How are nitrogen availability, fine-root mass, and nitrogen uptake related empirically? Implications for models and theory

Ray Dybzinski (Corresponding Author), Angelo Kelvakis, John McCabe, Samantha Panock, Kanyarak Anuchitlertchon, Leah Vasarhelyi, M. Luke McCormack, Gordon G. McNickle, Hendrik Poorter, Clare Trinder, Caroline E. Farrior

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Understanding the effects of global change in terrestrial communities requires an understanding of how limiting resources interact with plant traits to affect productivity. Here, we focus on nitrogen and ask whether plant community nitrogen uptake rate is determined (a) by nitrogen availability alone or (b) by the product of nitrogen availability and fine-root mass. Surprisingly, this is not empirically resolved. We performed controlled microcosm experiments and reanalyzed published pot experiments and field data to determine the relationship between community-level nitrogen uptake rate, nitrogen availability, and fine-root mass for 46 unique combinations of species, nitrogen levels, and growing conditions. We found that plant community nitrogen uptake rate was unaffected by fine-root mass in 63% of cases and saturated with fine-root mass in 29% of cases (92% in total). In contrast, plant community nitrogen uptake rate was clearly affected by nitrogen availability. The results support the idea that although plants may over-proliferate fine roots for individual-level competition, it comes without an increase in community-level nitrogen uptake. The results have implications for the mechanisms included in coupled carbon-nitrogen terrestrial biosphere models (CN-TBMs) and are consistent with CN-TBMs that operate above the individual scale and omit fine-root mass in equations of nitrogen uptake rate but inconsistent with the majority of CN-TBMs, which operate above the individual scale and include fine-root mass in equations of nitrogen uptake rate. For the much smaller number of CN-TBMs that explicitly model individual-based belowground competition for nitrogen, the results suggest that the relative (not absolute) fine-root mass of competing individuals should be included in the equations that determine individual-level nitrogen uptake rates. By providing empirical data to support the assumptions used in CN-TBMs, we put their global climate change predictions on firmer ground.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)885-899
Number of pages15
JournalGlobal Change Biology
Volume25
Issue number3
Early online date6 Jan 2019
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Mar 2019

Fingerprint

fine root
Nitrogen
Availability
nitrogen
biosphere
Carbon
carbon
plant community
individual-based model

Keywords

  • competition
  • dynamic global vegetation model
  • fine roots
  • game theory
  • nitrogen
  • over-proliferation
  • terrestrial biosphere model

Cite this

Dybzinski, R., Kelvakis, A., McCabe, J., Panock, S., Anuchitlertchon, K., Vasarhelyi, L., ... Farrior, C. E. (2019). How are nitrogen availability, fine-root mass, and nitrogen uptake related empirically? Implications for models and theory. Global Change Biology, 25(3), 885-899. https://doi.org/10.1111/gcb.14541

How are nitrogen availability, fine-root mass, and nitrogen uptake related empirically? Implications for models and theory. / Dybzinski, Ray (Corresponding Author); Kelvakis, Angelo; McCabe, John; Panock, Samantha; Anuchitlertchon, Kanyarak; Vasarhelyi, Leah; McCormack, M. Luke; McNickle, Gordon G.; Poorter, Hendrik; Trinder, Clare; Farrior, Caroline E.

