Harvest time optimisation for combustion quality of different miscanthus genotypes across Europe

Yasir Iqbal, Andreas Kiesel, Moritz Wagner, Christopher Nunn, Olena Kalinina, Astley Francis St John Hastings, John C. Clifton-Brown, Iris Lewandowski

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

6 Citations (Scopus)
4 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Delayed harvest can improve the quality of miscanthus biomass for combustion and enhance the long-term sustainability of the crop, despite accompanying yield losses. The aim of this study is to identify the optimal harvesting time, which can deliver improved biomass quality for combustion of novel miscanthus genotypes at various sites across Europe, without high yield losses and without compromising their environmental performance. The relevant field trials were established as part of the European project OPTIMISC with 15 genotypes at six sites across Europe. For this study, the five highest yielding genotypes from each germplasm group and three sites with contrasting climatic conditions (Stuttgart/Germany, Adana/Turkey and Moscow/Russia) were selected for assessment. The biomass samples were collected between August and March (depending on site) and subjected to mineral and ash content analysis. At Stuttgart, the delay in harvesting time led to a significant variation in combustion quality characteristics, such as N content (0.64-0.21%), ash content (5.15-2.60%) and ash sintering index (1.30-0.20). At Adana, the delay in harvesting time decreased the N content from 0.62 to 0.23%, ash content from 10.63 to 3.84% and sintering index from 0.54 to 0.07. At Moscow, the impact of delay in harvesting was not significant, except for N, Mg and ash sintering index. Overall, a delay in harvesting time improved the combustion quality characteristics of each genotype, but at the expense of yield. Yield losses of up to 49% in Stuttgart and Adana and 21% for Moscow were recorded, with variations between genotypes and sites. The harvesting time also affected nutrient offtake, which in turn influences the long-term environmental performance of the crop. The highest N, P and K offtakes were recorded at Stuttgart for each harvesting time except for final harvest (March), where Moscow had the highest N offtake. This study describes the three criteria (biomass quality, yield losses, nutrient offtake) for determining the ideal harvesting time, which gives the best compromise between dry matter yields and biomass quality characteristics without negatively affecting the environmental performance of the crop.
Original languageEnglish
Article number727
JournalFrontiers in plant science
Volume8
Early online date19 Apr 2017
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 10 May 2017

Fingerprint

Miscanthus
combustion
genotype
nutrient offtake
ash content
biomass
crops
Russia
mineral content
field experimentation
germplasm
Turkey (country)
Germany

Keywords

  • miscanthus
  • harvesting time
  • genotype
  • combustion quality
  • yield loss
  • nutrient offtake

Cite this

Harvest time optimisation for combustion quality of different miscanthus genotypes across Europe. / Iqbal, Yasir; Kiesel, Andreas; Wagner, Moritz; Nunn, Christopher; Kalinina, Olena; Hastings, Astley Francis St John; Clifton-Brown, John C.; Lewandowski, Iris.

