine mammals
  • sound propagation

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Ecology

Cite this

Hastie, G., Merchant, N. D., Götz, T., Russell, D. J. F., Thompson, P., & Janik, V. M. (2019). Effects of impulsive noise on marine mammals: investigating range-dependent risk. Ecological Applications, 29(5), [e01906]. https://doi.org/10.1002/eap.1906

Effects of impulsive noise on marine mammals : investigating range-dependent risk. / Hastie, Gordon (Corresponding Author); Merchant, Nathan D.; Götz, Thomas; Russell, Debbie J. F.; Thompson, Paul; Janik, Vincent M.

In: Ecological Applications, Vol. 29, No. 5, e01906, 01.07.2019.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Hastie, Gordon ; Merchant, Nathan D. ; Götz, Thomas ; Russell, Debbie J. F. ; Thompson, Paul ; Janik, Vincent M. / Effects of impulsive noise on marine mammals : investigating range-dependent risk. In: Ecological Applications. 2019 ; Vol. 29, No. 5.
@article{64de52d00a3046d4ae56392f06cde9e0,
title = "Effects of impulsive noise on marine mammals: investigating range-dependent risk",
abstract = "Concerns exist about the impacts of underwater noise on marine mammals. These include auditory damage, which is a significant risk for marine mammals exposed to impulsive sounds such as explosions, pile-driving, and seismic airguns. Currently, impact assessments use different risk criteria for impulsive and non-impulsive sounds (e.g. ships, drilling). However, as impulsive sounds dissipate through the environment, they potentially lose hazardous features (e.g. sudden onset) and become non-impulsive at some distance from the source. Despite management implications, a lack of data on range-dependent characteristics currently limits their inclusion in impact assessments. We address this using acoustic recordings of seismic airguns and pile-driving to quantify range-dependency in impulsive characteristics using four criteria: (i) rise time <25 ms; (ii) quotient of peak pressure and pulse duration >5,000 Pa.s-1; (iii) duration <1 s; (iv) crest factor >15 dB. We demonstrate that some characteristics changed markedly within ranges of ~10 km, and that the mean probability of exceeding criteria (i) and (ii) was <0.5 at ranges >3.5 km. In contrast, the mean probability of exceeding criteria (iii) remained >0.5 up to ~37.0 km, and the mean probability of exceeding criteria (iii) remained <0.5 throughout the range. These results suggest that a proportion of the recorded signals should be defined as impulsive based on each of the criteria, and that some of the criteria change markedly as a result of propagation. However, the impulsive nature of a sound is likely to be a complex interaction of all these criteria, and many other unrelated parameters such as duty cycle, recovery periods, and sound levels will also strongly affect the risk of hearing damage. We recommend future auditory damage studies and impact assessments explicitly consider the ranges at which sounds may lose some of their potentially hazardous characteristics.",
keywords = "seismic survey, pile driving, underwater noise, auditory damage, marine mammals, sound propagation",
author = "Gordon Hastie and Merchant, {Nathan D.} and Thomas G{\"o}tz and Russell, {Debbie J. F.} and Paul Thompson and Janik, {Vincent M.}",
note = "This work was funded as part of the Department of Energy and Climate Change's Offshore Energy Strategic Environmental Assessment programme, with additional resources from the National Capability funding from the Natural Environment Research Council to the Sea Mammal Research Unit (grant no. SMRU1001). Recordings of piling and seismic noise from the Moray Firth were collected with the support of the Department of Energy and Climate Change, Scottish Government, Oil and Gas UK Ltd., COWRIE, EU DOWNVInD project, Talisman Energy (UK) Ltd. and Scottish & Southern Energy. Thanks also to Helen Bailey and Keith Needham for making field recordings, Francesca Marubini for comments and suggestions on drafts of the manuscript, and to Stephen Robinson at the National Physics Laboratory and Douglas Gillespie at the Sea Mammal Research Unit for discussions and guidance about acoustic analyses.",
year = "2019",
month = "7",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1002/eap.1906",
language = "English",
volume = "29",
journal = "Ecological Applications",
issn = "1051-0761",
publisher = "Ecological Society of America",
number = "5",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Effects of impulsive noise on marine mammals

T2 - investigating range-dependent risk

AU - Hastie, Gordon

AU - Merchant, Nathan D.

AU - Götz, Thomas

AU - Russell, Debbie J. F.

AU - Thompson, Paul

AU - Janik, Vincent M.

