Inferring local adaptation from Q(ST)-F(ST) comparisons: neutral genetic and quantitative trait variation in European populations of great snipe

S. A. Saether, P. Fiske, J. A. Kalas, A. Kuresoo, L. Luigujoe, S. B. Piertney, T. Sahlman, J. Hoglund

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

78 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

We applied a phenotypic Q(ST) (P-ST) vs. F-ST approach to study spatial variation in selection among great snipe (Gallinago media) populations in two regions of northern Europe. Morphological divergence between regions was high despite low differentiation in selectively neutral genetic markers, whereas populations within regions showed very little neutral divergence and trait differentiation. Q(ST) > F-ST was robust against altering assumptions about the additive genetic proportions of variance components. The homogenizing effect of gene flow (or a short time available for neutral divergence) has apparently been effectively counterbalanced by differential natural selection, although one trait showed some evidence of being under uniform stabilizing selection. Neutral markers can hence be misleading for identifying evolutionary significant units, and adopting the P-ST-F-ST approach might therefore be valuable when common garden experiments is not an option. We discuss the statistical difficulties of documenting uniform selection as opposed to divergent selection, and the need for estimating measurement error. Instead of only comparing overall Q(ST) and F-ST values, we advocate the use of partial matrix permutation tests to analyse pairwise Q(ST) differences among populations, while statistically controlling for neutral differentiation.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1563-1576
Number of pages14
JournalJournal of Evolutionary Biology
Volume20
Issue number4
Early online date16 Apr 2007
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jul 2007

Keywords

  • conservation units
  • divergent selection
  • local adaptation
  • microsatellite primers
  • partial Mantel test
  • Q(ST)
  • repeatability as heritability
  • lagopus-lagopus-scoticus
  • F-statistics
  • conservation biology
  • morphological traits
  • Gallinago-media
  • life-history
  • marker loci
  • DNA markers
  • differentiation
  • divergence

Cite this

Inferring local adaptation from Q(ST)-F(ST) comparisons : neutral genetic and quantitative trait variation in European populations of great snipe. / Saether, S. A.; Fiske, P.; Kalas, J. A.; Kuresoo, A.; Luigujoe, L.; Piertney, S. B.; Sahlman, T.; Hoglund, J.

In: Journal of Evolutionary Biology, Vol. 20, No. 4, 07.2007, p. 1563-1576.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Saether, S. A. ; Fiske, P. ; Kalas, J. A. ; Kuresoo, A. ; Luigujoe, L. ; Piertney, S. B. ; Sahlman, T. ; Hoglund, J. / Inferring local adaptation from Q(ST)-F(ST) comparisons : neutral genetic and quantitative trait variation in European populations of great snipe. In: Journal of Evolutionary Biology. 2007 ; Vol. 20, No. 4. pp. 1563-1576.
@article{846d70ec74a243f08910c9997b821e73,
title = "Inferring local adaptation from Q(ST)-F(ST) comparisons: neutral genetic and quantitative trait variation in European populations of great snipe",
abstract = "We applied a phenotypic Q(ST) (P-ST) vs. F-ST approach to study spatial variation in selection among great snipe (Gallinago media) populations in two regions of northern Europe. Morphological divergence between regions was high despite low differentiation in selectively neutral genetic markers, whereas populations within regions showed very little neutral divergence and trait differentiation. Q(ST) > F-ST was robust against altering assumptions about the additive genetic proportions of variance components. The homogenizing effect of gene flow (or a short time available for neutral divergence) has apparently been effectively counterbalanced by differential natural selection, although one trait showed some evidence of being under uniform stabilizing selection. Neutral markers can hence be misleading for identifying evolutionary significant units, and adopting the P-ST-F-ST approach might therefore be valuable when common garden experiments is not an option. We discuss the statistical difficulties of documenting uniform selection as opposed to divergent selection, and the need for estimating measurement error. Instead of only comparing overall Q(ST) and F-ST values, we advocate the use of partial matrix permutation tests to analyse pairwise Q(ST) differences among populations, while statistically controlling for neutral differentiation.",
keywords = "conservation units, divergent selection, local adaptation, microsatellite primers, partial Mantel test, Q(ST), repeatability as heritability, lagopus-lagopus-scoticus, F-statistics, conservation biology, morphological traits, Gallinago-media, life-history, marker loci, DNA markers, differentiation, divergence",
author = "Saether, {S. A.} and P. Fiske and Kalas, {J. A.} and A. Kuresoo and L. Luigujoe and Piertney, {S. B.} and T. Sahlman and J. Hoglund",
year = "2007",
month = "7",
doi = "10.1111/j.1420-9101.2007.01328.x",
language = "English",
volume = "20",
pages = "1563--1576",
journal = "Journal of Evolutionary Biology",
issn = "1010-061X",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",
number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Inferring local adaptation from Q(ST)-F(ST) comparisons