In: Global Change Biology, Vol. 25, No. 3, 03.2019, p. 885-899.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Dybzinski, R, Kelvakis, A, McCabe, J, Panock, S, Anuchitlertchon, K, Vasarhelyi, L, McCormack, ML, McNickle, GG, Poorter, H, Trinder, C & Farrior, CE 2019, 'How are nitrogen availability, fine-root mass, and nitrogen uptake related empirically? Implications for models and theory', Global Change Biology, vol. 25, no. 3, pp. 885-899. https://doi.org/10.1111/gcb.14541
Dybzinski, Ray ; Kelvakis, Angelo ; McCabe, John ; Panock, Samantha ; Anuchitlertchon, Kanyarak ; Vasarhelyi, Leah ; McCormack, M. Luke ; McNickle, Gordon G. ; Poorter, Hendrik ; Trinder, Clare ; Farrior, Caroline E. / How are nitrogen availability, fine-root mass, and nitrogen uptake related empirically? Implications for models and theory. In: Global Change Biology. 2019 ; Vol. 25, No. 3. pp. 885-899.
@article{dfd723d2b40c4e88947d9469ef7693cb,
title = "How are nitrogen availability, fine-root mass, and nitrogen uptake related empirically? Implications for models and theory",
abstract = "Understanding the effects of global change in terrestrial communities requires an understanding of how limiting resources interact with plant traits to affect productivity. Here, we focus on nitrogen and ask whether plant community nitrogen uptake rate is determined (a) by nitrogen availability alone or (b) by the product of nitrogen availability and fine-root mass. Surprisingly, this is not empirically resolved. We performed controlled microcosm experiments and reanalyzed published pot experiments and field data to determine the relationship between community-level nitrogen uptake rate, nitrogen availability, and fine-root mass for 46 unique combinations of species, nitrogen levels, and growing conditions. We found that plant community nitrogen uptake rate was unaffected by fine-root mass in 63{\%} of cases and saturated with fine-root mass in 29{\%} of cases (92{\%} in total). In contrast, plant community nitrogen uptake rate was clearly affected by nitrogen availability. The results support the idea that although plants may over-proliferate fine roots for individual-level competition, it comes without an increase in community-level nitrogen uptake. The results have implications for the mechanisms included in coupled carbon-nitrogen terrestrial biosphere models (CN-TBMs) and are consistent with CN-TBMs that operate above the individual scale and omit fine-root mass in equations of nitrogen uptake rate but inconsistent with the majority of CN-TBMs, which operate above the individual scale and include fine-root mass in equations of nitrogen uptake rate. For the much smaller number of CN-TBMs that explicitly model individual-based belowground competition for nitrogen, the results suggest that the relative (not absolute) fine-root mass of competing individuals should be included in the equations that determine individual-level nitrogen uptake rates. By providing empirical data to support the assumptions used in CN-TBMs, we put their global climate change predictions on firmer ground.",
keywords = "competition, dynamic global vegetation model, fine roots, game theory, nitrogen, over-proliferation, terrestrial biosphere model",
author = "Ray Dybzinski and Angelo Kelvakis and John McCabe and Samantha Panock and Kanyarak Anuchitlertchon and Leah Vasarhelyi and McCormack, {M. Luke} and McNickle, {Gordon G.} and Hendrik Poorter and Clare Trinder and Farrior, {Caroline E.}",
note = "We gratefully acknowledge funding from Loyola University Chicago; suggestions for improvement by David Robinson and anonymous peer reviewers; logistical support from K. Erickson; help with maintenance and harvests from O. Urbanski, L. Papaioannou, H. Roudebush, & V. Roudebush; and tissue and substrate analyses from Z. Zhu. The authors have no conflicts of interest to report.",
year = "2019",
month = "3",
doi = "10.1111/gcb.14541",
language = "English",
volume = "25",
pages = "885--899",
journal = "Global Change Biology",
issn = "1354-1013",
publisher = "John Wiley & Sons, Ltd (10.1111)",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - How are nitrogen availability, fine-root mass, and nitrogen uptake related empirically? Implications for models and theory

AU - Dybzinski, Ray

AU - Kelvakis, Angelo

AU - McCabe, John

AU - Panock, Samantha

AU - Anuchitlertchon, Kanyarak

AU - Vasarhelyi, Leah

AU - McCormack, M. Luke

AU - McNickle, Gordon G.

AU - Poorter, Hendrik

AU - Trinder, Clare

AU - Farrior, Caroline E.

N1 - We gratefully acknowledge funding from Loyola University Chicago; suggestions for improvement by David Robinson and anonymous peer reviewers; logistical support from K. Erickson; help with maintenance and harvests from O. Urbanski, L. Papaioannou, H. Roudebush, & V. Roudebush; and tissue and substrate analyses from Z. Zhu. The authors have no conflicts of interest to report.