N1 - This work was funded as part of the Department of Energy and Climate Change's Offshore Energy Strategic Environmental Assessment programme, with additional resources from the National Capability funding from the Natural Environment Research Council to the Sea Mammal Research Unit (grant no. SMRU1001). Recordings of piling and seismic noise from the Moray Firth were collected with the support of the Department of Energy and Climate Change, Scottish Government, Oil and Gas UK Ltd., COWRIE, EU DOWNVInD project, Talisman Energy (UK) Ltd. and Scottish & Southern Energy. Thanks also to Helen Bailey and Keith Needham for making field recordings, Francesca Marubini for comments and suggestions on drafts of the manuscript, and to Stephen Robinson at the National Physics Laboratory and Douglas Gillespie at the Sea Mammal Research Unit for discussions and guidance about acoustic analyses.

PY - 2019/7/1

Y1 - 2019/7/1

N2 - Concerns exist about the impacts of underwater noise on marine mammals. These include auditory damage, which is a significant risk for marine mammals exposed to impulsive sounds such as explosions, pile-driving, and seismic airguns. Currently, impact assessments use different risk criteria for impulsive and non-impulsive sounds (e.g. ships, drilling). However, as impulsive sounds dissipate through the environment, they potentially lose hazardous features (e.g. sudden onset) and become non-impulsive at some distance from the source. Despite management implications, a lack of data on range-dependent characteristics currently limits their inclusion in impact assessments. We address this using acoustic recordings of seismic airguns and pile-driving to quantify range-dependency in impulsive characteristics using four criteria: (i) rise time <25 ms; (ii) quotient of peak pressure and pulse duration >5,000 Pa.s-1; (iii) duration <1 s; (iv) crest factor >15 dB. We demonstrate that some characteristics changed markedly within ranges of ~10 km, and that the mean probability of exceeding criteria (i) and (ii) was <0.5 at ranges >3.5 km. In contrast, the mean probability of exceeding criteria (iii) remained >0.5 up to ~37.0 km, and the mean probability of exceeding criteria (iii) remained <0.5 throughout the range. These results suggest that a proportion of the recorded signals should be defined as impulsive based on each of the criteria, and that some of the criteria change markedly as a result of propagation. However, the impulsive nature of a sound is likely to be a complex interaction of all these criteria, and many other unrelated parameters such as duty cycle, recovery periods, and sound levels will also strongly affect the risk of hearing damage. We recommend future auditory damage studies and impact assessments explicitly consider the ranges at which sounds may lose some of their potentially hazardous characteristics.

AB - Concerns exist about the impacts of underwater noise on marine mammals. These include auditory damage, which is a significant risk for marine mammals exposed to impulsive sounds such as explosions, pile-driving, and seismic airguns. Currently, impact assessments use different risk criteria for impulsive and non-impulsive sounds (e.g. ships, drilling). However, as impulsive sounds dissipate through the environment, they potentially lose hazardous features (e.g. sudden onset) and become non-impulsive at some distance from the source. Despite management implications, a lack of data on range-dependent characteristics currently limits their inclusion in impact assessments. We address this using acoustic recordings of seismic airguns and pile-driving to quantify range-dependency in impulsive characteristics using four criteria: (i) rise time <25 ms; (ii) quotient of peak pressure and pulse duration >5,000 Pa.s-1; (iii) duration <1 s; (iv) crest factor >15 dB. We demonstrate that some characteristics changed markedly within ranges of ~10 km, and that the mean probability of exceeding criteria (i) and (ii) was <0.5 at ranges >3.5 km. In contrast, the mean probability of exceeding criteria (iii) remained >0.5 up to ~37.0 km, and the mean probability of exceeding criteria (iii) remained <0.5 throughout the range. These results suggest that a proportion of the recorded signals should be defined as impulsive based on each of the criteria, and that some of the criteria change markedly as a result of propagation. However, the impulsive nature of a sound is likely to be a complex interaction of all these criteria, and many other unrelated parameters such as duty cycle, recovery periods, and sound levels will also strongly affect the risk of hearing damage. We recommend future auditory damage studies and impact assessments explicitly consider the ranges at which sounds may lose some of their potentially hazardous characteristics.

KW - seismic survey

KW - pile driving

KW - underwater noise

KW - auditory damage

KW - marine mammals

KW - sound propagation

UR - http://www.mendeley.com/research/effects-impulsive-noise-marine-mammals-investigating-rangedependent-risk

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85068229053&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1002/eap.1906

DO - 10.1002/eap.1906

M3 - Article

VL - 29

JO - Ecological Applications

JF - Ecological Applications

SN - 1051-0761

IS - 5

M1 - e01906

ER -