Goldman and Siegel on the epistemic aims of education

Alessia Marabini, Luca Moretti

Research output: Working paper

Abstract

Philosophers have claimed that education aims at fostering disparate epistemic goals. In this paper we focus on an important segment of this debate involving conversation between Alvin Goldman and Harvey Siegel. Goldman claims that education is essentially aimed at producing true beliefs. Siegel contends that education is essentially aimed at fostering both true beliefs and, independently, critical thinking and rational belief. Although we find Siegel’s position intuitively more plausible than Goldman’s, we also find Siegel’s defence of it wanting. We suggest novel argumentative strategies that draw on Siegel’s own arguments but look to us more promising.
Original languageEnglish
PublisherPhilPapers
Publication statusSubmitted - 2018

Fingerprint

Education
Critical Thinking
Philosopher

Keywords

  • epistemic aims of education
  • epistemic aims
  • epistemic rationality
  • critical thinking testimony
  • Alvin Goldman
  • Harvey Siegel

Cite this

Goldman and Siegel on the epistemic aims of education. / Marabini, Alessia ; Moretti, Luca.

PhilPapers, 2018.

Research output: Working paper

@techreport{ad8a6ebd9e194fb0a540a88b3447e3ac,
title = "Goldman and Siegel on the epistemic aims of education",
abstract = "Philosophers have claimed that education aims at fostering disparate epistemic goals. In this paper we focus on an important segment of this debate involving conversation between Alvin Goldman and Harvey Siegel. Goldman claims that education is essentially aimed at producing true beliefs. Siegel contends that education is essentially aimed at fostering both true beliefs and, independently, critical thinking and rational belief. Although we find Siegel’s position intuitively more plausible than Goldman’s, we also find Siegel’s defence of it wanting. We suggest novel argumentative strategies that draw on Siegel’s own arguments but look to us more promising.",
keywords = "epistemic aims of education, epistemic aims, epistemic rationality, critical thinking testimony, Alvin Goldman, Harvey Siegel",
author = "Alessia Marabini and Luca Moretti",
year = "2018",
language = "English",
publisher = "PhilPapers",
type = "WorkingPaper",
institution = "PhilPapers",

}

TY - UNPB

T1 - Goldman and Siegel on the epistemic aims of education

AU - Marabini, Alessia

AU - Moretti, Luca

PY - 2018

Y1 - 2018

N2 - Philosophers have claimed that education aims at fostering disparate epistemic goals. In this paper we focus on an important segment of this debate involving conversation between Alvin Goldman and Harvey Siegel. Goldman claims that education is essentially aimed at producing true beliefs. Siegel contends that education is essentially aimed at fostering both true beliefs and, independently, critical thinking and rational belief. Although we find Siegel’s position intuitively more plausible than Goldman’s, we also find Siegel’s defence of it wanting. We suggest novel argumentative strategies that draw on Siegel’s own arguments but look to us more promising.

AB - Philosophers have claimed that education aims at fostering disparate epistemic goals. In this paper we focus on an important segment of this debate involving conversation between Alvin Goldman and Harvey Siegel. Goldman claims that education is essentially aimed at producing true beliefs. Siegel contends that education is essentially aimed at fostering both true beliefs and, independently, critical thinking and rational belief. Although we find Siegel’s position intuitively more plausible than Goldman’s, we also find Siegel’s defence of it wanting. We suggest novel argumentative strategies that draw on Siegel’s own arguments but look to us more promising.

KW - epistemic aims of education

KW - epistemic aims

KW - epistemic rationality

KW - critical thinking testimony

KW - Alvin Goldman

KW - Harvey Siegel

M3 - Working paper

BT - Goldman and Siegel on the epistemic aims of education

PB - PhilPapers

ER -