Estimating size and assessing trends in a coastal bottlenose dolphin population

B Wilson, P S Hammond, P M Thompson

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

245 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

We used a case study of a coastal bottlenose dolphin population to present a framework for determining the number of individuals present and assessing the likely time scale over which trends in abundance may be determined. Such a framework is appropriate for animal species that possess natural markings sufficient for individual recognition, and may be valuable in the development and implementation of management and monitoring programs for vulnerable populations.

Population abundance was estimated using mark-recapture methods applied to photoidentification data. This experiment was designed to minimize violation of method assumptions so as to allow use of the most parsimonious model for analysis. The data were examined critically to investigate mark-recapture assumptions, while analytical methods and data were selected to minimize and, where necessary, account for violations. The estimated number of animals with long-lasting marks from left and right side estimates were 73 +/- 12 and 80 +/- 11 individuals, respectively (means +/- 1 se). When divided by the estimated proportion of such animals in the population (0.57 +/- 0.043 and 0.61 +/- 0.035, respectively) and averaged, weighted by inverse variance, a total population size of 129 +/- 15 individual animals was estimated (95% CI = 110-174 animals).

Data on calves observed and carcasses recovered suggest that the population could be increasing or decreasing at an annual rate of up to 5%. A power analysis, undertaken to investigate the length of monitoring program required to detect changes in population abundance at a 90% level of certainty, showed that detection of a trend could only occur following >8 yr of research effort. Biennial sampling has power similar to that of annual sampling, but savings in resources are offset by the loss of data on the reproductive histories of individuals.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)288-300
Number of pages13
JournalEcological Applications
Volume9
Publication statusPublished - 1999

Keywords

  • abundance
  • bottlenose dolphin
  • cetacea
  • management
  • mark-recapture
  • monitoring
  • Moray Firth
  • Scotland
  • North Sea
  • photoidentification
  • population trends
  • power analysis
  • Tursiops
  • truncatus
  • NOSED DOLPHINS
  • TURSIOPS-TRUNCATUS
  • STATISTICAL POWER
  • MORAY FIRTH
  • WHALES
  • PARAMETERS

Cite this

Estimating size and assessing trends in a coastal bottlenose dolphin population. / Wilson, B ; Hammond, P S ; Thompson, P M .

In: Ecological Applications, Vol. 9, 1999, p. 288-300.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{ea888c5d0c5e446f8328270ceaf6b349,
title = "Estimating size and assessing trends in a coastal bottlenose dolphin population",
abstract = "We used a case study of a coastal bottlenose dolphin population to present a framework for determining the number of individuals present and assessing the likely time scale over which trends in abundance may be determined. Such a framework is appropriate for animal species that possess natural markings sufficient for individual recognition, and may be valuable in the development and implementation of management and monitoring programs for vulnerable populations.Population abundance was estimated using mark-recapture methods applied to photoidentification data. This experiment was designed to minimize violation of method assumptions so as to allow use of the most parsimonious model for analysis. The data were examined critically to investigate mark-recapture assumptions, while analytical methods and data were selected to minimize and, where necessary, account for violations. The estimated number of animals with long-lasting marks from left and right side estimates were 73 +/- 12 and 80 +/- 11 individuals, respectively (means +/- 1 se). When divided by the estimated proportion of such animals in the population (0.57 +/- 0.043 and 0.61 +/- 0.035, respectively) and averaged, weighted by inverse variance, a total population size of 129 +/- 15 individual animals was estimated (95{\%} CI = 110-174 animals).Data on calves observed and carcasses recovered suggest that the population could be increasing or decreasing at an annual rate of up to 5{\%}. A power analysis, undertaken to investigate the length of monitoring program required to detect changes in population abundance at a 90{\%} level of certainty, showed that detection of a trend could only occur following >8 yr of research effort. Biennial sampling has power similar to that of annual sampling, but savings in resources are offset by the loss of data on the reproductive histories of individuals.",
keywords = "abundance, bottlenose dolphin, cetacea, management, mark-recapture, monitoring, Moray Firth, Scotland, North Sea, photoidentification, population trends, power analysis, Tursiops, truncatus, NOSED DOLPHINS, TURSIOPS-TRUNCATUS, STATISTICAL POWER, MORAY FIRTH, WHALES, PARAMETERS",
author = "B Wilson and Hammond, {P S} and Thompson, {P M}",
year = "1999",
language = "English",
volume = "9",
pages = "288--300",
journal = "Ecological Applications",
issn = "1051-0761",
publisher = "Ecological Society of America",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Estimating size and assessing trends in a coastal bottlenose dolphin population

