I don’t know what I’m doing. How about you?

Discourse and identity in practitioners dealing with the survivors of childhood sexual abuse

Julian Adrian Randall

Research output: Working paperDiscussion paper

6 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

This research is based on interviews conducted with a voluntary group of health practitioners who care for the adult survivors of childhood sexual abuse in one area of Scotland. This project takes a broadly interpretive approach to the interviews, and examines the processes of sense-making apparent in the scripts of the doctors, community nurse and counsellors who comprise this voluntary Forum. Those interviewed were highly sceptical of traditional medical approaches to dealing with survivors of such abuse, and they all questioned the effectiveness of expert professional knowledge. The research highlights the role of patient disclosure as a key mechanism in the process of their treatment, which is akin to the confessional technology discussed in detail in the work of Michel Foucault. Combined with other medical technologies patient disclosure is revealed as a technique of normalization. In this particular case the experts themselves were engaged in unravelling this process in search of alternative approaches to caring for their patients, which were based on a relationship of equal partnership rather than of expert authority. This research thus begins to illustrate the processes of sense-making and identity formation which exist between professional health care workers and the victims of abuse for whom they care.
Original languageEnglish
PublisherUniversity of Aberdeen
Number of pages42
Publication statusPublished - Jan 2007

Publication series

NameUniversity of Aberdeen Business School Working Paper Series
No.07
Volume2007
ISSN (Print)0143-4543

Fingerprint

sexual violence
childhood
discourse
expert
abuse
medical technology
identity formation
normalization
interview
counselor
nurse
health care
worker
health
knowledge
community
Group

Keywords

  • professional identity
  • Foucault
  • self identity
  • discourse
  • sexual abuse
  • disclosure
  • normalization
  • transformation

Cite this

Randall, J. A. (2007). I don’t know what I’m doing. How about you? Discourse and identity in practitioners dealing with the survivors of childhood sexual abuse. (University of Aberdeen Business School Working Paper Series; Vol. 2007, No. 07). University of Aberdeen.

I don’t know what I’m doing. How about you? Discourse and identity in practitioners dealing with the survivors of childhood sexual abuse. / Randall, Julian Adrian.

University of Aberdeen, 2007. (University of Aberdeen Business School Working Paper Series; Vol. 2007, No. 07).

Research output: Working paperDiscussion paper

Randall, JA 2007 'I don’t know what I’m doing. How about you? Discourse and identity in practitioners dealing with the survivors of childhood sexual abuse' University of Aberdeen Business School Working Paper Series, no. 07, vol. 2007, University of Aberdeen.
Randall JA. I don’t know what I’m doing. How about you? Discourse and identity in practitioners dealing with the survivors of childhood sexual abuse. University of Aberdeen. 2007 Jan. (University of Aberdeen Business School Working Paper Series; 07).
Randall, Julian Adrian. / I don’t know what I’m doing. How about you? Discourse and identity in practitioners dealing with the survivors of childhood sexual abuse. University of Aberdeen, 2007. (University of Aberdeen Business School Working Paper Series; 07).
@techreport{7ea9a2c213aa4906a509b6665b8d03b0,
title = "I don’t know what I’m doing. How about you?: Discourse and identity in practitioners dealing with the survivors of childhood sexual abuse",
abstract = "This research is based on interviews conducted with a voluntary group of health practitioners who care for the adult survivors of childhood sexual abuse in one area of Scotland. This project takes a broadly interpretive approach to the interviews, and examines the processes of sense-making apparent in the scripts of the doctors, community nurse and counsellors who comprise this voluntary Forum. Those interviewed were highly sceptical of traditional medical approaches to dealing with survivors of such abuse, and they all questioned the effectiveness of expert professional knowledge. The research highlights the role of patient disclosure as a key mechanism in the process of their treatment, which is akin to the confessional technology discussed in detail in the work of Michel Foucault. Combined with other medical technologies patient disclosure is revealed as a technique of normalization. In this particular case the experts themselves were engaged in unravelling this process in search of alternative approaches to caring for their patients, which were based on a relationship of equal partnership rather than of expert authority. This research thus begins to illustrate the processes of sense-making and identity formation which exist between professional health care workers and the victims of abuse for whom they care.",
keywords = "professional identity, Foucault, self identity, discourse, sexual abuse, disclosure, normalization, transformation",
author = "Randall, {Julian Adrian}",
year = "2007",
month = "1",
language = "English",
series = "University of Aberdeen Business School Working Paper Series",
publisher = "University of Aberdeen",
number = "07",
type = "WorkingPaper",
institution = "University of Aberdeen",

}

TY - UNPB

T1 - I don’t know what I’m doing. How about you?

T2 - Discourse and identity in practitioners dealing with the survivors of childhood sexual abuse

AU - Randall, Julian Adrian

PY - 2007/1

Y1 - 2007/1

N2 - This research is based on interviews conducted with a voluntary group of health practitioners who care for the adult survivors of childhood sexual abuse in one area of Scotland. This project takes a broadly interpretive approach to the interviews, and examines the processes of sense-making apparent in the scripts of the doctors, community nurse and counsellors who comprise this voluntary Forum. Those interviewed were highly sceptical of traditional medical approaches to dealing with survivors of such abuse, and they all questioned the effectiveness of expert professional knowledge. The research highlights the role of patient disclosure as a key mechanism in the process of their treatment, which is akin to the confessional technology discussed in detail in the work of Michel Foucault. Combined with other medical technologies patient disclosure is revealed as a technique of normalization. In this particular case the experts themselves were engaged in unravelling this process in search of alternative approaches to caring for their patients, which were based on a relationship of equal partnership rather than of expert authority. This research thus begins to illustrate the processes of sense-making and identity formation which exist between professional health care workers and the victims of abuse for whom they care.

AB - This research is based on interviews conducted with a voluntary group of health practitioners who care for the adult survivors of childhood sexual abuse in one area of Scotland. This project takes a broadly interpretive approach to the interviews, and examines the processes of sense-making apparent in the scripts of the doctors, community nurse and counsellors who comprise this voluntary Forum. Those interviewed were highly sceptical of traditional medical approaches to dealing with survivors of such abuse, and they all questioned the effectiveness of expert professional knowledge. The research highlights the role of patient disclosure as a key mechanism in the process of their treatment, which is akin to the confessional technology discussed in detail in the work of Michel Foucault. Combined with other medical technologies patient disclosure is revealed as a technique of normalization. In this particular case the experts themselves were engaged in unravelling this process in search of alternative approaches to caring for their patients, which were based on a relationship of equal partnership rather than of expert authority. This research thus begins to illustrate the processes of sense-making and identity formation which exist between professional health care workers and the victims of abuse for whom they care.

KW - professional identity

KW - Foucault

KW - self identity

KW - discourse

KW - sexual abuse

KW - disclosure

KW - normalization

KW - transformation

M3 - Discussion paper

T3 - University of Aberdeen Business School Working Paper Series

BT - I don’t know what I’m doing. How about you?

PB - University of Aberdeen

ER -