Error analysis of fixed grid formulation for boundary based structural optimisation

Peter Dunning, H Alicia Kim, Glen Mullineux

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

Abstract

The fixed grid finite element approximation has become popular with boundary based topology optimization methods, due to its simplicity and speed in updating stiffness matrices. However, maximum errors occur on the boundary due to the homogenization of bi-material elements. This is of particular significance to boundary based optimization as sensitivity analysis along the boundary often drives the optimization. To date only a limited study of fixed grid errors exists, focusing on numerical examples. Errors in the fixed grid stiffness matrix approximation were identified as a possible source of errors observed in previous studies. This paper analytically investigates the errors in the fixed grid stiffness matrix approximation compared to classic finite element results. The analysis shows that generally errors increase as area ratio decreases and they are shape dependent. A simple example is used to investigate the global effect of the fixed grid approximation.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publication7th ASMO UK/ISSMO conference on Engineering Design Optimization
EditorsVassili Toropov
Place of PublicationLeeds
PublisherASMO-UK
Number of pages10
ISBN (Electronic)9780853162728, 0853162727
Publication statusPublished - 8 Jul 2008

Fingerprint

Structural optimization
Error analysis
Stiffness matrix
Shape optimization
Sensitivity analysis

Cite this

Dunning, P., Kim, H. A., & Mullineux, G. (2008). Error analysis of fixed grid formulation for boundary based structural optimisation. In V. Toropov (Ed.), 7th ASMO UK/ISSMO conference on Engineering Design Optimization Leeds: ASMO-UK.

Error analysis of fixed grid formulation for boundary based structural optimisation. / Dunning, Peter; Kim, H Alicia; Mullineux, Glen.

7th ASMO UK/ISSMO conference on Engineering Design Optimization. ed. / Vassili Toropov. Leeds : ASMO-UK, 2008.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution

Dunning, P, Kim, HA & Mullineux, G 2008, Error analysis of fixed grid formulation for boundary based structural optimisation. in V Toropov (ed.), 7th ASMO UK/ISSMO conference on Engineering Design Optimization. ASMO-UK, Leeds.
Dunning P, Kim HA, Mullineux G. Error analysis of fixed grid formulation for boundary based structural optimisation. In Toropov V, editor, 7th ASMO UK/ISSMO conference on Engineering Design Optimization. Leeds: ASMO-UK. 2008
Dunning, Peter ; Kim, H Alicia ; Mullineux, Glen. / Error analysis of fixed grid formulation for boundary based structural optimisation. 7th ASMO UK/ISSMO conference on Engineering Design Optimization. editor / Vassili Toropov. Leeds : ASMO-UK, 2008.
@inproceedings{dc949bc3c83e415bb98e5d06d122ec26,
title = "Error analysis of fixed grid formulation for boundary based structural optimisation",
abstract = "The fixed grid finite element approximation has become popular with boundary based topology optimization methods, due to its simplicity and speed in updating stiffness matrices. However, maximum errors occur on the boundary due to the homogenization of bi-material elements. This is of particular significance to boundary based optimization as sensitivity analysis along the boundary often drives the optimization. To date only a limited study of fixed grid errors exists, focusing on numerical examples. Errors in the fixed grid stiffness matrix approximation were identified as a possible source of errors observed in previous studies. This paper analytically investigates the errors in the fixed grid stiffness matrix approximation compared to classic finite element results. The analysis shows that generally errors increase as area ratio decreases and they are shape dependent. A simple example is used to investigate the global effect of the fixed grid approximation.",
author = "Peter Dunning and Kim, {H Alicia} and Glen Mullineux",
year = "2008",
month = "7",
day = "8",
language = "English",
editor = "Vassili Toropov",
booktitle = "7th ASMO UK/ISSMO conference on Engineering Design Optimization",
publisher = "ASMO-UK",

}

TY - GEN

T1 - Error analysis of fixed grid formulation for boundary based structural optimisation

AU - Dunning, Peter

AU - Kim, H Alicia

AU - Mullineux, Glen

PY - 2008/7/8

Y1 - 2008/7/8

N2 - The fixed grid finite element approximation has become popular with boundary based topology optimization methods, due to its simplicity and speed in updating stiffness matrices. However, maximum errors occur on the boundary due to the homogenization of bi-material elements. This is of particular significance to boundary based optimization as sensitivity analysis along the boundary often drives the optimization. To date only a limited study of fixed grid errors exists, focusing on numerical examples. Errors in the fixed grid stiffness matrix approximation were identified as a possible source of errors observed in previous studies. This paper analytically investigates the errors in the fixed grid stiffness matrix approximation compared to classic finite element results. The analysis shows that generally errors increase as area ratio decreases and they are shape dependent. A simple example is used to investigate the global effect of the fixed grid approximation.

AB - The fixed grid finite element approximation has become popular with boundary based topology optimization methods, due to its simplicity and speed in updating stiffness matrices. However, maximum errors occur on the boundary due to the homogenization of bi-material elements. This is of particular significance to boundary based optimization as sensitivity analysis along the boundary often drives the optimization. To date only a limited study of fixed grid errors exists, focusing on numerical examples. Errors in the fixed grid stiffness matrix approximation were identified as a possible source of errors observed in previous studies. This paper analytically investigates the errors in the fixed grid stiffness matrix approximation compared to classic finite element results. The analysis shows that generally errors increase as area ratio decreases and they are shape dependent. A simple example is used to investigate the global effect of the fixed grid approximation.

M3 - Conference contribution

BT - 7th ASMO UK/ISSMO conference on Engineering Design Optimization

A2 - Toropov, Vassili

PB - ASMO-UK

CY - Leeds

ER -