Evaluation of hot-film, dual optical and Pitot tube probes for liquid-liquid two-phase flow measurements

Faik Hamad, Shuisheng He

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

24 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

An experimental study of kerosene–water upward two-phaseflow in a vertical pipe was carried out using hot-film, dualoptical and Pitottubeprobes to measure the water, kerosene drops and mixture velocities. Experiments were conducted in a vertical pipe of 77.8 mm inner diameter at 4.2 m from the inlet (L/D=54). The tests were carried out for constant superficial water velocities of 0.29, 0.59 and 0.77 m/s (flow rates = 83, 167 and 220 l/min) and volume fractions of 4.2%, 9.2%, 18.6% and 28.2%. The Fluent 6.3.26 was used to model the single and two-phaseflow and to reproduce the results for the experimental study. Two methods were used to evaluate the accuracy of the probes for the measurement of the velocities of water, drops and mixture for two-phaseflow: (i) comparison of measured local velocities with predictions from the CFD simulation; (ii) comparison between the area-averaged velocities calculated from the integration of the local measurements of water, drops and mixture velocities and velocities calculated from flow meters’ measurements.

The results for single phaseflow measured using Pitottube and hot-filmprobe agree well with CFD predictions. In the case of two-phaseflow, the water and drops velocities were measured by hot-film and dualopticalprobes respectively. The latter was also used to measure the volume fraction. These three measured parameters were used to calculate the mixture velocity. The Pitottube was also used to measure the mixture velocity by applying the same principle used for single phaseflow velocity. Overall the mixture local velocity measured by Pitottube and that calculated from hot-film and dualopticalprobemeasurements agreed well with Fluent predictions. The discrepancy between the mixture area-averaged velocity and velocity calculated from flow meters was less than 10% except for one test case. It is concluded that the combined hot-film and optical approach can be used for water and drop velocity measurements with good accuracy for the flow conditions considered in this study. The Pitottube can also be used for the measurement of mixture velocities for conditions of mixture velocities greater than 0.4 m/s. The small discrepancy between the predictions and experimental data from the present study and literature demonstrated that both instrumentation and CFD simulations have the potential for two-phaseflow investigation and industrial applications.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)302-311
Number of pages10
JournalFlow Measurement and Instrumentation
Volume21
Issue number3
Early online date25 Mar 2010
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Sep 2010

Fingerprint

pitot tubes
Phase Measurement
Flow Measurement
Phase measurement
Liquid Flow
flow measurement
Flow measurement
two phase flow
Two-phase Flow
Two phase flow
Tube
Probe
Liquid
tubes
evaluation
probes
Liquids
Evaluation
liquids
Water

Keywords

  • hot-film probe
  • dual optical probe
  • pitot tube
  • kerosene-water two-phase flow
  • mixture velocity
  • CFD simulation

Cite this

Evaluation of hot-film, dual optical and Pitot tube probes for liquid-liquid two-phase flow measurements. / Hamad, Faik; He, Shuisheng.

In: Flow Measurement and Instrumentation, Vol. 21, No. 3, 09.2010, p. 302-311.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{651de9bb344b4e1ca5bcd59c38b335b6,
title = "Evaluation of hot-film, dual optical and Pitot tube probes for liquid-liquid two-phase flow measurements",
abstract = "An experimental study of kerosene–water upward two-phaseflow in a vertical pipe was carried out using hot-film, dualoptical and Pitottubeprobes to measure the water, kerosene drops and mixture velocities. Experiments were conducted in a vertical pipe of 77.8 mm inner diameter at 4.2 m from the inlet (L/D=54). The tests were carried out for constant superficial water velocities of 0.29, 0.59 and 0.77 m/s (flow rates = 83, 167 and 220 l/min) and volume fractions of 4.2{\%}, 9.2{\%}, 18.6{\%} and 28.2{\%}. The Fluent 6.3.26 was used to model the single and two-phaseflow and to reproduce the results for the experimental study. Two methods were used to evaluate the accuracy of the probes for the measurement of the velocities of water, drops and mixture for two-phaseflow: (i) comparison of measured local velocities with predictions from the CFD simulation; (ii) comparison between the area-averaged velocities calculated from the integration of the local measurements of water, drops and mixture velocities and velocities calculated from flow meters’ measurements. The results for single phaseflow measured using Pitottube and hot-filmprobe agree well with CFD predictions. In the case of two-phaseflow, the water and drops velocities were measured by hot-film and dualopticalprobes respectively. The latter was also used to measure the volume fraction. These three measured parameters were used to calculate the mixture velocity. The Pitottube was also used to measure the mixture velocity by applying the same principle used for single phaseflow velocity. Overall the mixture local velocity measured by Pitottube and that calculated from hot-film and dualopticalprobemeasurements agreed well with Fluent predictions. The discrepancy between the mixture area-averaged velocity and velocity calculated from flow meters was less than 10{\%} except for one test case. It is concluded that the combined hot-film and optical approach can be used for water and drop velocity measurements with good accuracy for the flow conditions considered in this study. The Pitottube can also be used for the measurement of mixture velocities for conditions of mixture velocities greater than 0.4 m/s. The small discrepancy between the predictions and experimental data from the present study and literature demonstrated that both instrumentation and CFD simulations have the potential for two-phaseflow investigation and industrial applications.",
keywords = "hot-film probe, dual optical probe, pitot tube, kerosene-water two-phase flow, mixture velocity, CFD simulation",
author = "Faik Hamad and Shuisheng He",
year = "2010",
month = "9",
doi = "10.1016/j.flowmeasinst.2010.03.004",
language = "English",
volume = "21",
pages = "302--311",
journal = "Flow Measurement and Instrumentation",
issn = "0955-5986",
publisher = "Elsevier BV",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Evaluation of hot-film, dual optical and Pitot tube probes for liquid-liquid two-phase flow measurements

