Estimating cumulative exposure of wildlife to non-lethal disturbance using spatially explicit capture-recapture models

Fredrik Christiansen, Chiara G. Bertulli, Marianne H. Rasmussen, David Lusseau

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

20 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Impact assessments often focus on short-term behavioral responses of animals to human disturbance. However, the cumulative effects caused by repeated behavioral disruptions are of management concern because these effects have the potential to influence individuals' survival and reproduction. We need to estimate individual exposure rates to disturbance to determine cumulative effects. We present a new approach to estimate the spatial exposure of minke whales to whalewatching boats in Faxaflõi Bay, Iceland. We used recent advances in spatially explicit capture-recapture modeling to estimate the probability that whales would encounter a disturbance (i.e., whalewatching boat). We obtained spatially explicit individual encounter histories of individually identifiable animals using photo-identification. We divided the study area into 1-km2 grid cells and considered each cell a spatially distinct sampling unit. We used capture history of individuals to model and estimate spatial encounter probabilities of individual minke whales across the study area, accounting for heterogeneity in sampling effort. We inferred the exposure of individual minke whales to whalewatching vessels throughout the feeding season by estimating individual whale encounters with vessels using the whale encounter probabilities and spatially explicit whalewatching intensity in the same area, obtained from recorded whalewatching vessel tracks. We then estimated the cumulative time whales spent with whalewatching boats to assess the biological significance of whalewatching disturbances. The estimated exposure levels to boats varied considerably between individuals because of both temporal and spatial variations in the activity centers of whales and the whalewatching intensity in the area. However, although some whales were repeatedly exposed to whalewatching boats throughout the feeding season, the estimated cumulative time they spent with boats was very low. Although whalewatching boat interactions caused feeding disruptions for the whales, the estimated low cumulative exposure indicated that the whalewatching industry in its current state likely is not having any long-term negative effects on vital rates.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)311-324
Number of pages14
JournalJournal of Wildlife Management
Volume79
Issue number2
Early online date9 Jan 2015
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Feb 2015

Fingerprint

cumulative exposure
whales
whale
wildlife
boats
disturbance
vessel
exposure
animal
Iceland
sampling
behavioral response
history
temporal variation
spatial variation
animals

Keywords

  • cumulative effects
  • encounter intensity
  • encounter probability
  • habitat use
  • marine mammal
  • minke whale
  • photo-ID
  • spatial ecology
  • tourism impact

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Nature and Landscape Conservation
  • Ecology
  • Ecology, Evolution, Behavior and Systematics

Cite this

Estimating cumulative exposure of wildlife to non-lethal disturbance using spatially explicit capture-recapture models. / Christiansen, Fredrik; Bertulli, Chiara G.; Rasmussen, Marianne H.; Lusseau, David.

In: Journal of Wildlife Management, Vol. 79, No. 2, 01.02.2015, p. 311-324.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Christiansen, Fredrik ; Bertulli, Chiara G. ; Rasmussen, Marianne H. ; Lusseau, David. / Estimating cumulative exposure of wildlife to non-lethal disturbance using spatially explicit capture-recapture models. In: Journal of Wildlife Management. 2015 ; Vol. 79, No. 2. pp. 311-324.
@article{28046f4ebf2b4649a2a8adc78cfc5ddd,
title = "Estimating cumulative exposure of wildlife to non-lethal disturbance using spatially explicit capture-recapture models",
abstract = "Impact assessments often focus on short-term behavioral responses of animals to human disturbance. However, the cumulative effects caused by repeated behavioral disruptions are of management concern because these effects have the potential to influence individuals' survival and reproduction. We need to estimate individual exposure rates to disturbance to determine cumulative effects. We present a new approach to estimate the spatial exposure of minke whales to whalewatching boats in Faxafl{\~o}i Bay, Iceland. We used recent advances in spatially explicit capture-recapture modeling to estimate the probability that whales would encounter a disturbance (i.e., whalewatching boat). We obtained spatially explicit individual encounter histories of individually identifiable animals using photo-identification. We divided the study area into 1-km2 grid cells and considered each cell a spatially distinct sampling unit. We used capture history of individuals to model and estimate spatial encounter probabilities of individual minke whales across the study area, accounting for heterogeneity in sampling effort. We inferred the exposure of individual minke whales to whalewatching vessels throughout the feeding season by estimating individual whale encounters with vessels using the whale encounter probabilities and spatially explicit whalewatching intensity in the same area, obtained from recorded whalewatching vessel tracks. We then estimated the cumulative time whales spent with whalewatching boats to assess the biological significance of whalewatching disturbances. The estimated exposure levels to boats varied considerably between individuals because of both temporal and spatial variations in the activity centers of whales and the whalewatching intensity in the area. However, although some whales were repeatedly exposed to whalewatching boats throughout the feeding season, the estimated cumulative time they spent with boats was very low. Although whalewatching boat interactions caused feeding disruptions for the whales, the estimated low cumulative exposure indicated that the whalewatching industry in its current state likely is not having any long-term negative effects on vital rates.",
keywords = "cumulative effects, encounter intensity, encounter probability, habitat use, marine mammal, minke whale, photo-ID, spatial ecology, tourism impact",
author = "Fredrik Christiansen and Bertulli, {Chiara G.} and Rasmussen, {Marianne H.} and David Lusseau",
note = "ACKNOWLEDGMENTS We thank all the volunteers who assisted C. G. Bertulli with the photo-ID data collection. We thank Elding Whale Watching for logistical support during the data collection. We thank Dr. M. G. Efford for his advice during the model development phase and Dr. D. L. Borchers who provided much valuable feedback on the analysis and an earlier draft of this paper. Finally, we thank Associate Editor Dr. S. J. Converse and 2 anonymous reviewers for their constructive comments, which helped to improve this manuscript.",
year = "2015",
month = "2",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1002/jwmg.836",
language = "English",
volume = "79",
pages = "311--324",
journal = "Journal of Wildlife Management",
issn = "0022-541X",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Estimating cumulative exposure of wildlife to non-lethal disturbance using spatially explicit capture-recapture models

