Examining gender differences in received, provided, and invisible social control

an application of the dual-effects model

Janina Lüscher, Sibylle Ochsner, Nina Knoll, Gertraud Stadler, Rainer Hornung, Urte Scholz

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

5 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The dual-effects model of social control not only assumes that social control leads to better health practices but also arouses psychological distress. However, findings are inconsistent. The present study advances the current literature by examining social control from a dyadic perspective in the context of smoking. In addition, the study examines whether control, continuous smoking abstinence, and affect are differentially related for men and women. Before and three weeks after a self-set quit attempt, we examined 106 smokers (77 men, mean age: 40.67, average number of cigarettes smoked per day: 16.59 [SD=8.52, range=1-40] at baseline and 5.27 [SD=6.97, range=0-40] at follow-up) and their nonsmoking heterosexual partners, assessing received and provided control, continuous abstinence, and affect. With regard to smoker's affective reactions, partner's provided control was related to an increase in positive and to a decrease in negative affect, but only for female smokers. Moreover, the greater the discrepancy between smoker received and partner's provided control was the more positive affect increased and the more negative affect decreased, but again only for female smokers. These findings demonstrate that female smokers' well-being was raised over time if they were not aware of the control attempts of their nonsmoking partners, indicating positive effects of invisible social control. This study's results emphasize the importance of applying a dyadic perspective and taking gender differences in the dual-effects model of social control into account.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)678-694
Number of pages17
JournalAnxiety, Stress and Coping
Volume27
Issue number6
Early online date19 Mar 2014
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2014

Fingerprint

Smoking
Heterosexuality
Tobacco Products
Invisible
Social Control
Gender Differences
Psychology
Health
Psychological Distress
Positive Affect
Affective
Well-being

Keywords

  • provided social control
  • received social control
  • invisible social control
  • smoking
  • gender
  • dual-effects model of social control

Cite this

Examining gender differences in received, provided, and invisible social control : an application of the dual-effects model. / Lüscher, Janina; Ochsner, Sibylle; Knoll, Nina; Stadler, Gertraud; Hornung, Rainer; Scholz, Urte.

In: Anxiety, Stress and Coping, Vol. 27, No. 6, 2014, p. 678-694.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Lüscher, Janina ; Ochsner, Sibylle ; Knoll, Nina ; Stadler, Gertraud ; Hornung, Rainer ; Scholz, Urte. / Examining gender differences in received, provided, and invisible social control : an application of the dual-effects model. In: Anxiety, Stress and Coping. 2014 ; Vol. 27, No. 6. pp. 678-694.
@article{b33c50edadec4f8a8278087a0c98a1d5,
title = "Examining gender differences in received, provided, and invisible social control: an application of the dual-effects model",
abstract = "The dual-effects model of social control not only assumes that social control leads to better health practices but also arouses psychological distress. However, findings are inconsistent. The present study advances the current literature by examining social control from a dyadic perspective in the context of smoking. In addition, the study examines whether control, continuous smoking abstinence, and affect are differentially related for men and women. Before and three weeks after a self-set quit attempt, we examined 106 smokers (77 men, mean age: 40.67, average number of cigarettes smoked per day: 16.59 [SD=8.52, range=1-40] at baseline and 5.27 [SD=6.97, range=0-40] at follow-up) and their nonsmoking heterosexual partners, assessing received and provided control, continuous abstinence, and affect. With regard to smoker's affective reactions, partner's provided control was related to an increase in positive and to a decrease in negative affect, but only for female smokers. Moreover, the greater the discrepancy between smoker received and partner's provided control was the more positive affect increased and the more negative affect decreased, but again only for female smokers. These findings demonstrate that female smokers' well-being was raised over time if they were not aware of the control attempts of their nonsmoking partners, indicating positive effects of invisible social control. This study's results emphasize the importance of applying a dyadic perspective and taking gender differences in the dual-effects model of social control into account.",
keywords = "provided social control, received social control, invisible social control, smoking, gender, dual-effects model of social control",
author = "Janina L{\"u}scher and Sibylle Ochsner and Nina Knoll and Gertraud Stadler and Rainer Hornung and Urte Scholz",
note = "The first author is funded by the Swiss National Science Foundation [grant number PP00P1_133632/1]. This project was funded by the Swiss National Science Foundation [grantnumber 100014_124516].",
year = "2014",
doi = "10.1080/10615806.2014.892585",
language = "English",
volume = "27",
pages = "678--694",
journal = "Anxiety, Stress and Coping",
issn = "1061-5806",
publisher = "Taylor & Francis",
number = "6",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Examining gender differences in received, provided, and invisible social control