AU - Wilson, B

AU - Hammond, P S

AU - Thompson, P M

PY - 1999

Y1 - 1999

N2 - We used a case study of a coastal bottlenose dolphin population to present a framework for determining the number of individuals present and assessing the likely time scale over which trends in abundance may be determined. Such a framework is appropriate for animal species that possess natural markings sufficient for individual recognition, and may be valuable in the development and implementation of management and monitoring programs for vulnerable populations.Population abundance was estimated using mark-recapture methods applied to photoidentification data. This experiment was designed to minimize violation of method assumptions so as to allow use of the most parsimonious model for analysis. The data were examined critically to investigate mark-recapture assumptions, while analytical methods and data were selected to minimize and, where necessary, account for violations. The estimated number of animals with long-lasting marks from left and right side estimates were 73 +/- 12 and 80 +/- 11 individuals, respectively (means +/- 1 se). When divided by the estimated proportion of such animals in the population (0.57 +/- 0.043 and 0.61 +/- 0.035, respectively) and averaged, weighted by inverse variance, a total population size of 129 +/- 15 individual animals was estimated (95% CI = 110-174 animals).Data on calves observed and carcasses recovered suggest that the population could be increasing or decreasing at an annual rate of up to 5%. A power analysis, undertaken to investigate the length of monitoring program required to detect changes in population abundance at a 90% level of certainty, showed that detection of a trend could only occur following >8 yr of research effort. Biennial sampling has power similar to that of annual sampling, but savings in resources are offset by the loss of data on the reproductive histories of individuals.

AB - We used a case study of a coastal bottlenose dolphin population to present a framework for determining the number of individuals present and assessing the likely time scale over which trends in abundance may be determined. Such a framework is appropriate for animal species that possess natural markings sufficient for individual recognition, and may be valuable in the development and implementation of management and monitoring programs for vulnerable populations.Population abundance was estimated using mark-recapture methods applied to photoidentification data. This experiment was designed to minimize violation of method assumptions so as to allow use of the most parsimonious model for analysis. The data were examined critically to investigate mark-recapture assumptions, while analytical methods and data were selected to minimize and, where necessary, account for violations. The estimated number of animals with long-lasting marks from left and right side estimates were 73 +/- 12 and 80 +/- 11 individuals, respectively (means +/- 1 se). When divided by the estimated proportion of such animals in the population (0.57 +/- 0.043 and 0.61 +/- 0.035, respectively) and averaged, weighted by inverse variance, a total population size of 129 +/- 15 individual animals was estimated (95% CI = 110-174 animals).Data on calves observed and carcasses recovered suggest that the population could be increasing or decreasing at an annual rate of up to 5%. A power analysis, undertaken to investigate the length of monitoring program required to detect changes in population abundance at a 90% level of certainty, showed that detection of a trend could only occur following >8 yr of research effort. Biennial sampling has power similar to that of annual sampling, but savings in resources are offset by the loss of data on the reproductive histories of individuals.

KW - abundance

KW - bottlenose dolphin

KW - cetacea

KW - management

KW - mark-recapture

KW - monitoring

KW - Moray Firth

KW - Scotland

KW - North Sea

KW - photoidentification

KW - population trends

KW - power analysis

KW - Tursiops

KW - truncatus

KW - NOSED DOLPHINS

KW - TURSIOPS-TRUNCATUS

KW - STATISTICAL POWER

KW - MORAY FIRTH

KW - WHALES

KW - PARAMETERS

M3 - Article

VL - 9

SP - 288

EP - 300

JO - Ecological Applications

JF - Ecological Applications

SN - 1051-0761

ER -