Getting off the carousel: Exploring the wicked problem of curriculum reform

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

6 Citations (Scopus)
8 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

INTRODUCTION: Making substantial changes to the form and delivery of medical education is challenging. One reason for this may be misalignment between existing conceptualizations of curricula and curriculum reform in medical education, with the former perceived as 'complex' yet the latter as linear. Reframing curriculum reform as a process-driven, complex entity may enhance the possibility of change. To explore the utility of this approach, we carried out an exploratory case study of curriculum reform in a real-life context.

METHODS: We used a qualitative case study approach. Data were collected from 17 interviews with senior faculty involved in curriculum reform in one medical school plus document analysis of approximately 50 documents and files, to provide background, context, and aid triangulation.

RESULTS: Data coding and analysis was initially inductive, using thematic analysis. After themes were identified, we applied the 'wicked problem' framework to highlight aspects of the data. This paper focuses on two main analytic themes. First, that multiple players hold different views and values in relation to curriculum reform, resulting in various influences on the process and outcomes of reform. Second, 'solutions' generate consequences which go beyond the anticipated advantages of curriculum reform.

DISCUSSION: This is the first empirical study of curriculum reform in medical education which uses the wicked problem framework to conceptually illuminate the complex processes which occur in relation to reform. Those involved in reform must be reflective and attentive to the possibility that persistent and emerging challenges may be a result of wicked problems.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)337-343
Number of pages7
JournalPerspectives on medical education
Volume6
Issue number5
Early online date26 Sep 2017
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Oct 2017

Fingerprint

Curriculum
Medical Education
Medical Schools
Interviews

Keywords

  • Wicked Problem
  • Curriculum Reform
  • Case Study
  • Undergraduate Medical Education

Cite this

Getting off the carousel : Exploring the wicked problem of curriculum reform. / Hawick, Lorraine; Cleland, Jennifer; Kitto, Simon.

In: Perspectives on medical education, Vol. 6, No. 5, 10.2017, p. 337-343.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{b947b75344f2458ead56f6f4f2c1ec9a,
title = "Getting off the carousel: Exploring the wicked problem of curriculum reform",
abstract = "INTRODUCTION: Making substantial changes to the form and delivery of medical education is challenging. One reason for this may be misalignment between existing conceptualizations of curricula and curriculum reform in medical education, with the former perceived as 'complex' yet the latter as linear. Reframing curriculum reform as a process-driven, complex entity may enhance the possibility of change. To explore the utility of this approach, we carried out an exploratory case study of curriculum reform in a real-life context.METHODS: We used a qualitative case study approach. Data were collected from 17 interviews with senior faculty involved in curriculum reform in one medical school plus document analysis of approximately 50 documents and files, to provide background, context, and aid triangulation.RESULTS: Data coding and analysis was initially inductive, using thematic analysis. After themes were identified, we applied the 'wicked problem' framework to highlight aspects of the data. This paper focuses on two main analytic themes. First, that multiple players hold different views and values in relation to curriculum reform, resulting in various influences on the process and outcomes of reform. Second, 'solutions' generate consequences which go beyond the anticipated advantages of curriculum reform.DISCUSSION: This is the first empirical study of curriculum reform in medical education which uses the wicked problem framework to conceptually illuminate the complex processes which occur in relation to reform. Those involved in reform must be reflective and attentive to the possibility that persistent and emerging challenges may be a result of wicked problems.",
keywords = "Wicked Problem, Curriculum Reform, Case Study, Undergraduate Medical Education",
author = "Lorraine Hawick and Jennifer Cleland and Simon Kitto",
note = "Acknowledgements The authors wish to thank all participants in this study. Our thanks to the School of Medicine where this study was undertaken for supporting LH’s doctoral research program. Our thanks to Alan Bleakley for his advice and guidance when planning the interview component of this study.",
year = "2017",
month = "10",
doi = "10.1007/s40037-017-0371-z",
language = "English",
volume = "6",
pages = "337--343",
journal = "Perspectives on medical education",
issn = "2212-2761",
publisher = "Bohn Stafleu van Loghum",
number = "5",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Getting off the carousel

T2 - Exploring the wicked problem of curriculum reform

AU - Hawick, Lorraine

AU - Cleland, Jennifer

AU - Kitto, Simon

N1 - Acknowledgements The authors wish to thank all participants in this study. Our thanks to the School of Medicine where this study was undertaken for supporting LH’s doctoral research program. Our thanks to Alan Bleakley for his advice and guidance when planning the interview component of this study.

PY - 2017/10

Y1 - 2017/10

N2 - INTRODUCTION: Making substantial changes to the form and delivery of medical education is challenging. One reason for this may be misalignment between existing conceptualizations of curricula and curriculum reform in medical education, with the former perceived as 'complex' yet the latter as linear. Reframing curriculum reform as a process-driven, complex entity may enhance the possibility of change. To explore the utility of this approach, we carried out an exploratory case study of curriculum reform in a real-life context.METHODS: We used a qualitative case study approach. Data were collected from 17 interviews with senior faculty involved in curriculum reform in one medical school plus document analysis of approximately 50 documents and files, to provide background, context, and aid triangulation.RESULTS: Data coding and analysis was initially inductive, using thematic analysis. After themes were identified, we applied the 'wicked problem' framework to highlight aspects of the data. This paper focuses on two main analytic themes. First, that multiple players hold different views and values in relation to curriculum reform, resulting in various influences on the process and outcomes of reform. Second, 'solutions' generate consequences which go beyond the anticipated advantages of curriculum reform.DISCUSSION: This is the first empirical study of curriculum reform in medical education which uses the wicked problem framework to conceptually illuminate the complex processes which occur in relation to reform. Those involved in reform must be reflective and attentive to the possibility that persistent and emerging challenges may be a result of wicked problems.

AB - INTRODUCTION: Making substantial changes to the form and delivery of medical education is challenging. One reason for this may be misalignment between existing conceptualizations of curricula and curriculum reform in medical education, with the former perceived as 'complex' yet the latter as linear. Reframing curriculum reform as a process-driven, complex entity may enhance the possibility of change. To explore the utility of this approach, we carried out an exploratory case study of curriculum reform in a real-life context.METHODS: We used a qualitative case study approach. Data were collected from 17 interviews with senior faculty involved in curriculum reform in one medical school plus document analysis of approximately 50 documents and files, to provide background, context, and aid triangulation.RESULTS: Data coding and analysis was initially inductive, using thematic analysis. After themes were identified, we applied the 'wicked problem' framework to highlight aspects of the data. This paper focuses on two main analytic themes. First, that multiple players hold different views and values in relation to curriculum reform, resulting in various influences on the process and outcomes of reform. Second, 'solutions' generate consequences which go beyond the anticipated advantages of curriculum reform.DISCUSSION: This is the first empirical study of curriculum reform in medical education which uses the wicked problem framework to conceptually illuminate the complex processes which occur in relation to reform. Those involved in reform must be reflective and attentive to the possibility that persistent and emerging challenges may be a result of wicked problems.

KW - Wicked Problem

KW - Curriculum Reform

KW - Case Study

KW - Undergraduate Medical Education

U2 - 10.1007/s40037-017-0371-z

DO - 10.1007/s40037-017-0371-z

M3 - Article

C2 - 28952049

VL - 6

SP - 337

EP - 343

JO - Perspectives on medical education

JF - Perspectives on medical education

SN - 2212-2761

IS - 5

ER -