PY - 2019/3

Y1 - 2019/3

N2 - Understanding the effects of global change in terrestrial communities requires an understanding of how limiting resources interact with plant traits to affect productivity. Here, we focus on nitrogen and ask whether plant community nitrogen uptake rate is determined (a) by nitrogen availability alone or (b) by the product of nitrogen availability and fine-root mass. Surprisingly, this is not empirically resolved. We performed controlled microcosm experiments and reanalyzed published pot experiments and field data to determine the relationship between community-level nitrogen uptake rate, nitrogen availability, and fine-root mass for 46 unique combinations of species, nitrogen levels, and growing conditions. We found that plant community nitrogen uptake rate was unaffected by fine-root mass in 63% of cases and saturated with fine-root mass in 29% of cases (92% in total). In contrast, plant community nitrogen uptake rate was clearly affected by nitrogen availability. The results support the idea that although plants may over-proliferate fine roots for individual-level competition, it comes without an increase in community-level nitrogen uptake. The results have implications for the mechanisms included in coupled carbon-nitrogen terrestrial biosphere models (CN-TBMs) and are consistent with CN-TBMs that operate above the individual scale and omit fine-root mass in equations of nitrogen uptake rate but inconsistent with the majority of CN-TBMs, which operate above the individual scale and include fine-root mass in equations of nitrogen uptake rate. For the much smaller number of CN-TBMs that explicitly model individual-based belowground competition for nitrogen, the results suggest that the relative (not absolute) fine-root mass of competing individuals should be included in the equations that determine individual-level nitrogen uptake rates. By providing empirical data to support the assumptions used in CN-TBMs, we put their global climate change predictions on firmer ground.

AB - Understanding the effects of global change in terrestrial communities requires an understanding of how limiting resources interact with plant traits to affect productivity. Here, we focus on nitrogen and ask whether plant community nitrogen uptake rate is determined (a) by nitrogen availability alone or (b) by the product of nitrogen availability and fine-root mass. Surprisingly, this is not empirically resolved. We performed controlled microcosm experiments and reanalyzed published pot experiments and field data to determine the relationship between community-level nitrogen uptake rate, nitrogen availability, and fine-root mass for 46 unique combinations of species, nitrogen levels, and growing conditions. We found that plant community nitrogen uptake rate was unaffected by fine-root mass in 63% of cases and saturated with fine-root mass in 29% of cases (92% in total). In contrast, plant community nitrogen uptake rate was clearly affected by nitrogen availability. The results support the idea that although plants may over-proliferate fine roots for individual-level competition, it comes without an increase in community-level nitrogen uptake. The results have implications for the mechanisms included in coupled carbon-nitrogen terrestrial biosphere models (CN-TBMs) and are consistent with CN-TBMs that operate above the individual scale and omit fine-root mass in equations of nitrogen uptake rate but inconsistent with the majority of CN-TBMs, which operate above the individual scale and include fine-root mass in equations of nitrogen uptake rate. For the much smaller number of CN-TBMs that explicitly model individual-based belowground competition for nitrogen, the results suggest that the relative (not absolute) fine-root mass of competing individuals should be included in the equations that determine individual-level nitrogen uptake rates. By providing empirical data to support the assumptions used in CN-TBMs, we put their global climate change predictions on firmer ground.

KW - competition

KW - dynamic global vegetation model

KW - fine roots

KW - game theory

KW - nitrogen

KW - over-proliferation

KW - terrestrial biosphere model

UR - http://www.mendeley.com/research/nitrogen-availability-fineroot-mass-nitrogen-uptake-related-empirically-implications-models-theory

U2 - 10.1111/gcb.14541

DO - 10.1111/gcb.14541

M3 - Article

VL - 25

SP - 885

EP - 899

JO - Global Change Biology

JF - Global Change Biology

SN - 1354-1013

IS - 3

ER -