Ice and Concrete: Solid Fluids of Environmental Change

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

5 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Recent environmental changes have sparked off unprecedented dialogues between practitioners of the earth sciences and the humanities - dialogues which defy some of the basic assumptions underpinning western science. However, a gap still persists between natural scientists and scholars in the humanities in their tendency to concentrate respectively on solid matter and fluid meaning. This article seeks to close this gap by paying attention to glacial ice and concrete, materials that often mark the onset and culmination of human history and have been historically regarded as solid fluids. We suggest that ice and concrete are caught in a punctuated understanding of change that turns fluidity and solidity into mutually exclusive properties. The article concludes by comparing this oxymoronic syndrome with the ways the Inuit of West Greenland experience their cryogenic landscapes as nurturing environments in constant becoming.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)19-31
Number of pages13
JournalJournal of Contemporary Archaeology
Volume5
Issue number1
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2018

Fingerprint

environmental change
ice
fluid
Earth science
history
solid matter
material
science

Keywords

  • anthropocene
  • climate change
  • concrete
  • ice
  • solid fluids
  • stratification
  • time

Cite this

Ice and Concrete : Solid Fluids of Environmental Change. / Simonetti, Cristian; Ingold, Timothy.

In: Journal of Contemporary Archaeology, Vol. 5, No. 1, 2018, p. 19-31.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{b15fbc4d981449428ad039408cd4a572,
title = "Ice and Concrete: Solid Fluids of Environmental Change",
abstract = "Recent environmental changes have sparked off unprecedented dialogues between practitioners of the earth sciences and the humanities - dialogues which defy some of the basic assumptions underpinning western science. However, a gap still persists between natural scientists and scholars in the humanities in their tendency to concentrate respectively on solid matter and fluid meaning. This article seeks to close this gap by paying attention to glacial ice and concrete, materials that often mark the onset and culmination of human history and have been historically regarded as solid fluids. We suggest that ice and concrete are caught in a punctuated understanding of change that turns fluidity and solidity into mutually exclusive properties. The article concludes by comparing this oxymoronic syndrome with the ways the Inuit of West Greenland experience their cryogenic landscapes as nurturing environments in constant becoming.",
keywords = "anthropocene, climate change, concrete, ice, solid fluids, stratification, time",
author = "Cristian Simonetti and Timothy Ingold",
note = "The research on which this article is based has been supported by the project Solid Fluids in the Anthropocene: A Transdisciplinary Inquiry into the Archaeological Anthropology of Materials (2015–2018), funded by the British Academy for the Humanities and the Social Sciences under its International Partnership and Mobility Scheme. The research has also been supported by the project Concrete Futures: An Inquiry into Modern Life in the Anthropocene with Materials (2015–2018), funded by Fondo Nacional de Desarrollo Cient{\'i}fico y Tecnol{\'o}gico (FONDECYT), Chile, No. 11150278. We are grateful to the British Academy and to FONDECYT for their support. An earlier version of this article was presented at the workshop “Time of Materials” organized by Gay Hawkins at the University of Western Sydney. We are grateful to Gay for inviting us to contribute to the event, to Juan Francisco Salazar for making our attendance possible and to Guy Keulemans who, at the workshop, provided detailed comments on the version presented there. We extend our gratitude to two anonymous reviewers, whose generous comments, criticism and suggestions also contributed to the development of our argument.",
year = "2018",
doi = "10.1558/jca33371",
language = "English",
volume = "5",
pages = "19--31",
journal = "Journal of Contemporary Archaeology",
issn = "2051-3429",
publisher = "Equinox Publishing Ltd",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Ice and Concrete

T2 - Solid Fluids of Environmental Change

AU - Simonetti, Cristian

AU - Ingold, Timothy

N1 - The research on which this article is based has been supported by the project Solid Fluids in the Anthropocene: A Transdisciplinary Inquiry into the Archaeological Anthropology of Materials (2015–2018), funded by the British Academy for the Humanities and the Social Sciences under its International Partnership and Mobility Scheme. The research has also been supported by the project Concrete Futures: An Inquiry into Modern Life in the Anthropocene with Materials (2015–2018), funded by Fondo Nacional de Desarrollo Científico y Tecnológico (FONDECYT), Chile, No. 11150278. We are grateful to the British Academy and to FONDECYT for their support. An earlier version of this article was presented at the workshop “Time of Materials” organized by Gay Hawkins at the University of Western Sydney. We are grateful to Gay for inviting us to contribute to the event, to Juan Francisco Salazar for making our attendance possible and to Guy Keulemans who, at the workshop, provided detailed comments on the version presented there. We extend our gratitude to two anonymous reviewers, whose generous comments, criticism and suggestions also contributed to the development of our argument.

PY - 2018

Y1 - 2018

N2 - Recent environmental changes have sparked off unprecedented dialogues between practitioners of the earth sciences and the humanities - dialogues which defy some of the basic assumptions underpinning western science. However, a gap still persists between natural scientists and scholars in the humanities in their tendency to concentrate respectively on solid matter and fluid meaning. This article seeks to close this gap by paying attention to glacial ice and concrete, materials that often mark the onset and culmination of human history and have been historically regarded as solid fluids. We suggest that ice and concrete are caught in a punctuated understanding of change that turns fluidity and solidity into mutually exclusive properties. The article concludes by comparing this oxymoronic syndrome with the ways the Inuit of West Greenland experience their cryogenic landscapes as nurturing environments in constant becoming.

AB - Recent environmental changes have sparked off unprecedented dialogues between practitioners of the earth sciences and the humanities - dialogues which defy some of the basic assumptions underpinning western science. However, a gap still persists between natural scientists and scholars in the humanities in their tendency to concentrate respectively on solid matter and fluid meaning. This article seeks to close this gap by paying attention to glacial ice and concrete, materials that often mark the onset and culmination of human history and have been historically regarded as solid fluids. We suggest that ice and concrete are caught in a punctuated understanding of change that turns fluidity and solidity into mutually exclusive properties. The article concludes by comparing this oxymoronic syndrome with the ways the Inuit of West Greenland experience their cryogenic landscapes as nurturing environments in constant becoming.

KW - anthropocene

KW - climate change

KW - concrete

KW - ice

KW - solid fluids

KW - stratification

KW - time

U2 - 10.1558/jca33371

DO - 10.1558/jca33371

M3 - Article

VL - 5

SP - 19

EP - 31

JO - Journal of Contemporary Archaeology

JF - Journal of Contemporary Archaeology

SN - 2051-3429

IS - 1

ER -