Grasping what is graspable: Evidence from visual form agnosia

R. D. McIntosh, H. C. Dijkerman, Mark Arwyn Mon-Williams, A. D. Milner

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    34 Citations (Scopus)

    Abstract

    Patient DF has profound visual form agnosia. Despite this, she has no problem adjusting her finger-thumb grip aperture to the width of objects when reaching to grasp them. In a previous study, however, she was found to have great difficulty in scaling her grip aperture when attempting to grasp a transparent disc through two holes cut into it. This problem was attributed to a putative difference between the visual processing of size and distance in the brain, whereby DF retained the capacity for processing object size but not the separation between distinct elements such as holes. In the present study we have tested this idea more directly, and found no evidence to support such a distinction. Nonetheless, we replicated our earlier finding that DF is unable to produce normal prehension movements when attempting to grasp transparent stimuli by placing her digits into holes. We suggest that, whilst some simple objects offer themselves directly to the dorsal stream for grasping, an intact ventral stream is required to respond appropriately to more complex stimuli.

    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)695-702
    Number of pages7
    JournalCortex
    Volume40
    Publication statusPublished - 2004

    Keywords

    • agnosia
    • size
    • visuomotor
    • grasping
    • distance
    • PATIENT
    • DISSOCIATION
    • ORIENTATION
    • PERCEPTION
    • PATTERN

    Cite this

    McIntosh, R. D., Dijkerman, H. C., Mon-Williams, M. A., & Milner, A. D. (2004). Grasping what is graspable: Evidence from visual form agnosia. Cortex, 40, 695-702.

    Grasping what is graspable: Evidence from visual form agnosia. / McIntosh, R. D.; Dijkerman, H. C.; Mon-Williams, Mark Arwyn; Milner, A. D.

    In: Cortex, Vol. 40, 2004, p. 695-702.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    McIntosh, RD, Dijkerman, HC, Mon-Williams, MA & Milner, AD 2004, 'Grasping what is graspable: Evidence from visual form agnosia', Cortex, vol. 40, pp. 695-702.
    McIntosh RD, Dijkerman HC, Mon-Williams MA, Milner AD. Grasping what is graspable: Evidence from visual form agnosia. Cortex. 2004;40:695-702.
    McIntosh, R. D. ; Dijkerman, H. C. ; Mon-Williams, Mark Arwyn ; Milner, A. D. / Grasping what is graspable: Evidence from visual form agnosia. In: Cortex. 2004 ; Vol. 40. pp. 695-702.
    @article{e8974a131fe24a969a17ad8122a2416f,
    title = "Grasping what is graspable: Evidence from visual form agnosia",
    abstract = "Patient DF has profound visual form agnosia. Despite this, she has no problem adjusting her finger-thumb grip aperture to the width of objects when reaching to grasp them. In a previous study, however, she was found to have great difficulty in scaling her grip aperture when attempting to grasp a transparent disc through two holes cut into it. This problem was attributed to a putative difference between the visual processing of size and distance in the brain, whereby DF retained the capacity for processing object size but not the separation between distinct elements such as holes. In the present study we have tested this idea more directly, and found no evidence to support such a distinction. Nonetheless, we replicated our earlier finding that DF is unable to produce normal prehension movements when attempting to grasp transparent stimuli by placing her digits into holes. We suggest that, whilst some simple objects offer themselves directly to the dorsal stream for grasping, an intact ventral stream is required to respond appropriately to more complex stimuli.",
    keywords = "agnosia, size, visuomotor, grasping, distance, PATIENT, DISSOCIATION, ORIENTATION, PERCEPTION, PATTERN",
    author = "McIntosh, {R. D.} and Dijkerman, {H. C.} and Mon-Williams, {Mark Arwyn} and Milner, {A. D.}",
    year = "2004",
    language = "English",
    volume = "40",
    pages = "695--702",
    journal = "Cortex",
    issn = "0010-9452",
    publisher = "Masson SpA",

    }

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Grasping what is graspable: Evidence from visual form agnosia

    AU - McIntosh, R. D.

    AU - Dijkerman, H. C.

    AU - Mon-Williams, Mark Arwyn

    AU - Milner, A. D.

    PY - 2004

    Y1 - 2004

    N2 - Patient DF has profound visual form agnosia. Despite this, she has no problem adjusting her finger-thumb grip aperture to the width of objects when reaching to grasp them. In a previous study, however, she was found to have great difficulty in scaling her grip aperture when attempting to grasp a transparent disc through two holes cut into it. This problem was attributed to a putative difference between the visual processing of size and distance in the brain, whereby DF retained the capacity for processing object size but not the separation between distinct elements such as holes. In the present study we have tested this idea more directly, and found no evidence to support such a distinction. Nonetheless, we replicated our earlier finding that DF is unable to produce normal prehension movements when attempting to grasp transparent stimuli by placing her digits into holes. We suggest that, whilst some simple objects offer themselves directly to the dorsal stream for grasping, an intact ventral stream is required to respond appropriately to more complex stimuli.

    AB - Patient DF has profound visual form agnosia. Despite this, she has no problem adjusting her finger-thumb grip aperture to the width of objects when reaching to grasp them. In a previous study, however, she was found to have great difficulty in scaling her grip aperture when attempting to grasp a transparent disc through two holes cut into it. This problem was attributed to a putative difference between the visual processing of size and distance in the brain, whereby DF retained the capacity for processing object size but not the separation between distinct elements such as holes. In the present study we have tested this idea more directly, and found no evidence to support such a distinction. Nonetheless, we replicated our earlier finding that DF is unable to produce normal prehension movements when attempting to grasp transparent stimuli by placing her digits into holes. We suggest that, whilst some simple objects offer themselves directly to the dorsal stream for grasping, an intact ventral stream is required to respond appropriately to more complex stimuli.

    KW - agnosia

    KW - size

    KW - visuomotor

    KW - grasping

    KW - distance

    KW - PATIENT

    KW - DISSOCIATION

    KW - ORIENTATION

    KW - PERCEPTION

    KW - PATTERN

    M3 - Article

    VL - 40

    SP - 695

    EP - 702

    JO - Cortex

    JF - Cortex

    SN - 0010-9452

    ER -