Guidelines 2.0: systematic development of a comprehensive checklist for a successful guideline enterprise

Holger J Schünemann, Wojtek Wiercioch, Itziar Etxeandia, Maicon Falavigna, Nancy Santesso, Reem Mustafa, Matthew Ventresca, Romina Brignardello-Petersen, Kaja-Triin Laisaar, Sérgio Kowalski, Tejan Baldeh, Yuan Zhang, Ulla Raid, Ignacio Neumann, Susan L Norris, Judith Thornton, Robin Harbour, Shaun Treweek, Gordon Guyatt, Pablo Alonso-CoelloMarge Reinap, Jan Brozek, Andrew Oxman, Elie A Akl

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

176 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

BACKGROUND: Although several tools to evaluate the credibility of health care guidelines exist, guidance on practical steps for developing guidelines is lacking. We systematically compiled a comprehensive checklist of items linked to relevant resources and tools that guideline developers could consider, without the expectation that every guideline would address each item.

METHODS: We searched data sources, including manuals of international guideline developers, literature on guidelines for guidelines (with a focus on methodology reports from international and national agencies, and professional societies) and recent articles providing systematic guidance. We reviewed these sources in duplicate, extracted items for the checklist using a sensitive approach and developed overarching topics relevant to guidelines. In an iterative process, we reviewed items for duplication and omissions and involved experts in guideline development for revisions and suggestions for items to be added.

RESULTS: We developed a checklist with 18 topics and 146 items and a webpage to facilitate its use by guideline developers. The topics and included items cover all stages of the guideline enterprise, from the planning and formulation of guidelines, to their implementation and evaluation. The final checklist includes links to training materials as well as resources with suggested methodology for applying the items.

INTERPRETATION: The checklist will serve as a resource for guideline developers. Consideration of items on the checklist will support the development, implementation and evaluation of guidelines. We will use crowdsourcing to revise the checklist and keep it up to date.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)E123-142
Number of pages20
JournalCanadian Medical Association Journal
Volume186
Issue number3
Early online date16 Dec 2013
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 18 Feb 2014

Fingerprint

Checklist
Guidelines
Crowdsourcing
International Agencies
Information Storage and Retrieval

Keywords

  • Checklist
  • Data Collection
  • Evidence-Based Medicine
  • Humans
  • Practice Guidelines as Topic
  • Statistics as Topic

Cite this

Schünemann, H. J., Wiercioch, W., Etxeandia, I., Falavigna, M., Santesso, N., Mustafa, R., ... Akl, E. A. (2014). Guidelines 2.0: systematic development of a comprehensive checklist for a successful guideline enterprise. Canadian Medical Association Journal, 186(3), E123-142. https://doi.org/10.1503/cmaj.131237

Guidelines 2.0 : systematic development of a comprehensive checklist for a successful guideline enterprise. / Schünemann, Holger J; Wiercioch, Wojtek; Etxeandia, Itziar; Falavigna, Maicon; Santesso, Nancy; Mustafa, Reem; Ventresca, Matthew; Brignardello-Petersen, Romina; Laisaar, Kaja-Triin; Kowalski, Sérgio; Baldeh, Tejan; Zhang, Yuan; Raid, Ulla; Neumann, Ignacio; Norris, Susan L; Thornton, Judith; Harbour, Robin; Treweek, Shaun; Guyatt, Gordon; Alonso-Coello, Pablo; Reinap, Marge; Brozek, Jan; Oxman, Andrew; Akl, Elie A.

In: Canadian Medical Association Journal, Vol. 186, No. 3, 18.02.2014, p. E123-142.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Schünemann, HJ, Wiercioch, W, Etxeandia, I, Falavigna, M, Santesso, N, Mustafa, R, Ventresca, M, Brignardello-Petersen, R, Laisaar, K-T, Kowalski, S, Baldeh, T, Zhang, Y, Raid, U, Neumann, I, Norris, SL, Thornton, J, Harbour, R, Treweek, S, Guyatt, G, Alonso-Coello, P, Reinap, M, Brozek, J, Oxman, A & Akl, EA 2014, 'Guidelines 2.0: systematic development of a comprehensive checklist for a successful guideline enterprise', Canadian Medical Association Journal, vol. 186, no. 3, pp. E123-142. https://doi.org/10.1503/cmaj.131237
Schünemann, Holger J ; Wiercioch, Wojtek ; Etxeandia, Itziar ; Falavigna, Maicon ; Santesso, Nancy ; Mustafa, Reem ; Ventresca, Matthew ; Brignardello-Petersen, Romina ; Laisaar, Kaja-Triin ; Kowalski, Sérgio ; Baldeh, Tejan ; Zhang, Yuan ; Raid, Ulla ; Neumann, Ignacio ; Norris, Susan L ; Thornton, Judith ; Harbour, Robin ; Treweek, Shaun ; Guyatt, Gordon ; Alonso-Coello, Pablo ; Reinap, Marge ; Brozek, Jan ; Oxman, Andrew ; Akl, Elie A. / Guidelines 2.0 : systematic development of a comprehensive checklist for a successful guideline enterprise. In: Canadian Medical Association Journal. 2014 ; Vol. 186, No. 3. pp. E123-142.
@article{af98302013f04f5b83b1bd3b6238a9f2,
title = "Guidelines 2.0: systematic development of a comprehensive checklist for a successful guideline enterprise",
abstract = "BACKGROUND: Although several tools to evaluate the credibility of health care guidelines exist, guidance on practical steps for developing guidelines is lacking. We systematically compiled a comprehensive checklist of items linked to relevant resources and tools that guideline developers could consider, without the expectation that every guideline would address each item.METHODS: We searched data sources, including manuals of international guideline developers, literature on guidelines for guidelines (with a focus on methodology reports from international and national agencies, and professional societies) and recent articles providing systematic guidance. We reviewed these sources in duplicate, extracted items for the checklist using a sensitive approach and developed overarching topics relevant to guidelines. In an iterative process, we reviewed items for duplication and omissions and involved experts in guideline development for revisions and suggestions for items to be added.RESULTS: We developed a checklist with 18 topics and 146 items and a webpage to facilitate its use by guideline developers. The topics and included items cover all stages of the guideline enterprise, from the planning and formulation of guidelines, to their implementation and evaluation. The final checklist includes links to training materials as well as resources with suggested methodology for applying the items.INTERPRETATION: The checklist will serve as a resource for guideline developers. Consideration of items on the checklist will support the development, implementation and evaluation of guidelines. We will use crowdsourcing to revise the checklist and keep it up to date.",
keywords = "Checklist, Data Collection, Evidence-Based Medicine, Humans, Practice Guidelines as Topic, Statistics as Topic",
author = "Sch{\"u}nemann, {Holger J} and Wojtek Wiercioch and Itziar Etxeandia and Maicon Falavigna and Nancy Santesso and Reem Mustafa and Matthew Ventresca and Romina Brignardello-Petersen and Kaja-Triin Laisaar and S{\'e}rgio Kowalski and Tejan Baldeh and Yuan Zhang and Ulla Raid and Ignacio Neumann and Norris, {Susan L} and Judith Thornton and Robin Harbour and Shaun Treweek and Gordon Guyatt and Pablo Alonso-Coello and Marge Reinap and Jan Brozek and Andrew Oxman and Akl, {Elie A}",
year = "2014",
month = "2",
day = "18",
doi = "10.1503/cmaj.131237",
language = "English",
volume = "186",
pages = "E123--142",
journal = "Canadian Medical Association Journal",
issn = "0820-3946",
publisher = "Canadian Medical Association",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Guidelines 2.0

