Handling uncertainty: An extension of DL-lite with subjective logic

Jhonatan Garcia, Jeff Z. Pan, Achille Fokoue, Katia Sycara, Yuqing Tang, Federico Cerutti

Research output: Contribution to journalAbstract

Abstract

Data in real world applications is often subject to some kind of uncertainty, which can be due to incompleteness, unreliability or inconsistency. This poses a great challenge for ontology-based data access (OBDA) applications, which are expected to provide a meaningful answers to queries, even under uncertain domains. Several extensions of classical OBDA systems has been proposed to address this problem, with probabilistic, possibilistic, and fuzzy OBDA being the most relevant ones. However, these extensions present some limitations with respect to their applicability. Probabilistic OBDA deal only with categorical assertions, possibilistic logic is better suited to make a ranking of axioms, and fuzzy OBDA addresses the problem of modelling vagueness, rather than uncertainty. In this paper we propose Subjective DL-Lite (SDL-Lite), an extension of DL-Lite with Subjective Logic. Subjective DL-Lite allows us to model uncertainty in the data through the application of opinions, which encapsulate our degrees of belief, disbelief and uncertainty for each given assertion. We explore the semantics of Subjective DL-Lite, clarify the main differences with respect to its classical DL-Lite counterpart, and construct a canonical model of the ontology by means of a chase that will serve as the foundation for a future construction of an OBDA system supporting opinions.

Original languageEnglish
Number of pages12
JournalCEUR Workshop Proceedings
Volume1350
Publication statusPublished - 2015
Event28th International Workshop on Description Logics: DL 2015 - Athens, Greece
Duration: 7 Jun 201510 Jun 2015
http://dl.kr.org/dl2015/

Fingerprint

Ontology
Uncertainty
Semantics

Keywords

  • Description logics
  • OBDA
  • Query answering
  • Subjective logic

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Computer Science(all)

Cite this

Garcia, J., Pan, J. Z., Fokoue, A., Sycara, K., Tang, Y., & Cerutti, F. (2015). Handling uncertainty: An extension of DL-lite with subjective logic. CEUR Workshop Proceedings, 1350.

Handling uncertainty : An extension of DL-lite with subjective logic. / Garcia, Jhonatan; Pan, Jeff Z.; Fokoue, Achille; Sycara, Katia; Tang, Yuqing; Cerutti, Federico.

In: CEUR Workshop Proceedings, Vol. 1350, 2015.

Research output: Contribution to journalAbstract

Garcia, J, Pan, JZ, Fokoue, A, Sycara, K, Tang, Y & Cerutti, F 2015, 'Handling uncertainty: An extension of DL-lite with subjective logic' CEUR Workshop Proceedings, vol. 1350.
Garcia, Jhonatan ; Pan, Jeff Z. ; Fokoue, Achille ; Sycara, Katia ; Tang, Yuqing ; Cerutti, Federico. / Handling uncertainty : An extension of DL-lite with subjective logic. In: CEUR Workshop Proceedings. 2015 ; Vol. 1350.
@article{8cc55a6be4f74139bfa8710cbcd78ea1,
title = "Handling uncertainty: An extension of DL-lite with subjective logic",
abstract = "Data in real world applications is often subject to some kind of uncertainty, which can be due to incompleteness, unreliability or inconsistency. This poses a great challenge for ontology-based data access (OBDA) applications, which are expected to provide a meaningful answers to queries, even under uncertain domains. Several extensions of classical OBDA systems has been proposed to address this problem, with probabilistic, possibilistic, and fuzzy OBDA being the most relevant ones. However, these extensions present some limitations with respect to their applicability. Probabilistic OBDA deal only with categorical assertions, possibilistic logic is better suited to make a ranking of axioms, and fuzzy OBDA addresses the problem of modelling vagueness, rather than uncertainty. In this paper we propose Subjective DL-Lite (SDL-Lite), an extension of DL-Lite with Subjective Logic. Subjective DL-Lite allows us to model uncertainty in the data through the application of opinions, which encapsulate our degrees of belief, disbelief and uncertainty for each given assertion. We explore the semantics of Subjective DL-Lite, clarify the main differences with respect to its classical DL-Lite counterpart, and construct a canonical model of the ontology by means of a chase that will serve as the foundation for a future construction of an OBDA system supporting opinions.",
keywords = "Description logics, OBDA, Query answering, Subjective logic",
author = "Jhonatan Garcia and Pan, {Jeff Z.} and Achille Fokoue and Katia Sycara and Yuqing Tang and Federico Cerutti",
year = "2015",
language = "English",
volume = "1350",
journal = "CEUR Workshop Proceedings",
issn = "1613-0073",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Handling uncertainty

T2 - An extension of DL-lite with subjective logic

AU - Garcia, Jhonatan

AU - Pan, Jeff Z.

AU - Fokoue, Achille

AU - Sycara, Katia

AU - Tang, Yuqing

AU - Cerutti, Federico

PY - 2015

Y1 - 2015

N2 - Data in real world applications is often subject to some kind of uncertainty, which can be due to incompleteness, unreliability or inconsistency. This poses a great challenge for ontology-based data access (OBDA) applications, which are expected to provide a meaningful answers to queries, even under uncertain domains. Several extensions of classical OBDA systems has been proposed to address this problem, with probabilistic, possibilistic, and fuzzy OBDA being the most relevant ones. However, these extensions present some limitations with respect to their applicability. Probabilistic OBDA deal only with categorical assertions, possibilistic logic is better suited to make a ranking of axioms, and fuzzy OBDA addresses the problem of modelling vagueness, rather than uncertainty. In this paper we propose Subjective DL-Lite (SDL-Lite), an extension of DL-Lite with Subjective Logic. Subjective DL-Lite allows us to model uncertainty in the data through the application of opinions, which encapsulate our degrees of belief, disbelief and uncertainty for each given assertion. We explore the semantics of Subjective DL-Lite, clarify the main differences with respect to its classical DL-Lite counterpart, and construct a canonical model of the ontology by means of a chase that will serve as the foundation for a future construction of an OBDA system supporting opinions.

AB - Data in real world applications is often subject to some kind of uncertainty, which can be due to incompleteness, unreliability or inconsistency. This poses a great challenge for ontology-based data access (OBDA) applications, which are expected to provide a meaningful answers to queries, even under uncertain domains. Several extensions of classical OBDA systems has been proposed to address this problem, with probabilistic, possibilistic, and fuzzy OBDA being the most relevant ones. However, these extensions present some limitations with respect to their applicability. Probabilistic OBDA deal only with categorical assertions, possibilistic logic is better suited to make a ranking of axioms, and fuzzy OBDA addresses the problem of modelling vagueness, rather than uncertainty. In this paper we propose Subjective DL-Lite (SDL-Lite), an extension of DL-Lite with Subjective Logic. Subjective DL-Lite allows us to model uncertainty in the data through the application of opinions, which encapsulate our degrees of belief, disbelief and uncertainty for each given assertion. We explore the semantics of Subjective DL-Lite, clarify the main differences with respect to its classical DL-Lite counterpart, and construct a canonical model of the ontology by means of a chase that will serve as the foundation for a future construction of an OBDA system supporting opinions.

KW - Description logics

KW - OBDA

KW - Query answering

KW - Subjective logic

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84992623002&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Abstract

VL - 1350

JO - CEUR Workshop Proceedings

JF - CEUR Workshop Proceedings

SN - 1613-0073

ER -