Ethical tensions associated with the promotion of public health policy in health visiting

a qualitative investigation of health visitors' views

Julie Catherine Greenway, Vikki Ann Entwistle, Ruud Termeulen

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

4 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Aim To explore whether and how health visitors experience ethical tensions between the public health agenda and the need to be responsive to individual clients. BACKGROUND: Current health policy in England gives health visitors a key role in implementing the government's public health agenda. Health visitors are also required by their Professional Code to respond to the health-related concerns and preferences of their individual clients. This may generate tensions. METHODS: A total of 17 semi-structured individual interviews covering participants' experiences of implementing public health interventions and perceptions of the ethical tensions involved were conducted. Interviews were audio-recorded, transcribed and analysed thematically using a Framework approach. Findings Health visitors raised a number of ethical concerns, which they attributed to organisational resource allocation and the introduction of protocols and targets relating to public health goals. They did not always regard it as appropriate to raise topics that employing organisations had identified as public health priorities with particular clients for whom they were not priorities, or who had other more pressing needs. They noted that resources that were allocated towards reaching public health targets were unavailable for clients who needed support in other areas. Organisational protocols designed to monitor performance put pressure on health visitors to prioritise achieving targets and undermined their ability to exercise professional judgement when supporting individual clients. This had implications for health visitors' sense of professionalism. Health visitors saw trusting relationships as key to effective health visiting practice, but the requirement to implement public health priorities, combined with a lack of resources in health visiting, eroded their ability to form these. Policies need to be evaluated with regard to their impact upon a broader range of processes and outcomes than public health goals. The erosion of health visitors' professional values and ability to develop relationships with clients could have numerous adverse implications.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)200-211
Number of pages12
JournalPrimary health care research & development
Volume14
Issue number2
Early online date10 Aug 2012
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Apr 2013

Fingerprint

Community Health Nurses
Public Policy
Health Policy
Health Promotion
Public Health
Health
Aptitude
Health Priorities
Interviews
Resource Allocation
Health Resources
England
Organizations
Exercise
Pressure

Keywords

  • community health nursing
  • ethics
  • professional-patient relations
  • public health

Cite this

Ethical tensions associated with the promotion of public health policy in health visiting : a qualitative investigation of health visitors' views. / Greenway, Julie Catherine; Entwistle, Vikki Ann; Termeulen, Ruud.

In: Primary health care research & development, Vol. 14, No. 2, 04.2013, p. 200-211.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{539a59664ad24ccb8d10d302dfe90cfe,
title = "Ethical tensions associated with the promotion of public health policy in health visiting: a qualitative investigation of health visitors' views",
abstract = "Aim To explore whether and how health visitors experience ethical tensions between the public health agenda and the need to be responsive to individual clients. BACKGROUND: Current health policy in England gives health visitors a key role in implementing the government's public health agenda. Health visitors are also required by their Professional Code to respond to the health-related concerns and preferences of their individual clients. This may generate tensions. METHODS: A total of 17 semi-structured individual interviews covering participants' experiences of implementing public health interventions and perceptions of the ethical tensions involved were conducted. Interviews were audio-recorded, transcribed and analysed thematically using a Framework approach. Findings Health visitors raised a number of ethical concerns, which they attributed to organisational resource allocation and the introduction of protocols and targets relating to public health goals. They did not always regard it as appropriate to raise topics that employing organisations had identified as public health priorities with particular clients for whom they were not priorities, or who had other more pressing needs. They noted that resources that were allocated towards reaching public health targets were unavailable for clients who needed support in other areas. Organisational protocols designed to monitor performance put pressure on health visitors to prioritise achieving targets and undermined their ability to exercise professional judgement when supporting individual clients. This had implications for health visitors' sense of professionalism. Health visitors saw trusting relationships as key to effective health visiting practice, but the requirement to implement public health priorities, combined with a lack of resources in health visiting, eroded their ability to form these. Policies need to be evaluated with regard to their impact upon a broader range of processes and outcomes than public health goals. The erosion of health visitors' professional values and ability to develop relationships with clients could have numerous adverse implications.",
keywords = "community health nursing, ethics, professional-patient relations, public health",
author = "Greenway, {Julie Catherine} and Entwistle, {Vikki Ann} and Ruud Termeulen",
year = "2013",
month = "4",
doi = "10.1017/S1463423612000400",
language = "English",
volume = "14",
pages = "200--211",
journal = "Primary health care research & development",
issn = "1477-1128",
publisher = "Cambridge University Press",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Ethical tensions associated with the promotion of public health policy in health visiting