T2 - neutral genetic and quantitative trait variation in European populations of great snipe

AU - Saether, S. A.

AU - Fiske, P.

AU - Kalas, J. A.

AU - Kuresoo, A.

AU - Luigujoe, L.

AU - Piertney, S. B.

AU - Sahlman, T.

AU - Hoglund, J.

PY - 2007/7

Y1 - 2007/7

N2 - We applied a phenotypic Q(ST) (P-ST) vs. F-ST approach to study spatial variation in selection among great snipe (Gallinago media) populations in two regions of northern Europe. Morphological divergence between regions was high despite low differentiation in selectively neutral genetic markers, whereas populations within regions showed very little neutral divergence and trait differentiation. Q(ST) > F-ST was robust against altering assumptions about the additive genetic proportions of variance components. The homogenizing effect of gene flow (or a short time available for neutral divergence) has apparently been effectively counterbalanced by differential natural selection, although one trait showed some evidence of being under uniform stabilizing selection. Neutral markers can hence be misleading for identifying evolutionary significant units, and adopting the P-ST-F-ST approach might therefore be valuable when common garden experiments is not an option. We discuss the statistical difficulties of documenting uniform selection as opposed to divergent selection, and the need for estimating measurement error. Instead of only comparing overall Q(ST) and F-ST values, we advocate the use of partial matrix permutation tests to analyse pairwise Q(ST) differences among populations, while statistically controlling for neutral differentiation.

AB - We applied a phenotypic Q(ST) (P-ST) vs. F-ST approach to study spatial variation in selection among great snipe (Gallinago media) populations in two regions of northern Europe. Morphological divergence between regions was high despite low differentiation in selectively neutral genetic markers, whereas populations within regions showed very little neutral divergence and trait differentiation. Q(ST) > F-ST was robust against altering assumptions about the additive genetic proportions of variance components. The homogenizing effect of gene flow (or a short time available for neutral divergence) has apparently been effectively counterbalanced by differential natural selection, although one trait showed some evidence of being under uniform stabilizing selection. Neutral markers can hence be misleading for identifying evolutionary significant units, and adopting the P-ST-F-ST approach might therefore be valuable when common garden experiments is not an option. We discuss the statistical difficulties of documenting uniform selection as opposed to divergent selection, and the need for estimating measurement error. Instead of only comparing overall Q(ST) and F-ST values, we advocate the use of partial matrix permutation tests to analyse pairwise Q(ST) differences among populations, while statistically controlling for neutral differentiation.

KW - conservation units

KW - divergent selection

KW - local adaptation

KW - microsatellite primers

KW - partial Mantel test

KW - Q(ST)

KW - repeatability as heritability

KW - lagopus-lagopus-scoticus

KW - F-statistics

KW - conservation biology

KW - morphological traits

KW - Gallinago-media

KW - life-history

KW - marker loci

KW - DNA markers

KW - differentiation

KW - divergence

U2 - 10.1111/j.1420-9101.2007.01328.x

DO - 10.1111/j.1420-9101.2007.01328.x

M3 - Article

VL - 20

SP - 1563

EP - 1576

JO - Journal of Evolutionary Biology

JF - Journal of Evolutionary Biology

SN - 1010-061X

IS - 4

ER -