AU - Hamad, Faik

AU - He, Shuisheng

PY - 2010/9

Y1 - 2010/9

N2 - An experimental study of kerosene–water upward two-phaseflow in a vertical pipe was carried out using hot-film, dualoptical and Pitottubeprobes to measure the water, kerosene drops and mixture velocities. Experiments were conducted in a vertical pipe of 77.8 mm inner diameter at 4.2 m from the inlet (L/D=54). The tests were carried out for constant superficial water velocities of 0.29, 0.59 and 0.77 m/s (flow rates = 83, 167 and 220 l/min) and volume fractions of 4.2%, 9.2%, 18.6% and 28.2%. The Fluent 6.3.26 was used to model the single and two-phaseflow and to reproduce the results for the experimental study. Two methods were used to evaluate the accuracy of the probes for the measurement of the velocities of water, drops and mixture for two-phaseflow: (i) comparison of measured local velocities with predictions from the CFD simulation; (ii) comparison between the area-averaged velocities calculated from the integration of the local measurements of water, drops and mixture velocities and velocities calculated from flow meters’ measurements. The results for single phaseflow measured using Pitottube and hot-filmprobe agree well with CFD predictions. In the case of two-phaseflow, the water and drops velocities were measured by hot-film and dualopticalprobes respectively. The latter was also used to measure the volume fraction. These three measured parameters were used to calculate the mixture velocity. The Pitottube was also used to measure the mixture velocity by applying the same principle used for single phaseflow velocity. Overall the mixture local velocity measured by Pitottube and that calculated from hot-film and dualopticalprobemeasurements agreed well with Fluent predictions. The discrepancy between the mixture area-averaged velocity and velocity calculated from flow meters was less than 10% except for one test case. It is concluded that the combined hot-film and optical approach can be used for water and drop velocity measurements with good accuracy for the flow conditions considered in this study. The Pitottube can also be used for the measurement of mixture velocities for conditions of mixture velocities greater than 0.4 m/s. The small discrepancy between the predictions and experimental data from the present study and literature demonstrated that both instrumentation and CFD simulations have the potential for two-phaseflow investigation and industrial applications.

AB - An experimental study of kerosene–water upward two-phaseflow in a vertical pipe was carried out using hot-film, dualoptical and Pitottubeprobes to measure the water, kerosene drops and mixture velocities. Experiments were conducted in a vertical pipe of 77.8 mm inner diameter at 4.2 m from the inlet (L/D=54). The tests were carried out for constant superficial water velocities of 0.29, 0.59 and 0.77 m/s (flow rates = 83, 167 and 220 l/min) and volume fractions of 4.2%, 9.2%, 18.6% and 28.2%. The Fluent 6.3.26 was used to model the single and two-phaseflow and to reproduce the results for the experimental study. Two methods were used to evaluate the accuracy of the probes for the measurement of the velocities of water, drops and mixture for two-phaseflow: (i) comparison of measured local velocities with predictions from the CFD simulation; (ii) comparison between the area-averaged velocities calculated from the integration of the local measurements of water, drops and mixture velocities and velocities calculated from flow meters’ measurements. The results for single phaseflow measured using Pitottube and hot-filmprobe agree well with CFD predictions. In the case of two-phaseflow, the water and drops velocities were measured by hot-film and dualopticalprobes respectively. The latter was also used to measure the volume fraction. These three measured parameters were used to calculate the mixture velocity. The Pitottube was also used to measure the mixture velocity by applying the same principle used for single phaseflow velocity. Overall the mixture local velocity measured by Pitottube and that calculated from hot-film and dualopticalprobemeasurements agreed well with Fluent predictions. The discrepancy between the mixture area-averaged velocity and velocity calculated from flow meters was less than 10% except for one test case. It is concluded that the combined hot-film and optical approach can be used for water and drop velocity measurements with good accuracy for the flow conditions considered in this study. The Pitottube can also be used for the measurement of mixture velocities for conditions of mixture velocities greater than 0.4 m/s. The small discrepancy between the predictions and experimental data from the present study and literature demonstrated that both instrumentation and CFD simulations have the potential for two-phaseflow investigation and industrial applications.

KW - hot-film probe

KW - dual optical probe

KW - pitot tube

KW - kerosene-water two-phase flow

KW - mixture velocity

KW - CFD simulation

U2 - 10.1016/j.flowmeasinst.2010.03.004

DO - 10.1016/j.flowmeasinst.2010.03.004

M3 - Article

VL - 21

SP - 302

EP - 311

JO - Flow Measurement and Instrumentation

JF - Flow Measurement and Instrumentation

SN - 0955-5986

IS - 3

ER -