In: Frontiers in plant science, Vol. 8, 727, 10.05.2017.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Iqbal, Yasir ; Kiesel, Andreas ; Wagner, Moritz ; Nunn, Christopher ; Kalinina, Olena ; Hastings, Astley Francis St John ; Clifton-Brown, John C. ; Lewandowski, Iris. / Harvest time optimisation for combustion quality of different miscanthus genotypes across Europe. In: Frontiers in plant science. 2017 ; Vol. 8.
@article{4433223400b74e4e85278afb908c6fb8,
title = "Harvest time optimisation for combustion quality of different miscanthus genotypes across Europe",
abstract = "Delayed harvest can improve the quality of miscanthus biomass for combustion and enhance the long-term sustainability of the crop, despite accompanying yield losses. The aim of this study is to identify the optimal harvesting time, which can deliver improved biomass quality for combustion of novel miscanthus genotypes at various sites across Europe, without high yield losses and without compromising their environmental performance. The relevant field trials were established as part of the European project OPTIMISC with 15 genotypes at six sites across Europe. For this study, the five highest yielding genotypes from each germplasm group and three sites with contrasting climatic conditions (Stuttgart/Germany, Adana/Turkey and Moscow/Russia) were selected for assessment. The biomass samples were collected between August and March (depending on site) and subjected to mineral and ash content analysis. At Stuttgart, the delay in harvesting time led to a significant variation in combustion quality characteristics, such as N content (0.64-0.21{\%}), ash content (5.15-2.60{\%}) and ash sintering index (1.30-0.20). At Adana, the delay in harvesting time decreased the N content from 0.62 to 0.23{\%}, ash content from 10.63 to 3.84{\%} and sintering index from 0.54 to 0.07. At Moscow, the impact of delay in harvesting was not significant, except for N, Mg and ash sintering index. Overall, a delay in harvesting time improved the combustion quality characteristics of each genotype, but at the expense of yield. Yield losses of up to 49{\%} in Stuttgart and Adana and 21{\%} for Moscow were recorded, with variations between genotypes and sites. The harvesting time also affected nutrient offtake, which in turn influences the long-term environmental performance of the crop. The highest N, P and K offtakes were recorded at Stuttgart for each harvesting time except for final harvest (March), where Moscow had the highest N offtake. This study describes the three criteria (biomass quality, yield losses, nutrient offtake) for determining the ideal harvesting time, which gives the best compromise between dry matter yields and biomass quality characteristics without negatively affecting the environmental performance of the crop.",
keywords = "miscanthus, harvesting time, genotype, combustion quality, yield loss, nutrient offtake",
author = "Yasir Iqbal and Andreas Kiesel and Moritz Wagner and Christopher Nunn and Olena Kalinina and Hastings, {Astley Francis St John} and Clifton-Brown, {John C.} and Iris Lewandowski",
note = "The research work has been carried out as a part of OPTIMISC project, which received funding from the European Union Seventh Framework Programme (FP7/2007-2013) under grant agreement No. 289159. Authors would like to acknowledge all project partners for managing field trials at each site and providing samples. The authors wish to thank Dr. Jens M{\"o}hring for his support during the statistical analysis. Particular thanks go to the staff of the experimental station, Ihinger Hof, especially Thomas Truckses for providing help during field measurements and sample collection. The chemical analysis was supported by Dagmar Mezger and Martin Zahner. The manuscript was edited by Nicole Gaudet.",
year = "2017",
month = "5",
day = "10",
doi = "10.3389/fpls.2017.00727",
language = "English",
volume = "8",
journal = "Frontiers in plant science",
issn = "1664-462X",
publisher = "Frontiers Media S.A.",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Harvest time optimisation for combustion quality of different miscanthus genotypes across Europe

AU - Iqbal, Yasir

AU - Kiesel, Andreas

AU - Wagner, Moritz

AU - Nunn, Christopher

AU - Kalinina, Olena

AU - Hastings, Astley Francis St John

AU - Clifton-Brown, John C.

AU - Lewandowski, Iris

N1 - The research work has been carried out as a part of OPTIMISC project, which received funding from the European Union Seventh Framework Programme (FP7/2007-2013) under grant agreement No. 289159. Authors would like to acknowledge all project partners for managing field trials at each site and providing samples. The authors wish to thank Dr. Jens Möhring for his support during the statistical analysis. Particular thanks go to the staff of the experimental station, Ihinger Hof, especially Thomas Truckses for providing help during field measurements and sample collection. The chemical analysis was supported by Dagmar Mezger and Martin Zahner. The manuscript was edited by Nicole Gaudet.