T2 - systematic development of a comprehensive checklist for a successful guideline enterprise

AU - Schünemann, Holger J

AU - Wiercioch, Wojtek

AU - Etxeandia, Itziar

AU - Falavigna, Maicon

AU - Santesso, Nancy

AU - Mustafa, Reem

AU - Ventresca, Matthew

AU - Brignardello-Petersen, Romina

AU - Laisaar, Kaja-Triin

AU - Kowalski, Sérgio

AU - Baldeh, Tejan

AU - Zhang, Yuan

AU - Raid, Ulla

AU - Neumann, Ignacio

AU - Norris, Susan L

AU - Thornton, Judith

AU - Harbour, Robin

AU - Treweek, Shaun

AU - Guyatt, Gordon

AU - Alonso-Coello, Pablo

AU - Reinap, Marge

AU - Brozek, Jan

AU - Oxman, Andrew

AU - Akl, Elie A

PY - 2014/2/18

Y1 - 2014/2/18

N2 - BACKGROUND: Although several tools to evaluate the credibility of health care guidelines exist, guidance on practical steps for developing guidelines is lacking. We systematically compiled a comprehensive checklist of items linked to relevant resources and tools that guideline developers could consider, without the expectation that every guideline would address each item.METHODS: We searched data sources, including manuals of international guideline developers, literature on guidelines for guidelines (with a focus on methodology reports from international and national agencies, and professional societies) and recent articles providing systematic guidance. We reviewed these sources in duplicate, extracted items for the checklist using a sensitive approach and developed overarching topics relevant to guidelines. In an iterative process, we reviewed items for duplication and omissions and involved experts in guideline development for revisions and suggestions for items to be added.RESULTS: We developed a checklist with 18 topics and 146 items and a webpage to facilitate its use by guideline developers. The topics and included items cover all stages of the guideline enterprise, from the planning and formulation of guidelines, to their implementation and evaluation. The final checklist includes links to training materials as well as resources with suggested methodology for applying the items.INTERPRETATION: The checklist will serve as a resource for guideline developers. Consideration of items on the checklist will support the development, implementation and evaluation of guidelines. We will use crowdsourcing to revise the checklist and keep it up to date.

AB - BACKGROUND: Although several tools to evaluate the credibility of health care guidelines exist, guidance on practical steps for developing guidelines is lacking. We systematically compiled a comprehensive checklist of items linked to relevant resources and tools that guideline developers could consider, without the expectation that every guideline would address each item.METHODS: We searched data sources, including manuals of international guideline developers, literature on guidelines for guidelines (with a focus on methodology reports from international and national agencies, and professional societies) and recent articles providing systematic guidance. We reviewed these sources in duplicate, extracted items for the checklist using a sensitive approach and developed overarching topics relevant to guidelines. In an iterative process, we reviewed items for duplication and omissions and involved experts in guideline development for revisions and suggestions for items to be added.RESULTS: We developed a checklist with 18 topics and 146 items and a webpage to facilitate its use by guideline developers. The topics and included items cover all stages of the guideline enterprise, from the planning and formulation of guidelines, to their implementation and evaluation. The final checklist includes links to training materials as well as resources with suggested methodology for applying the items.INTERPRETATION: The checklist will serve as a resource for guideline developers. Consideration of items on the checklist will support the development, implementation and evaluation of guidelines. We will use crowdsourcing to revise the checklist and keep it up to date.

KW - Checklist

KW - Data Collection

KW - Evidence-Based Medicine

KW - Humans

KW - Practice Guidelines as Topic

KW - Statistics as Topic

U2 - 10.1503/cmaj.131237

DO - 10.1503/cmaj.131237

M3 - Article

C2 - 24344144

VL - 186

SP - E123-142

JO - Canadian Medical Association Journal

JF - Canadian Medical Association Journal

SN - 0820-3946

IS - 3

ER -