Evaluating effectiveness of complex interventions aimed at reducing maternal mortality in developing countries

Louise Ross, Padam Prasad Simkhada, William Cairns Stewart Smith

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

13 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Background Reducing the worldwide mortality ratio by 75 per cent between 1990 and 2015 is a key Millennium Development Goal. Randomized controlled trials (RCTs) are the accepted 'gold standard' to assess the effectiveness of interventions but they are not always appropriate for practical, ethical or economic reasons in developing countries. This study examines the use of cluster randomized trials and quasi-experimental (nonrandomized) study designs to evaluate complex interventions implemented to reduce maternal mortality.

Methods We systematically searched electronic databases including MEDLINE, EMBASE, CINAHL, BNI, ASSIA, IBSS, CSA and COCHRANE. English language publications between 1990 and 2003 were included. Studies that assessed the effects of complex interventions aimed at reducing maternal mortality in developing countries were included.

Results Four cluster randomized trials and eleven quasi-experimental studies were identified. Two cluster randomized trials examined reduction in prenatal visits with no adverse effects on maternal mortality. Two trials assessed the effects of vitamin A supplementation. Both trials found a significant reduction in maternal mortality ratios after vitamin A supplementation. A decline in maternal deaths was reported in eight of the nonrandomized studies. Measuring maternal mortality was a frequent problem because of insufficient sample sizes and/or poor recording methods. Other limitations include lack of suitable comparison groups and difficulties assessing the effects of confounding factors in the quasi-experimental studies.

Conclusions RCTs may not be appropriate to evaluate complex interventions in maternal mortality and cluster RCTs and quasi-experimental designs may be more suitable. However, further work is required to improve the robustness of such alternative study designs.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)331-337
Number of pages6
JournalJournal of Public Health
Volume27
Issue number4
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Dec 2005

Keywords

  • cluster
  • maternal mortality
  • nonrandomized
  • EMERGENCY OBSTETRIC CARE
  • RANDOMIZED-TRIAL
  • ANTENATAL CARE
  • BETA-CAROTENE
  • VITAMIN-A
  • PROGRAM
  • PREGNANCY
  • SUPPLEMENTATION
  • BANGLADESH
  • NIGERIA

Cite this

Evaluating effectiveness of complex interventions aimed at reducing maternal mortality in developing countries. / Ross, Louise; Simkhada, Padam Prasad; Smith, William Cairns Stewart.

In: Journal of Public Health, Vol. 27, No. 4, 12.2005, p. 331-337.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{07af92364ae24bf48f1790e2b176afd4,
title = "Evaluating effectiveness of complex interventions aimed at reducing maternal mortality in developing countries",
abstract = "Background Reducing the worldwide mortality ratio by 75 per cent between 1990 and 2015 is a key Millennium Development Goal. Randomized controlled trials (RCTs) are the accepted 'gold standard' to assess the effectiveness of interventions but they are not always appropriate for practical, ethical or economic reasons in developing countries. This study examines the use of cluster randomized trials and quasi-experimental (nonrandomized) study designs to evaluate complex interventions implemented to reduce maternal mortality.Methods We systematically searched electronic databases including MEDLINE, EMBASE, CINAHL, BNI, ASSIA, IBSS, CSA and COCHRANE. English language publications between 1990 and 2003 were included. Studies that assessed the effects of complex interventions aimed at reducing maternal mortality in developing countries were included.Results Four cluster randomized trials and eleven quasi-experimental studies were identified. Two cluster randomized trials examined reduction in prenatal visits with no adverse effects on maternal mortality. Two trials assessed the effects of vitamin A supplementation. Both trials found a significant reduction in maternal mortality ratios after vitamin A supplementation. A decline in maternal deaths was reported in eight of the nonrandomized studies. Measuring maternal mortality was a frequent problem because of insufficient sample sizes and/or poor recording methods. Other limitations include lack of suitable comparison groups and difficulties assessing the effects of confounding factors in the quasi-experimental studies.Conclusions RCTs may not be appropriate to evaluate complex interventions in maternal mortality and cluster RCTs and quasi-experimental designs may be more suitable. However, further work is required to improve the robustness of such alternative study designs.",
keywords = "cluster, maternal mortality, nonrandomized, EMERGENCY OBSTETRIC CARE, RANDOMIZED-TRIAL, ANTENATAL CARE, BETA-CAROTENE, VITAMIN-A, PROGRAM, PREGNANCY, SUPPLEMENTATION, BANGLADESH, NIGERIA",
author = "Louise Ross and Simkhada, {Padam Prasad} and Smith, {William Cairns Stewart}",
year = "2005",
month = "12",
doi = "10.1093/pubmed/fdi058",
language = "English",
volume = "27",
pages = "331--337",
journal = "Journal of Public Health",
issn = "1741-3842",
publisher = "Oxford University Press",
number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Evaluating effectiveness of complex interventions aimed at reducing maternal mortality in developing countries