T2 - an application of the dual-effects model

AU - Lüscher, Janina

AU - Ochsner, Sibylle

AU - Knoll, Nina

AU - Stadler, Gertraud

AU - Hornung, Rainer

AU - Scholz, Urte

N1 - The first author is funded by the Swiss National Science Foundation [grant number PP00P1_133632/1]. This project was funded by the Swiss National Science Foundation [grantnumber 100014_124516].

PY - 2014

Y1 - 2014

N2 - The dual-effects model of social control not only assumes that social control leads to better health practices but also arouses psychological distress. However, findings are inconsistent. The present study advances the current literature by examining social control from a dyadic perspective in the context of smoking. In addition, the study examines whether control, continuous smoking abstinence, and affect are differentially related for men and women. Before and three weeks after a self-set quit attempt, we examined 106 smokers (77 men, mean age: 40.67, average number of cigarettes smoked per day: 16.59 [SD=8.52, range=1-40] at baseline and 5.27 [SD=6.97, range=0-40] at follow-up) and their nonsmoking heterosexual partners, assessing received and provided control, continuous abstinence, and affect. With regard to smoker's affective reactions, partner's provided control was related to an increase in positive and to a decrease in negative affect, but only for female smokers. Moreover, the greater the discrepancy between smoker received and partner's provided control was the more positive affect increased and the more negative affect decreased, but again only for female smokers. These findings demonstrate that female smokers' well-being was raised over time if they were not aware of the control attempts of their nonsmoking partners, indicating positive effects of invisible social control. This study's results emphasize the importance of applying a dyadic perspective and taking gender differences in the dual-effects model of social control into account.

AB - The dual-effects model of social control not only assumes that social control leads to better health practices but also arouses psychological distress. However, findings are inconsistent. The present study advances the current literature by examining social control from a dyadic perspective in the context of smoking. In addition, the study examines whether control, continuous smoking abstinence, and affect are differentially related for men and women. Before and three weeks after a self-set quit attempt, we examined 106 smokers (77 men, mean age: 40.67, average number of cigarettes smoked per day: 16.59 [SD=8.52, range=1-40] at baseline and 5.27 [SD=6.97, range=0-40] at follow-up) and their nonsmoking heterosexual partners, assessing received and provided control, continuous abstinence, and affect. With regard to smoker's affective reactions, partner's provided control was related to an increase in positive and to a decrease in negative affect, but only for female smokers. Moreover, the greater the discrepancy between smoker received and partner's provided control was the more positive affect increased and the more negative affect decreased, but again only for female smokers. These findings demonstrate that female smokers' well-being was raised over time if they were not aware of the control attempts of their nonsmoking partners, indicating positive effects of invisible social control. This study's results emphasize the importance of applying a dyadic perspective and taking gender differences in the dual-effects model of social control into account.

KW - provided social control

KW - received social control

KW - invisible social control

KW - smoking

KW - gender

KW - dual-effects model of social control

U2 - 10.1080/10615806.2014.892585

DO - 10.1080/10615806.2014.892585

M3 - Article

VL - 27

SP - 678

EP - 694

JO - Anxiety, Stress and Coping

JF - Anxiety, Stress and Coping

SN - 1061-5806

IS - 6

ER -