PY - 2017/5/10

Y1 - 2017/5/10

N2 - Delayed harvest can improve the quality of miscanthus biomass for combustion and enhance the long-term sustainability of the crop, despite accompanying yield losses. The aim of this study is to identify the optimal harvesting time, which can deliver improved biomass quality for combustion of novel miscanthus genotypes at various sites across Europe, without high yield losses and without compromising their environmental performance. The relevant field trials were established as part of the European project OPTIMISC with 15 genotypes at six sites across Europe. For this study, the five highest yielding genotypes from each germplasm group and three sites with contrasting climatic conditions (Stuttgart/Germany, Adana/Turkey and Moscow/Russia) were selected for assessment. The biomass samples were collected between August and March (depending on site) and subjected to mineral and ash content analysis. At Stuttgart, the delay in harvesting time led to a significant variation in combustion quality characteristics, such as N content (0.64-0.21%), ash content (5.15-2.60%) and ash sintering index (1.30-0.20). At Adana, the delay in harvesting time decreased the N content from 0.62 to 0.23%, ash content from 10.63 to 3.84% and sintering index from 0.54 to 0.07. At Moscow, the impact of delay in harvesting was not significant, except for N, Mg and ash sintering index. Overall, a delay in harvesting time improved the combustion quality characteristics of each genotype, but at the expense of yield. Yield losses of up to 49% in Stuttgart and Adana and 21% for Moscow were recorded, with variations between genotypes and sites. The harvesting time also affected nutrient offtake, which in turn influences the long-term environmental performance of the crop. The highest N, P and K offtakes were recorded at Stuttgart for each harvesting time except for final harvest (March), where Moscow had the highest N offtake. This study describes the three criteria (biomass quality, yield losses, nutrient offtake) for determining the ideal harvesting time, which gives the best compromise between dry matter yields and biomass quality characteristics without negatively affecting the environmental performance of the crop.

AB - Delayed harvest can improve the quality of miscanthus biomass for combustion and enhance the long-term sustainability of the crop, despite accompanying yield losses. The aim of this study is to identify the optimal harvesting time, which can deliver improved biomass quality for combustion of novel miscanthus genotypes at various sites across Europe, without high yield losses and without compromising their environmental performance. The relevant field trials were established as part of the European project OPTIMISC with 15 genotypes at six sites across Europe. For this study, the five highest yielding genotypes from each germplasm group and three sites with contrasting climatic conditions (Stuttgart/Germany, Adana/Turkey and Moscow/Russia) were selected for assessment. The biomass samples were collected between August and March (depending on site) and subjected to mineral and ash content analysis. At Stuttgart, the delay in harvesting time led to a significant variation in combustion quality characteristics, such as N content (0.64-0.21%), ash content (5.15-2.60%) and ash sintering index (1.30-0.20). At Adana, the delay in harvesting time decreased the N content from 0.62 to 0.23%, ash content from 10.63 to 3.84% and sintering index from 0.54 to 0.07. At Moscow, the impact of delay in harvesting was not significant, except for N, Mg and ash sintering index. Overall, a delay in harvesting time improved the combustion quality characteristics of each genotype, but at the expense of yield. Yield losses of up to 49% in Stuttgart and Adana and 21% for Moscow were recorded, with variations between genotypes and sites. The harvesting time also affected nutrient offtake, which in turn influences the long-term environmental performance of the crop. The highest N, P and K offtakes were recorded at Stuttgart for each harvesting time except for final harvest (March), where Moscow had the highest N offtake. This study describes the three criteria (biomass quality, yield losses, nutrient offtake) for determining the ideal harvesting time, which gives the best compromise between dry matter yields and biomass quality characteristics without negatively affecting the environmental performance of the crop.

KW - miscanthus

KW - harvesting time

KW - genotype

KW - combustion quality

KW - yield loss

KW - nutrient offtake

U2 - 10.3389/fpls.2017.00727

DO - 10.3389/fpls.2017.00727

M3 - Article

VL - 8

JO - Frontiers in plant science

JF - Frontiers in plant science

SN - 1664-462X

M1 - 727

ER -