Intra-individual measures of association in neuropsychology: inferential methods for comparing a single case with a control or normative sample

John Robertson Crawford, P. H. Garthwaite, A. Venneri, D. C. Howell

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

30 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Performance on some neuropsychological tests is best expressed as an intra-individual measure of association (such as a parametric or non-parametric correlation coefficient or the slope of a regression line). Examples of the use of intra-individual measures of association (IIMAs) include the quantification of performance on tests designed to assess temporal order memory or the accuracy of time estimation. The present paper presents methods for comparing a patient's performance with a control or normative sample when performance is expressed as an IIMA. The methods test if there is a significant difference between a patient's IIMA and those obtained from controls, yield an estimate of the abnormality of the patient's IIMA, and provide confidence limits on the level of abnormality. The methods can be used with normative or control samples of any size and will therefore be of particular relevance to single-case researchers. A method for comparing the difference between a patient's scores on two measures with the differences observed in controls is also described (one or both measures can be IIMAs). All the methods require only summary statistics (rather than the raw data from the normative or control sample); it is hoped that this feature will encourage the development of norms for tasks that use IIMAs to quantify performance. Worked examples of the statistical methods are provided using data from a clinical case and controls. A computer program (for PCs) that implements the methods is described and made available.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)989-1000
Number of pages11
JournalJournal of the International Neuropsychological Society
Volume9
Issue number7
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2003

Keywords

  • single-case methods
  • statistical methods
  • IIMA
  • TEST SCORE DIFFERENCES
  • VISUAL FORM AGNOSIA
  • HUNTINGTONS-DISEASE
  • TEMPORAL-ORDER
  • MEMORY
  • PERCEPTION
  • PATIENT
  • TIME
  • DISSOCIATIONS
  • ORIENTATION

Cite this

@article{59b59d6e809247919bc2d87d7cabb1b3,
title = "Intra-individual measures of association in neuropsychology: inferential methods for comparing a single case with a control or normative sample",
abstract = "Performance on some neuropsychological tests is best expressed as an intra-individual measure of association (such as a parametric or non-parametric correlation coefficient or the slope of a regression line). Examples of the use of intra-individual measures of association (IIMAs) include the quantification of performance on tests designed to assess temporal order memory or the accuracy of time estimation. The present paper presents methods for comparing a patient's performance with a control or normative sample when performance is expressed as an IIMA. The methods test if there is a significant difference between a patient's IIMA and those obtained from controls, yield an estimate of the abnormality of the patient's IIMA, and provide confidence limits on the level of abnormality. The methods can be used with normative or control samples of any size and will therefore be of particular relevance to single-case researchers. A method for comparing the difference between a patient's scores on two measures with the differences observed in controls is also described (one or both measures can be IIMAs). All the methods require only summary statistics (rather than the raw data from the normative or control sample); it is hoped that this feature will encourage the development of norms for tasks that use IIMAs to quantify performance. Worked examples of the statistical methods are provided using data from a clinical case and controls. A computer program (for PCs) that implements the methods is described and made available.",
keywords = "single-case methods, statistical methods, IIMA, TEST SCORE DIFFERENCES, VISUAL FORM AGNOSIA, HUNTINGTONS-DISEASE, TEMPORAL-ORDER, MEMORY, PERCEPTION, PATIENT, TIME, DISSOCIATIONS, ORIENTATION",
author = "Crawford, {John Robertson} and Garthwaite, {P. H.} and A. Venneri and Howell, {D. C.}",
year = "2003",
doi = "10.1017/S1355617703970032",
language = "English",
volume = "9",
pages = "989--1000",
journal = "Journal of the International Neuropsychological Society",
issn = "1355-6177",
publisher = "Cambridge University Press",
number = "7",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Intra-individual measures of association in neuropsychology: inferential methods for comparing a single case with a control or normative sample

AU - Crawford, John Robertson

AU - Garthwaite, P. H.

AU - Venneri, A.

AU - Howell, D. C.

PY - 2003

Y1 - 2003

N2 - Performance on some neuropsychological tests is best expressed as an intra-individual measure of association (such as a parametric or non-parametric correlation coefficient or the slope of a regression line). Examples of the use of intra-individual measures of association (IIMAs) include the quantification of performance on tests designed to assess temporal order memory or the accuracy of time estimation. The present paper presents methods for comparing a patient's performance with a control or normative sample when performance is expressed as an IIMA. The methods test if there is a significant difference between a patient's IIMA and those obtained from controls, yield an estimate of the abnormality of the patient's IIMA, and provide confidence limits on the level of abnormality. The methods can be used with normative or control samples of any size and will therefore be of particular relevance to single-case researchers. A method for comparing the difference between a patient's scores on two measures with the differences observed in controls is also described (one or both measures can be IIMAs). All the methods require only summary statistics (rather than the raw data from the normative or control sample); it is hoped that this feature will encourage the development of norms for tasks that use IIMAs to quantify performance. Worked examples of the statistical methods are provided using data from a clinical case and controls. A computer program (for PCs) that implements the methods is described and made available.

AB - Performance on some neuropsychological tests is best expressed as an intra-individual measure of association (such as a parametric or non-parametric correlation coefficient or the slope of a regression line). Examples of the use of intra-individual measures of association (IIMAs) include the quantification of performance on tests designed to assess temporal order memory or the accuracy of time estimation. The present paper presents methods for comparing a patient's performance with a control or normative sample when performance is expressed as an IIMA. The methods test if there is a significant difference between a patient's IIMA and those obtained from controls, yield an estimate of the abnormality of the patient's IIMA, and provide confidence limits on the level of abnormality. The methods can be used with normative or control samples of any size and will therefore be of particular relevance to single-case researchers. A method for comparing the difference between a patient's scores on two measures with the differences observed in controls is also described (one or both measures can be IIMAs). All the methods require only summary statistics (rather than the raw data from the normative or control sample); it is hoped that this feature will encourage the development of norms for tasks that use IIMAs to quantify performance. Worked examples of the statistical methods are provided using data from a clinical case and controls. A computer program (for PCs) that implements the methods is described and made available.

KW - single-case methods

KW - statistical methods

KW - IIMA

KW - TEST SCORE DIFFERENCES

KW - VISUAL FORM AGNOSIA

KW - HUNTINGTONS-DISEASE

KW - TEMPORAL-ORDER

KW - MEMORY

KW - PERCEPTION

KW - PATIENT

KW - TIME

KW - DISSOCIATIONS

KW - ORIENTATION

U2 - 10.1017/S1355617703970032

DO - 10.1017/S1355617703970032

M3 - Article

VL - 9

SP - 989

EP - 1000

JO - Journal of the International Neuropsychological Society

JF - Journal of the International Neuropsychological Society

SN - 1355-6177

IS - 7

ER -