T2 - a qualitative investigation of health visitors' views

AU - Greenway, Julie Catherine

AU - Entwistle, Vikki Ann

AU - Termeulen, Ruud

PY - 2013/4

Y1 - 2013/4

N2 - Aim To explore whether and how health visitors experience ethical tensions between the public health agenda and the need to be responsive to individual clients. BACKGROUND: Current health policy in England gives health visitors a key role in implementing the government's public health agenda. Health visitors are also required by their Professional Code to respond to the health-related concerns and preferences of their individual clients. This may generate tensions. METHODS: A total of 17 semi-structured individual interviews covering participants' experiences of implementing public health interventions and perceptions of the ethical tensions involved were conducted. Interviews were audio-recorded, transcribed and analysed thematically using a Framework approach. Findings Health visitors raised a number of ethical concerns, which they attributed to organisational resource allocation and the introduction of protocols and targets relating to public health goals. They did not always regard it as appropriate to raise topics that employing organisations had identified as public health priorities with particular clients for whom they were not priorities, or who had other more pressing needs. They noted that resources that were allocated towards reaching public health targets were unavailable for clients who needed support in other areas. Organisational protocols designed to monitor performance put pressure on health visitors to prioritise achieving targets and undermined their ability to exercise professional judgement when supporting individual clients. This had implications for health visitors' sense of professionalism. Health visitors saw trusting relationships as key to effective health visiting practice, but the requirement to implement public health priorities, combined with a lack of resources in health visiting, eroded their ability to form these. Policies need to be evaluated with regard to their impact upon a broader range of processes and outcomes than public health goals. The erosion of health visitors' professional values and ability to develop relationships with clients could have numerous adverse implications.

AB - Aim To explore whether and how health visitors experience ethical tensions between the public health agenda and the need to be responsive to individual clients. BACKGROUND: Current health policy in England gives health visitors a key role in implementing the government's public health agenda. Health visitors are also required by their Professional Code to respond to the health-related concerns and preferences of their individual clients. This may generate tensions. METHODS: A total of 17 semi-structured individual interviews covering participants' experiences of implementing public health interventions and perceptions of the ethical tensions involved were conducted. Interviews were audio-recorded, transcribed and analysed thematically using a Framework approach. Findings Health visitors raised a number of ethical concerns, which they attributed to organisational resource allocation and the introduction of protocols and targets relating to public health goals. They did not always regard it as appropriate to raise topics that employing organisations had identified as public health priorities with particular clients for whom they were not priorities, or who had other more pressing needs. They noted that resources that were allocated towards reaching public health targets were unavailable for clients who needed support in other areas. Organisational protocols designed to monitor performance put pressure on health visitors to prioritise achieving targets and undermined their ability to exercise professional judgement when supporting individual clients. This had implications for health visitors' sense of professionalism. Health visitors saw trusting relationships as key to effective health visiting practice, but the requirement to implement public health priorities, combined with a lack of resources in health visiting, eroded their ability to form these. Policies need to be evaluated with regard to their impact upon a broader range of processes and outcomes than public health goals. The erosion of health visitors' professional values and ability to develop relationships with clients could have numerous adverse implications.

KW - community health nursing

KW - ethics

KW - professional-patient relations

KW - public health

U2 - 10.1017/S1463423612000400

DO - 10.1017/S1463423612000400

M3 - Article

VL - 14

SP - 200

EP - 211

JO - Primary health care research & development

JF - Primary health care research & development

SN - 1477-1128

IS - 2

ER -