AU - Christiansen, Fredrik

AU - Bertulli, Chiara G.

AU - Rasmussen, Marianne H.

AU - Lusseau, David

N1 - ACKNOWLEDGMENTS We thank all the volunteers who assisted C. G. Bertulli with the photo-ID data collection. We thank Elding Whale Watching for logistical support during the data collection. We thank Dr. M. G. Efford for his advice during the model development phase and Dr. D. L. Borchers who provided much valuable feedback on the analysis and an earlier draft of this paper. Finally, we thank Associate Editor Dr. S. J. Converse and 2 anonymous reviewers for their constructive comments, which helped to improve this manuscript.

PY - 2015/2/1

Y1 - 2015/2/1

N2 - Impact assessments often focus on short-term behavioral responses of animals to human disturbance. However, the cumulative effects caused by repeated behavioral disruptions are of management concern because these effects have the potential to influence individuals' survival and reproduction. We need to estimate individual exposure rates to disturbance to determine cumulative effects. We present a new approach to estimate the spatial exposure of minke whales to whalewatching boats in Faxaflõi Bay, Iceland. We used recent advances in spatially explicit capture-recapture modeling to estimate the probability that whales would encounter a disturbance (i.e., whalewatching boat). We obtained spatially explicit individual encounter histories of individually identifiable animals using photo-identification. We divided the study area into 1-km2 grid cells and considered each cell a spatially distinct sampling unit. We used capture history of individuals to model and estimate spatial encounter probabilities of individual minke whales across the study area, accounting for heterogeneity in sampling effort. We inferred the exposure of individual minke whales to whalewatching vessels throughout the feeding season by estimating individual whale encounters with vessels using the whale encounter probabilities and spatially explicit whalewatching intensity in the same area, obtained from recorded whalewatching vessel tracks. We then estimated the cumulative time whales spent with whalewatching boats to assess the biological significance of whalewatching disturbances. The estimated exposure levels to boats varied considerably between individuals because of both temporal and spatial variations in the activity centers of whales and the whalewatching intensity in the area. However, although some whales were repeatedly exposed to whalewatching boats throughout the feeding season, the estimated cumulative time they spent with boats was very low. Although whalewatching boat interactions caused feeding disruptions for the whales, the estimated low cumulative exposure indicated that the whalewatching industry in its current state likely is not having any long-term negative effects on vital rates.

AB - Impact assessments often focus on short-term behavioral responses of animals to human disturbance. However, the cumulative effects caused by repeated behavioral disruptions are of management concern because these effects have the potential to influence individuals' survival and reproduction. We need to estimate individual exposure rates to disturbance to determine cumulative effects. We present a new approach to estimate the spatial exposure of minke whales to whalewatching boats in Faxaflõi Bay, Iceland. We used recent advances in spatially explicit capture-recapture modeling to estimate the probability that whales would encounter a disturbance (i.e., whalewatching boat). We obtained spatially explicit individual encounter histories of individually identifiable animals using photo-identification. We divided the study area into 1-km2 grid cells and considered each cell a spatially distinct sampling unit. We used capture history of individuals to model and estimate spatial encounter probabilities of individual minke whales across the study area, accounting for heterogeneity in sampling effort. We inferred the exposure of individual minke whales to whalewatching vessels throughout the feeding season by estimating individual whale encounters with vessels using the whale encounter probabilities and spatially explicit whalewatching intensity in the same area, obtained from recorded whalewatching vessel tracks. We then estimated the cumulative time whales spent with whalewatching boats to assess the biological significance of whalewatching disturbances. The estimated exposure levels to boats varied considerably between individuals because of both temporal and spatial variations in the activity centers of whales and the whalewatching intensity in the area. However, although some whales were repeatedly exposed to whalewatching boats throughout the feeding season, the estimated cumulative time they spent with boats was very low. Although whalewatching boat interactions caused feeding disruptions for the whales, the estimated low cumulative exposure indicated that the whalewatching industry in its current state likely is not having any long-term negative effects on vital rates.

KW - cumulative effects

KW - encounter intensity

KW - encounter probability

KW - habitat use

KW - marine mammal

KW - minke whale

KW - photo-ID

KW - spatial ecology

KW - tourism impact

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84921499743&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1002/jwmg.836

DO - 10.1002/jwmg.836

M3 - Article

VL - 79

SP - 311

EP - 324

JO - Journal of Wildlife Management

JF - Journal of Wildlife Management

SN - 0022-541X

IS - 2

ER -