AU - Ross, Louise

AU - Simkhada, Padam Prasad

AU - Smith, William Cairns Stewart

PY - 2005/12

Y1 - 2005/12

N2 - Background Reducing the worldwide mortality ratio by 75 per cent between 1990 and 2015 is a key Millennium Development Goal. Randomized controlled trials (RCTs) are the accepted 'gold standard' to assess the effectiveness of interventions but they are not always appropriate for practical, ethical or economic reasons in developing countries. This study examines the use of cluster randomized trials and quasi-experimental (nonrandomized) study designs to evaluate complex interventions implemented to reduce maternal mortality.Methods We systematically searched electronic databases including MEDLINE, EMBASE, CINAHL, BNI, ASSIA, IBSS, CSA and COCHRANE. English language publications between 1990 and 2003 were included. Studies that assessed the effects of complex interventions aimed at reducing maternal mortality in developing countries were included.Results Four cluster randomized trials and eleven quasi-experimental studies were identified. Two cluster randomized trials examined reduction in prenatal visits with no adverse effects on maternal mortality. Two trials assessed the effects of vitamin A supplementation. Both trials found a significant reduction in maternal mortality ratios after vitamin A supplementation. A decline in maternal deaths was reported in eight of the nonrandomized studies. Measuring maternal mortality was a frequent problem because of insufficient sample sizes and/or poor recording methods. Other limitations include lack of suitable comparison groups and difficulties assessing the effects of confounding factors in the quasi-experimental studies.Conclusions RCTs may not be appropriate to evaluate complex interventions in maternal mortality and cluster RCTs and quasi-experimental designs may be more suitable. However, further work is required to improve the robustness of such alternative study designs.

AB - Background Reducing the worldwide mortality ratio by 75 per cent between 1990 and 2015 is a key Millennium Development Goal. Randomized controlled trials (RCTs) are the accepted 'gold standard' to assess the effectiveness of interventions but they are not always appropriate for practical, ethical or economic reasons in developing countries. This study examines the use of cluster randomized trials and quasi-experimental (nonrandomized) study designs to evaluate complex interventions implemented to reduce maternal mortality.Methods We systematically searched electronic databases including MEDLINE, EMBASE, CINAHL, BNI, ASSIA, IBSS, CSA and COCHRANE. English language publications between 1990 and 2003 were included. Studies that assessed the effects of complex interventions aimed at reducing maternal mortality in developing countries were included.Results Four cluster randomized trials and eleven quasi-experimental studies were identified. Two cluster randomized trials examined reduction in prenatal visits with no adverse effects on maternal mortality. Two trials assessed the effects of vitamin A supplementation. Both trials found a significant reduction in maternal mortality ratios after vitamin A supplementation. A decline in maternal deaths was reported in eight of the nonrandomized studies. Measuring maternal mortality was a frequent problem because of insufficient sample sizes and/or poor recording methods. Other limitations include lack of suitable comparison groups and difficulties assessing the effects of confounding factors in the quasi-experimental studies.Conclusions RCTs may not be appropriate to evaluate complex interventions in maternal mortality and cluster RCTs and quasi-experimental designs may be more suitable. However, further work is required to improve the robustness of such alternative study designs.

KW - cluster

KW - maternal mortality

KW - nonrandomized

KW - EMERGENCY OBSTETRIC CARE

KW - RANDOMIZED-TRIAL

KW - ANTENATAL CARE

KW - BETA-CAROTENE

KW - VITAMIN-A

KW - PROGRAM

KW - PREGNANCY

KW - SUPPLEMENTATION

KW - BANGLADESH

KW - NIGERIA

U2 - 10.1093/pubmed/fdi058

DO - 10.1093/pubmed/fdi058

M3 - Article

VL - 27

SP - 331

EP - 337

JO - Journal of Public Health

JF - Journal of Public Health

SN - 1741-3842

IS - 4

ER -