Fixational saccades during grating detection and discrimination

Sara Spotorno, Guillaume S. Masson, Anna Montagnini

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

7 Citations (Scopus)
3 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

We investigated the patterns of fixational saccades in human observers performing two classical perceptual tasks: grating detection and discrimination. First, participants were asked to detect a vertical or tilted grating with one of three spatial frequencies and one of four luminance contrast levels. In the second experiment, participants had to discriminate the spatial frequency of two supra-threshold gratings. The gratings were always embedded in additive, high- or low-contrast pink noise. We observed that the patterns of fixational saccades were highly idiosyncratic among participants. Moreover, during the grating detection task, the amplitude and the number of saccades were inversely correlated with stimulus visibility. We did not find a systematic relationship between saccade parameters and grating frequency, apart from a slight decrease of saccade amplitude during grating discrimination with higher spatial frequencies. No consistent changes in the number and amplitude of fixational saccades with performance accuracy were reported. Surprisingly, during grating detection, saccade number and amplitude were similar in grating-with-noise and noise-only displays. Grating orientation did not affect substantially saccade direction in either task. The results challenge the idea that, when analyzing low-level spatial properties of visual stimuli, fixational saccades can be adapted in order to extract task-relevant information optimally. Rather, saccadic patterns seem to be overall modulated by task context, stimulus visibility and individual variability.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)105-118
Number of pages14
JournalVision Research
Volume118
Early online date4 Apr 2015
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jan 2016

Fingerprint

Saccades
Noise

Keywords

  • fixational saccades
  • grating detection
  • grating discrimination
  • spatial frequency
  • luminance contrast

Cite this

Fixational saccades during grating detection and discrimination. / Spotorno, Sara; Masson, Guillaume S.; Montagnini, Anna.

In: Vision Research, Vol. 118, 01.2016, p. 105-118.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Spotorno, Sara ; Masson, Guillaume S. ; Montagnini, Anna. / Fixational saccades during grating detection and discrimination. In: Vision Research. 2016 ; Vol. 118. pp. 105-118.
@article{895e8daf305641839f0fe23180697bef,
title = "Fixational saccades during grating detection and discrimination",
abstract = "We investigated the patterns of fixational saccades in human observers performing two classical perceptual tasks: grating detection and discrimination. First, participants were asked to detect a vertical or tilted grating with one of three spatial frequencies and one of four luminance contrast levels. In the second experiment, participants had to discriminate the spatial frequency of two supra-threshold gratings. The gratings were always embedded in additive, high- or low-contrast pink noise. We observed that the patterns of fixational saccades were highly idiosyncratic among participants. Moreover, during the grating detection task, the amplitude and the number of saccades were inversely correlated with stimulus visibility. We did not find a systematic relationship between saccade parameters and grating frequency, apart from a slight decrease of saccade amplitude during grating discrimination with higher spatial frequencies. No consistent changes in the number and amplitude of fixational saccades with performance accuracy were reported. Surprisingly, during grating detection, saccade number and amplitude were similar in grating-with-noise and noise-only displays. Grating orientation did not affect substantially saccade direction in either task. The results challenge the idea that, when analyzing low-level spatial properties of visual stimuli, fixational saccades can be adapted in order to extract task-relevant information optimally. Rather, saccadic patterns seem to be overall modulated by task context, stimulus visibility and individual variability.",
keywords = "fixational saccades, grating detection, grating discrimination, spatial frequency, luminance contrast",
author = "Sara Spotorno and Masson, {Guillaume S.} and Anna Montagnini",
note = "Acknowledgments This research was funded by French ANR Grant ANR-2010-BLAN-1432-01 (Visafix). The authors would like to thank Dr. Laurent Madelain and Dr. Claudio Simoncini for the helpful discussions during the development of the study.",
year = "2016",
month = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.visres.2015.03.013",
language = "English",
volume = "118",
pages = "105--118",
journal = "Vision Research",
issn = "0042-6989",
publisher = "Elsevier",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Fixational saccades during grating detection and discrimination

AU - Spotorno, Sara

AU - Masson, Guillaume S.

AU - Montagnini, Anna

N1 - Acknowledgments This research was funded by French ANR Grant ANR-2010-BLAN-1432-01 (Visafix). The authors would like to thank Dr. Laurent Madelain and Dr. Claudio Simoncini for the helpful discussions during the development of the study.

PY - 2016/1

Y1 - 2016/1

N2 - We investigated the patterns of fixational saccades in human observers performing two classical perceptual tasks: grating detection and discrimination. First, participants were asked to detect a vertical or tilted grating with one of three spatial frequencies and one of four luminance contrast levels. In the second experiment, participants had to discriminate the spatial frequency of two supra-threshold gratings. The gratings were always embedded in additive, high- or low-contrast pink noise. We observed that the patterns of fixational saccades were highly idiosyncratic among participants. Moreover, during the grating detection task, the amplitude and the number of saccades were inversely correlated with stimulus visibility. We did not find a systematic relationship between saccade parameters and grating frequency, apart from a slight decrease of saccade amplitude during grating discrimination with higher spatial frequencies. No consistent changes in the number and amplitude of fixational saccades with performance accuracy were reported. Surprisingly, during grating detection, saccade number and amplitude were similar in grating-with-noise and noise-only displays. Grating orientation did not affect substantially saccade direction in either task. The results challenge the idea that, when analyzing low-level spatial properties of visual stimuli, fixational saccades can be adapted in order to extract task-relevant information optimally. Rather, saccadic patterns seem to be overall modulated by task context, stimulus visibility and individual variability.

AB - We investigated the patterns of fixational saccades in human observers performing two classical perceptual tasks: grating detection and discrimination. First, participants were asked to detect a vertical or tilted grating with one of three spatial frequencies and one of four luminance contrast levels. In the second experiment, participants had to discriminate the spatial frequency of two supra-threshold gratings. The gratings were always embedded in additive, high- or low-contrast pink noise. We observed that the patterns of fixational saccades were highly idiosyncratic among participants. Moreover, during the grating detection task, the amplitude and the number of saccades were inversely correlated with stimulus visibility. We did not find a systematic relationship between saccade parameters and grating frequency, apart from a slight decrease of saccade amplitude during grating discrimination with higher spatial frequencies. No consistent changes in the number and amplitude of fixational saccades with performance accuracy were reported. Surprisingly, during grating detection, saccade number and amplitude were similar in grating-with-noise and noise-only displays. Grating orientation did not affect substantially saccade direction in either task. The results challenge the idea that, when analyzing low-level spatial properties of visual stimuli, fixational saccades can be adapted in order to extract task-relevant information optimally. Rather, saccadic patterns seem to be overall modulated by task context, stimulus visibility and individual variability.

KW - fixational saccades

KW - grating detection

KW - grating discrimination

KW - spatial frequency

KW - luminance contrast

U2 - 10.1016/j.visres.2015.03.013

DO - 10.1016/j.visres.2015.03.013

M3 - Article

C2 - 25849759

VL - 118

SP - 105

EP - 118

JO - Vision Research

JF - Vision Research

SN - 0042-6989

ER -